2 ms·
Why does law enforcement bother? Can't they just get the info from the telcos?
by Animats 7y ago
Why does law enforcement bother? Can't they just get the info from the telcos?
- giancarlostoro 7y agoThat requires a warrant. Surprised the FCC allows them to tamper with peoples phones tbh. Its all sketchy as heck and flawed if cases are dismissed when they question how the tech works.
- bonestamp2 7y agoThey're probably using it for parallel construction rather than gathering actual evidence for a court case. In other words, it will help them understand how/where to look for evidence that will be admissible in court.
- upofadown 7y agoLast I heard the FCC doesn't. When people complained the devices were not licensed the FCC issued licenses "for emergency use only". That's probably because interference with radio communications is against the law and the FCC as a mere regulator is subject to that law. All rather moot as these things are mostly used for various forms of illegal surveillance. The police have to keep their activity as secret as possible. That includes the fact that they are using them in the first place. This whole issue isn't new. The police normally do, or get others to do, surveillance that is illegal in various ways. The existence of these sorts of devices is an expression of a kind of desperation. Privacy is getting too good. So this might actually be a good thing if this forces a long overdue discussion.
- bb88 7y agoFirst, IANAL. This gets into some interesting legal law. If you are a normal private citizen, wiretapping without the the caller's permission is always a crime. However, The Government can apparently wiretap if: 1. There is an executive order allowing it from the president directly. This may or may not be a national secret. This may or may not be a 4th amendment violation. But if it's a secret, how would you know whether or not it's a 4th amendment violation? 2. There is congressional authorization (by law) in place that allows the government to perform warrantless wiretaps. 3. There is an existing wiretap warrant in effect that allows the recording of an individual or organization's telephones. This is how the FBI, DEA, etc, get their wiretaps typically. 4. A court has held the wiretapping on each of the three instances above was legal. Edited to add: Before 9/11 the government typically respected the 4th Amendment in day to day operations ("Look before you leap"). After 9/11 the respecting the 4th amendment was seen as "pre-9/11 thinking" and forced a shift to early interception ("Easier to ask forgiveness than permission").
- jtbayly 7y agoBut this sub-topic is not about wiretaps. It is about meta-data collection.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoTelcos don't do real time analysis of which IMEI/IMSI are currently connected to a Base Transciever Station. Historical pattern of life data is useful to make a case of where someone has been (or at least their phone), but if you're trying to arrest someone you want to know where the a suspect handset is with almost no latency. I understand the case being made, but these kind of systems work by identifying broadcast messages from handsets by providing a stronger Cell Reselect Offset path and a handful of other parameters that make the phone register with the "tower." It's the same conceptually as if you were broadcasting a low power AM radio signal and the police tuned to your station. Your broadcast signal isn't private. Maybe it should be, but I'm not sure how that would work with GSM/CDMA systems as designed.