5 ms·
>As a 16 year old it was awesome to work alongside other folks of varying ages and nationalities and get to know that other "walks" of life existed. For a cert
by coldtea 7y ago
>As a 16 year old it was awesome to work alongside other folks of varying ages and nationalities and get to know that other "walks" of life existed.
For a certain range of "other walks". Rich and upper middle class kids would seldom work there for example.
Which makes compulsory army service an even better version of the "meet people from all walks of life". It also helps with not over-dramatizing things (think "emo" teens) and generally being lazy (think kids whose parents do everything for them well into their 20s). And most people could do with more discipline, not less.
Unfortunately it comes with the baggage of you know, killing people. That said, in countries not in the offense this (being involved in combat) is almost never the case. Though these countries, with exceptions like Switzerland and Singapore, don't have an army service.
Perhaps an alternative, where people have to spend time with all walks of life, privileges are minimal, and they get to do some good, like e.g. planting trees, helping in crisis situations, etc, would be great.
- jdnenej 7y agoI went to a private school in Australia and had lots of friends from upper class backgrounds and almost all of them had a part time job at McDonald's or a supermarket purely for the experience and so they could have the finest PC gaming parts. They all left before starting uni to focus on study but I think it's untrue that upper class kids do not work at McDonald's. They just don't keep working there for the long term.
- BurningFrog 7y agoHow... do you get fine PC gaming parts from working McD?
- jdnenej 7y ago~$15-$17 AUD per hour and all living expenses paid for by parents. Combined with money you get from relatives on birthdays it becomes pretty easy to buy a new $400 gpu
- BurningFrog 7y agoAh, it's a way to get some spending money. I read it as McD workers somehow got special access to hardware...
- hooande 7y agoThe first criteria for a Third Place (wikipedia link below) is "Occupants of third places have little to no obligation to be there. They are not tied down to the area financially, politically, legally, or otherwise and are free to come and go as they please." Military service has a lot of benefits. But it probably wouldn't serve the same purpose that Mcdonalds does in these communities
- creddit 7y agoI grew up in what would probably be best termed the "upper middle class" and I had a job at McDonald's in high school.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 7y agoI did compulsory military service in my European country. I agree that is had a big advantage for me that I met people I would never have met otherwise, and would not have believed existed. > Unfortunately it comes with the baggage of you know, killing people I disagree in two ways. 1) A professional army, which is the realistic alternative, kills people just the same, should war happen. 2) By far the biggest baggage in my view is the involuntary servitude being forced on innocent young kids. That is not worthy a free country to me.
- jimmaswell 7y agoObviously less severe but #2 echoes why gym classes always seemed questionable to me.
- coldtea 7y ago>2) By far the biggest baggage in my view is the involuntary servitude being forced on innocent young kids. That is not worthy a free country to me. (1) the "innocent young kids" are 18+ grown-ass adults. Time to learn the also have some responsibilities towards the society they live in, not just privileges. Paying taxes alone doesn't count. This country they grew up, gone to school, and live in only exists because some people fought hard (and many died) to defend it. (2) It's not "involuntary servitude" it's citizen service. Free countries don't come for free - they're fought to create, to defend, and to keep free.
- MaximumYComb 7y agoThe military isn't "service" like a normal job. You are thrust into a world where rank has an immense amount of power over your entire life and, depending on your chain of command, you can be subject to abuses of power that are state-sanctioned. If the platoon SGT decided he wants to single you out for any possible reason there isn't a lot you can practically do except suffer. I served over 10 years in the military and it was a great decision for my life but I'm somewhat against conscription except in dire times.
- ohithereyou 7y ago
- toyg 7y agoThey had that in Italy since the early ‘70s, a “National Civil Service” as alternative to compulsory military service for people who “objected to the use of weapons on grounds of conscience”. It was a somewhat-punitive regime (18 months vs the 12 of military service, often with little choice about the organisation to serve, and basically unpaid). The range of activities was very wide, from menial tasks in offices and libraries to pretty hard labor in healthcare. As with all compulsory experiences, some people loved it, some hated it. Somehow it still exists, despite military service having been abolished more than 15 years ago. I have no idea why one would ever ask to join, but Italy being Italy, there is probably some bureaucratic reason for organisations to shove volunteers under that umbrella to get free money from the state.
- viraptor 7y ago> where people have to spend time That should never be the case. There's enough bad things happening to people forced to be in some environment. Let's not create more of them. Yes, those environments may be useful in many ways. But if you can't get away from potential abuse, they're not worth it.