5 ms·
I'm pretty sure it's not just parties outside of FB, but FB itself is implicated. Out of curiosity I paid to run ads to promote a page associated with a communi
by cmrdporcupine 7y ago
I'm pretty sure it's not just parties outside of FB, but FB itself is implicated. Out of curiosity I paid to run ads to promote a page associated with a community group I'm trying to get up and running ("Ski the Great Lakes"); I paid about $10 to run an ad for a few days. It became clear after a day or two that most of the engagement was fake; many Indian and Egyptian etc. accounts completely outside of the targeted demographic and clearly not real accounts.
A couple months later I'm still getting the odd 'like' from these type of accounts despite not running the campaign.
I didn't seek out any third party promotion, just used FB's own promotion tools.
(I also find it objectionable that one can run ads to promote commercial pages, but there's no way to do so for "groups"; if I want to spend some $$ to expand actual community engagement, for some non-commerical purpose, I can't. I can only promote a business.)
- ec109685 7y agoI don’t think Facebook is paying Indian companies to fake like your ad. Those accounts are probably trying to look legitimate so when they like they’re own pages, the signals are trusted. That said, Facebook should have refunded you obvious non legitimate clicks. Did you report it?
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoThat does sound like a reasonable explanation. It's not worth pursuing a refund for a $10 campaign. I'd be doing that if I was serious about it, though.
- chvid 7y agoThere are probably parts of Facebook that have incentive to ignore fake accounts and trafic, maybe even encourage it, as they are being measured by increases in user count or some raw quantification of user engagement.
- brentis 7y agoYou can set your demographic and still get many foreign likes. They are either using proxy service or something similar. FB does little to discourage and I frankly feel enables to drive revenue. These likes also pollute your account and skew your demographic as they are not sincere. Makes it ultimately difficult to understand your buyer.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoIt's pretty awful; I used to work in ad-tech, and if we had this level of click fraud our customers would have had our head on a platter.
- 867-5309 7y ago"work in" as in "be paid to peddle"
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoNicely put. “used to” is quite reading.
- nhumrich 7y ago"When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." - goodharts law
- hayksaakian 7y agoCan you do a "link to website" ad and then link to your facebook group?
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI did try this and I believe it didn't work for some reason that I can't recall. The recommended practice seemed to be to create a "Page" related to the group and then have a link from the page. But then I need to curate content for both, a total hassle.
- adatavizguy 7y agoIf you use the ad manager, try setting the demographic to people interested in a specific ski magazine, not in 'skiing' as a hobby. Notice how the number of potential audience reach is equal to the number of people who liked 'SKI magazine'. [0] Also, if starting out, limit the geography to the most wealthy of urban centers like within a mile like Foggy Bottom in DC or the Upper East Side of NYC, if college students get all the colleges where skiing is a big interest around Amherst, MA, for example. It's about getting creative to limit the number of the audience to around 20,000 or 30,000 using the interest technique. Only show the ad once per day per user. Use A/B testing with different ads and creatives at a TOTAL of $5 a day for a few days. Take the most effective ads and run them at $10 a day. If you have a page, post stories that will gain traction and interest. Boost them using this specific audience for a $1 or $2 to see if people share them. If not, stop promoting them. If they gain traction invest $20 to help them go viral. Facebook rewards high quality content ads by making them much, much cheaper to run. How do they know? People click and interact with them. Find the ads that people interactive with the most and throw the rest out. It only costs a $1 or 2 to know if they are successful. I keep my account disabled unless I need it to run ads. I feel dirty having reactivated. Im going to disable it again. [0] https://i.imgur.com/VLiou9O.png https://i.imgur.com/VLiou9O.png
- panabee 7y agothanks for sharing! are you available to consult on fb/social media campaigns?
- edisonjoao 7y agolol I need your help
- tacon 7y agoIIRC, you are seeing the backscatter from other people's paid like campaigns. If the agents liked only the pages people paid for, it would be almost trivial to discount and delete. So the agents spray likes over a very broad range of items, mostly unpaid.
- skocznymroczny 7y agoI may be out of the loop on this, but do people actually click on ads, especially FB ads?
- astura 7y agoIf I'm going to click on an ad, it's going to be a Facebook ad. Believe it or not I actually was a patient in a clinical trial I found out about through a Facebook ad.
- buboard 7y ago> but there's no way to do so for "groups"; That is intentional. Facebook had facebook pages, where users could subscribe (like) to be your audience. Then pages became too popular and theyrealized that they were losing potential advertising so they cut down that channel - now you have to pay to reach the subscriber base that you created yourself. They don't want to end up in a similar situation with groups so they are limiting group engagement. FB wants moar money