5 ms·
The truth has a habit of shining through if you are encouraged to keep asking questions and follow up on them. The point is that people are actively discourage
by sillysaurusx 7y ago
The truth has a habit of shining through if you are encouraged to keep asking questions and follow up on them.
The point is that people are actively discouraged from asking questions and following up on them. People lose their careers and livelihoods for asking the wrong sorts of questions.
Truth is no barrier to social backlash. In fact, questions that might be true tend to be the ones that get people the most heated. https://twitter.com/a_centrism/status/1211170458902487042 https://twitter.com/a_centrism/status/1211170458902487042
(I have no stance either way regarding that account, but it's an interesting phenomenon that someone has to basically shroud themselves in anonymity to present certain flavors of scientific research.)
- igorkraw 7y agoOn the specific topic of IQ and scientific racism, the "centrist" position of "just asking questions" has been a cloak for agendas and not caring about the truth for a while now. Exhibit A: https://mobile.twitter.com/Simon_Whitten/status/1173319663322841088 https://mobile.twitter.com/Simon_Whitten/status/117331966332... Exhibit B, what happens when you actually dig into the science behind the most well known peddler of the IQ is real and important, therefore racism is actually not a problem meme https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UBc7qBS1Ujo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UBc7qBS1Ujo Note that I'm not saying there aren't good faith inquiries to be had, but it is really hard to have these with racist agendas being pushed whole claiming "neutral" questions. A few observations that I would like people to keep in mind when looking at these fields: - the people who complain about being "silenced" continue to find funding, public platforms to push their research and in some cases, tenure - the "hard questions not being raised" seem to cluster around the question of differences between "races" and less around whether the concept of race actually makes sense in humans (AFAIK geneticists generally think no), whether these differences might be socially constructed (yes, that's possible. If there are systemic social biases against groups with genetic genes the impacts of these will be 100% explained by the presence of these genes in data, but 0% genetically determined as in biologically determined). And often they are then raised to dismiss concerns about the systematic problems which might have caused the measured problems - scientific racism and shoddy science in this field has a long history, and people carry their misconceptions around. Famous examples are "objective" written IQ tests given to barely literal test subjects, or asking trigonometry questions, Both of which test the schooling of the subjects more than the IQ In an inherently political field of science, denying the political nature and implications of questions being raised and the manner in which they are raised and trying ot claim "objectiveness" is in and of itself a political tactic.
- arethuza 7y agoGreat comment - sometimes I wish that HN would allow you to "spend" karma by upvoting multiple times (mind you - I can see the disadvantages of this as well). You've managed to capture a lot of my own unease about discussions of IQ - not being from the US (and most definitely not being a fan of IQ tests as a concept) I've often felt I was missing out on some other underlying aspect when IQ is discussed.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoA lot of your points are addressed explicitly by that twitter account. I would encourage you to spend some time reading through and examining the extensive studies being presented. Believe me, I would love to dismiss it as a biased person and be done with it. But the truth seems to be nuanced. Suppose tomorrow someone had concrete scientific evidence that climate change wasn't man-made. (It's a thought experiment, so humor me for a moment.) Do you think society at large would accept the evidence? Or would it be more along the lines of society tearing down whoever tried to present it? EDIT: Excellent link, by the way. Thank you for pointing out https://twitter.com/Simon_Whitten/status/1173319663322841088 https://twitter.com/Simon_Whitten/status/1173319663322841088.
- Frondo 7y agoHumoring your thought experiment: yes, I think society would accept the evidence. Lots and lots of people already dismiss the science, claim it's a hoax, or don't want to contend with the inconvenience climate change demands. But...I think you'd continue to see pushback on pollution in general, because living in polluted environments is just terrible. Remember LA in the 80s? Been to any of the SE Asian megacities now? Even if it had zero impact on the future of the planet, reducing emissions is still a laudable goal for the myriad other human costs. Moving away from car-centric lifestyles has a lot of benefits aside from the impact on carbon pollution, like reducing the time spent sitting in cars on gridlocked freeways and city streets. People would still push for the societal changes that reduce auto dependence for those reasons, even if there was zero human cost to carbon-producing transportation there.
- pjc50 7y ago
- pjc50 7y agoWhy did you have to go straight in on "race science"? The history there is that "inherent inferiority" has been used to justify everything from legal discrimination to actual genocide. "Race science" has killed more people than nuclear weapons and poisoned more lives than tetraethyl lead. It's the clearest example where a simple disclaimer like "I'm not racist but" is no more adequate than handling plutonium with kitchen gloves. It needs to be kept in an extremely safety-orientated environment, not splashed all over the internet.
- igorkraw 7y agoPersonal opinion: in general, if people talk about "dissent missing" and "we need more controversial opinions", that's often code for "we need more justification for bigotry". By adopting a perpetually "but we are just asking questions" facade they implicitly a) frame things as "value neutral" when it really isn't and b) place an absurdly high burden of proof before we can finally say "yes in fact racism is wrong"
- jessaustin 7y agoAnother conspiracy theory: obvious morons like the racists are encouraged and publicized in order to discredit those who dissent from the established narrative in real ways that actually challenge TPTB.
- igorkraw 7y agoThink of anything specific?
- jessaustin 7y agoIt's a conspiracy theory, so like you I hesitate to offer any "evidence". If you don't mind pondering some stray thoughts: Racism has taken on an outsized life of its own in USA, but that might have been a contingent feature of our horrific history. Poor whites have been brutal to blacks, but always with the approval and guidance of the wealthy. Their brutality never improved their own lot, but it did distract them... Now in the present, we've created a blameless class of authorities with "dangerous" jobs (well, not compared to pizza delivery) who are deputized to continue the racial brutalization we no longer trust "civilians" to provide. Meanwhile we export our (excess) brutality to brown populations in other lands but somehow this is never viewed through the obvious lens. DoD has "misplaced" trillions of dollars, and we have to learn of it through "alternative" publishers. Somehow, every time a non-white person is harmed without justification, someone makes money on it...
- dang 7y ago"Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21911548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21911548 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]