5 ms·
On a side note - why are bank apis so sht? Would love a clean read only way to http api my 3 banks. I don't even care if the security is rubbish for read only.
by Havoc 7y ago
On a side note - why are bank apis so sht?
Would love a clean read only way to http api my 3 banks. I don't even care if the security is rubbish for read only. Csv imports are bullshit. There is no reason why this can't be live and clean
So hard to keep track of things when it's spread over multiple banks & jurisdictions
- erichurkman 7y agoIf you don't mind a third party having access to your bank, you can use Plaid. Last I knew they supported free accounts with basic balance + transaction support and the first 100 accounts were free. I've definitely seen some home spun personal finance apps using Plaid for free.
- Havoc 7y ago>If you don't mind a third party having access to your bank, you can use Plaid I'm down with read only access. Full access.. Fk off But even that is a shit show. Eg a major card provider might push a api... But sorry not in your jurisdiction..not EU so you don't get EU benefits As best as I can tell not one of the half a dozen cards I carry can do a credible read only api of any sort
- erichurkman 7y agoPlaid is read only so far as I know. To do write type actions you bring in another party like Stripe.
- saganus 7y agoI also wonder about this myself, and my conclusion is that it probably increases the bank's systems attack surface for very little gain (in their eyes). Very few people have the knowledge and interest in interacting with a bank's API, so there's little upside with a lot of downsides. Even if read-only, something like this has to be architected correctly and we all know this is most often not the case. On the other hand, if businesses are built around these APIs, banks might perceive them as competition and no executive is going to choose to support them. Even though I (and probably others in HN) can see the value in offering more modern banking features built in top of official APIs, just look at what has happened with e.g. Twitter's API and others. Eroding your own vendor lock-in is generally frowned-upon by most companies, no matter how much we believe it might be win-win for everyone.
- sorum 7y agoIf you're in the US, I'd recommend checking out either Mint (by Intuit) or Personal Capital. Both use OAuth for the banks who support it. No handing over of bank credentials to a 3rd party and the sync is near real-time from my own testing of both. https://mint.intuit.com/ https://mint.intuit.com/ https://www.personalcapital.com/ https://www.personalcapital.com/ If you want something with more functionality to do budgeting, You Need A Budget (ynab.com) has a lot more functionality in that department, but does not support OAuth connections to banks; in my test period I had to re-add my bank accounts constantly. Shame, because the functionality of YNAB is stellar overall.