4 ms·
I did compulsory military service in my European country. I agree that is had a big advantage for me that I met people I would never have met otherwise, and wo
by BurningFrog 7y ago
I did compulsory military service in my European country.
I agree that is had a big advantage for me that I met people I would never have met otherwise, and would not have believed existed.
> Unfortunately it comes with the baggage of you know, killing people
I disagree in two ways.
1) A professional army, which is the realistic alternative, kills people just the same, should war happen.
2) By far the biggest baggage in my view is the involuntary servitude being forced on innocent young kids. That is not worthy a free country to me.
- jimmaswell 7y agoObviously less severe but #2 echoes why gym classes always seemed questionable to me.
- coldtea 7y ago>2) By far the biggest baggage in my view is the involuntary servitude being forced on innocent young kids. That is not worthy a free country to me. (1) the "innocent young kids" are 18+ grown-ass adults. Time to learn the also have some responsibilities towards the society they live in, not just privileges. Paying taxes alone doesn't count. This country they grew up, gone to school, and live in only exists because some people fought hard (and many died) to defend it. (2) It's not "involuntary servitude" it's citizen service. Free countries don't come for free - they're fought to create, to defend, and to keep free.
- MaximumYComb 7y agoThe military isn't "service" like a normal job. You are thrust into a world where rank has an immense amount of power over your entire life and, depending on your chain of command, you can be subject to abuses of power that are state-sanctioned. If the platoon SGT decided he wants to single you out for any possible reason there isn't a lot you can practically do except suffer. I served over 10 years in the military and it was a great decision for my life but I'm somewhat against conscription except in dire times.
- ohithereyou 7y ago>You are thrust into a world where rank has an immense amount of power over your entire life and, depending on your chain of command, you can be subject to abuses of power that are state-sanctioned. That sounds like a microcosm of American society as a whole.
- brosinante 7y ago> and live in only exists because some people fought hard (and many died) to defend it. Nationalism with extra steps.
- coldtea 7y agoThe alternative option would have been slavery with no steps, so there's that. Those speaking derisively of "nationalism" more often than not do so from the vantage point of being within a free nation and having a citizenship. But it's doubly ironic to dismiss nationalism so from the sweet privilege point of being a citizen of the most powerful nations on Earth (e.g. for an American). When you don't have a nation (e.g. a colonised or enslaved people, ethic minority ill treated within an empire or a larger nation run by another ethnicity, immigrant) you very much want to get access to one.
- brosinante 7y agoOf course, there's only two sides, nationalism or slavery.
- ThrowawayR2 7y ago> "Of course, there's only two sides, nationalism or slavery." The choices are staying strong enough to defend the nation or slavery. You could ask the former colonies of the old colonial powers about that. Or the Native Americans. Or the former subjects of the "Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere". Or, more recently, the Ukraine. I am a liberal but denying the importance of the military is just foolishness.
- coldtea 7y agoYes. Did you expect some magical unicorn third option? An idea like: "I'd like to live in a free country but I don't want to ever fight for it, so please don't invade it people, we're all pals and everything right?" only flies when you're already in a strong nation, that others don't dare mess with. And that's because others in your nation didn't let that idea fly in their heads.
- Cougher 7y agoThose "grown-ass adults" are still not old enough to handle an alcoholic beverage, but they're old enough to kill people, get killed, and get physically and psychologically maimed for the diplomatic failures of actual "grown-ass adults". "Paying taxes alone doesn't count." Who said anything about "paying taxes alone"? A role that involves paying taxes also involves working as a participant in society. You can choose to gatekeep about who and what counts if you wish. My gate says that teachers and healthcare workers are far and away a more important societal good. "This country they grew up, gone to school, and live in only exists because some people fought hard (and many died) to defend it." So this land and the people living on it wouldn't exist because people chose to kill other people? Huh. "It's not "involuntary servitude" it's citizen service." Just call it a different name and it's a-ok! "Free countries don't come for free - they're fought to create, to defend, and to keep free." A free country is hardly a free country when it forces you to die for, in most cases, bogus reasons for bogus wars.
- coldtea 7y ago>Those "grown-ass adults" are still not old enough to handle an alcoholic beverage, but they're old enough to kill people, get killed, and get physically and psychologically maimed for the diplomatic failures of actual "grown-ass adults". Well, depends on the country/culture. In several they are allowed to handle an alcoholic beverage just fine too at that age (heck, even slightly younger). And that's just on the level of law. In their own, they manage just fine to consume alcohol, with schemes ranging from an older friend buying, to fake IDs and all that. That said, if a country is under attack, then it doesn't matter whatever one is ready or not. You handle it with whatever you have. Especially if the enemy, or the fate imposed by the enemy, wont spare teenagers either. >Who said anything about "paying taxes alone"? Many people - who think it's their one and only duty as a citizen. I'm not just replying to what has been said, but also to common attitudes and more general themes related to the subject. >So this land and the people living on it wouldn't exist because people chose to kill other people? Huh. A country is not it's land, it's the state, it's sovereignty, it's infrastructure, and so on. So that land would exist, and others would be ruling it, including you. Huh. >A free country is hardly a free country when it forces you to die for, in most cases, bogus reasons for bogus wars. The existence (even prevalence) of bogus wars, doesn't make all war fighting bogus. Usually the bogus wars are on the offense side to begin with. The US didn't have any reason or right to be in the Phillipines or Vietnam for example. But they did have a reason to fight the British. Or the Japanese for that matter.
- rascul 7y ago> (2) It's not "involuntary servitude" it's citizen service. Free countries don't come for free - they're fought to create, to defend, and to keep free. Conscripts are forced to serve in the military. Sounds like slave soldiers to me.
- modo_mario 7y agoToo often it's people glorifying service, combat the military, the police that are so quick to build it down by ramping up fears and a siege mentality in relative safety, militarising the police and limiting freedom in the name of defence. People who uphold freedom as a dogmatic concept, a holy word void of context that can be attacked by outsiders other than some invading nation as if it is not a product of the systems and society that is free.
- Nasrudith 7y agoSounds like slavery and brainwashing with extra steps to me complete with doublethink. It is no accident that "we had to destroy the village to save it" came from a conscript army. Your choice doesn't matter but you have ordained responsibility and not those with power.