4 ms·
A proprietary protocol that somehow facilities throughout orders of magnitude than non proprietary alternatives. I call BS.
by dboreham 7y ago
A proprietary protocol that somehow facilities throughout orders of magnitude than non proprietary alternatives. I call BS.
- sansnomme 7y agoIf they are like Riot and have their own fiber, it is not unlikely. There are tons of boring optimizations open source software also won't bother with without significant sponsorship (some could be specific to a particular file format). If you look at most network (and also video) protocols, they are accumulations of decades of improvements rather than neural network style overnight breakthroughs.
- big_chungus 7y agoDo you know of any resources where I can learn more about these boring optimizations?
- SaxonRobber 7y agoMIT open courseware has a course on Performance Engineering which details some of the types of low level optimizations that can be done. It requires a lot of measuring and problem specific solutions.
- brians 7y agoI’ve helped with that course in the past. It’s awesome. It’s completely unrelated to WAN networking. I found the IETF groups working on these problems more helpful.
- big_chungus 7y agoThanks. Any specific recommendations for someone fairly new to low-level networking? IETF docs can be a little dense :)
- brians 7y agoI know about a couple of these. Some use very specific compression based on external knowledge—like that this is all office xml documents, with freedom to study the set of the last year’s documents. Some work by eliciting pessimal behavior from TCP flows sharing the same link—they’re really bad neighbors! Some use a family of different approaches to cope with different performance domains. Some use intermediate relays to cut the bandwidth-deat product by reducing delay. But the big key is this: standard tools aren’t even trying to be good at this. They’re aimed at making an Internet work, not at optimizing and particular flow.
- Spooky23 7y agoIt works, maybe not thousands of times faster, but it’s a fast protocol. Basically it chunks up data and pushes it out as quickly as possible with UDP then retransmits whatever is needed. It works great in enterprise networks where you have high packet latency due to shitty firewalls and inspection appliances. I haven’t used it in awhile, but I think they also have a proxy like service that lets you do managed file transfer directly from your datacenter network instead. It’s possible that I was using a complimentary product to do that.
- KaiserPro 7y agoAspera user here (Well I used to, before it was bought by IBM) Its only faster over large high latency links. Instead of using a single TCP stream to push data (with that exponential roll off) it has a TCP session to do accounting, and a bunch of UDP ports to stream the data. for links around 16ms latency, its not that much faster. For a 10 gig link with a latency of 100ms, it runs pretty much at wire speed. (assuming you have a machine that can handle it.)
- ncmncm 7y agoOrders of magnitude improvement over TCP is easy when the bandwidth-delay product and loss rate keep TCP stuck at 0.1% of line rate. It says more about how bad TCP is on those lines than about how good the alternative is. But the alternative is good, too. Worth the price? Depends on non-technical factors.
- justicezyx 7y agoA comment that calls BS but has no facts, I call BS?