6 ms·
Video: A Language for Making Movies
- MrRadar 7y agoHow does this compare to AVISynth? http://avisynth.nl/index.php/Main_Page http://avisynth.nl/index.php/Main_Page
- BubRoss 7y agoHow does this compare to ffmpeg, Nuke, davinci resolve, handbrake, AviSynth etc. etc. This is like making a language called math that is made for doing math. It's incredibly pretentious to name your project something that is confusing, difficult to find, raises more questions than answers on what it does, and definitely doesn't tell you why it exists. It says it combines racket with a video editor. What needs to be automated in a video editor? Why does it call itself a new language?
- applecrazy 7y agoFrom the docs (https://docs.racket-lang.org/video@video-v0-2/index.html https://docs.racket-lang.org/video@video-v0-2/index.html): > Video Language (or VidLang, sometimes referred to as just Video) is a DSL for editing...videos. It aims to merge the capabilities of a traditional graphical non-linear video editor (NLVE), with the power of a programming language.
- BubRoss 7y agoI saw that and don't think it answers any of my questions.
- acuozzo 7y ago> It aims to merge the capabilities of a traditional graphical non-linear video editor (NLVE), with the power of a programming language Which is exactly what AviSynth and VapourSynth have been doing successfully for years.
- colinthompson 7y agoI would love to see a running list of languages named like this. There are many, but I guess I can’t find or remember them since they’re all named so generically. Processing is the only other one I can think of at the moment.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoWell I mean... Go, D, Rust, Monkey, and so on. In the case of Rust I sometimes get more results about Rust the game than I do Rust the language.
- zamadatix 7y agoI think they mean languages named pretentiously not languages whose name is reused. Not many things (non-programming included) are named after putting letters into a blender and seeing what comes out.
- jobigoud 7y ago"Basic" might be another example. edit: from Wikipedia's list of languages I found the following: "Action!", "Basic", "BLISS", "Cool", "Hack", "Pure", "SMALL". Some of them are acronyms/retronyms. Special mentions: Smalltalk and High level shader language (HLSL).
- tobestobestobes 7y agowrt why video editing needs automating: there are a host of repetitive tasks in video editing that are very tedious to do with GUI editors. For instance, labelling shots with shot number overlay text. At the moment you can get quick results for this specific task using other tools such as FFmpeg. Personally, the top item on my wishlist would be a video editing library (Python?) that outputs to Final Cut Pro XML so that I could do final tweaks in a GUI-based editor of my choice.
- dimatura 7y agoI've used moviepy (https://github.com/Zulko/moviepy https://github.com/Zulko/moviepy) with some success. Doesn't do Final Cut export but it uses ffmpeg under the hood, so it could be used to create raw clips in some lossless format.
- rpmisms 7y agoSoory for necro. Editors should know how to code. Lots of editing tools are extensible in Python pretty easily. Sadly, those parts of my career didn't intersect.
- tobestobestobes 7y agoI don't find the Adobe Premiere SDK very intuitive or well documented, nor does it support Python. Looks like DaVinci Resolve does support Python and it seems well documented and intuitive. Thanks for the tip.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jaimex2 7y agoHow is this better than calling ffmpeg?
- throw_m239339 7y agoit uses racket and ffmpeg under the hood apparently. Let's not forget Javascript + Video web api + WebGL, insanely powerful when it comes to real time video manipulation.
- gvkhna 7y agoWebGL is good but has limitations around video editing, WebGPU and some improvements by browsers will address a lot of these though in the coming years. Full disclosure: Making an online video editor at https://www.mixcut.com https://www.mixcut.com with web technologies.
- sriku 7y agoAbout a decade and a half ago, Microsoft had this DirectShow interface called "Timeline" that would provide a similar though non-programmable interface to constructing movies via an XML document spec. The characteristic representation snafu there was the limited way in which "transition" worked and how we couldn't extend that notion. When I worked at muvee, we found that approach limiting and built an entire engine programmable via a scheme-like embedded programming language we called muSE. While muvee was about automatic video construction, the language had the necessary primitives to programmatically construct video. The basic abstraction on top of which everything from video clips to effects, transitions and layers were built was a "Show" which is a function from time to image. More here - [1] Authoring muvee styles - describes how to make your own automatic video "styles" and includes the lower level api too - https://srikumarks.github.io/muvee-style-authoring/index.html https://srikumarks.github.io/muvee-style-authoring/index.htm... [2] muSE the core open sourced language - https://github.com/srikumarks/muSE https://github.com/srikumarks/muSE edit: muvee Reveal - https://www.muvee.com/products/muvee-reveal-encore-automatic-video-editor https://www.muvee.com/products/muvee-reveal-encore-automatic... disclosure: I used to work for muvee.
- grblovrflowerrr 7y agoThe "Getting Started" page of the documentation seems to be a better introduction to the project than the home page. It has a tutorial with screenshots and code snippets, and is overall a better description of what the language does: https://docs.racket-lang.org/video@video/Getting_Started.html https://docs.racket-lang.org/video@video/Getting_Started.htm...
- spectramax 7y agoWhy call it "Video" to be drowned by other search results and never to show up on Google?
- gvkhna 7y agoWould you make another suggestion? Video editing is low on keywords. Full disclosure: Making an online video editor at https://www.mixcut.com https://www.mixcut.com
- spectramax 7y agoBtw, Mixcut is a great name. "Video" is such a bad name that literally anything is better than it. Its like calling a photo editing app, called "Photo" or a car company called "Car". Uff! Pick an animal. A tree species. Something from the periodic table. Or, something made up like "Mixcut". * Lion video editor * Juniper video editor * Tungsten video editor * Superion video editor
- gvkhna 7y agoThank you!
- aliveupstairs 7y agoId' say use real screenshots on your home page.
- gvkhna 7y agoAlmost there, we will launch very soon.
- fake-name 7y agoHoly crap it's terrible naming hour-o-clock. If you're creating a project like this, Use a unique name. This is basically going to be completely impossible to search for.
- ragebol 7y agoVideolang? DuckDuckGo also includes results to VideoLAN of VLC fame. Google does better and shows, well, what this comment section is about.
- MisterTea 7y agoI can agree but there are plenty of lame programming language and project names: Rust, Go , C, Julia, Salt, Chrome, etc. Then very generic company and product names: Amazon, Windows, Apple, and so on. Plenty of boring, generic names. One really annoying thing is that can make searching for information very difficult if the thing in question isn't very popular. E.g. I wanted to buy valves for a project rated for steam service. It was almost impossible at first as using steam and valve in the same search term bought up Valve the gaming company and their Steam gaming platform. I then had to use specific technical terms such as steam "gate valve" and so on plus throwing in -game or -gaming to weed out erroneous results.
- dimatura 7y agoIn the past I have used moviepy (https://github.com/Zulko/moviepy https://github.com/Zulko/moviepy) to programatically create videos in Python. At a very high level, it manages creation of image frames that are ultimately fed into ffmpeg. It is (was?) a bit buggy sometimes, but it gets the job done. Initially I used it because I couldn't bother with learning any of the free nonlinear video editors on Linux (many of which are pretty flaky/hard to use, or at least were back then). Having become actually become semi-familiar with a couple of NLEs since then, I can say moviepy is a bad NLE replacement for most use cases, but for others it's a real time saver.
- javajosh 7y agoTake this feedback as constructive, because Racket is cool and a movie-making language is interesting and I want you to succeed. Good software design is about anticipating what your user will need to know to move forward. Your project failed to do that at step 0: the project home page doesn't show the information people will need to move forward. Some indication of what the project does, what it looks like... What I thought when clicking on the HN link: Video-making with a programming language! How interesting! Lots of potential with animation, concurrency, etc. What does that look like? I want to see a session with the tool. At the very least I want to see the output of the tool, and some code snippets. If I like it I'd like to know who made it, and why, and what they've done with it so far, and where the money's coming from. Well, at least there's a getting started button, nice and big and red! Oh, all it's telling me to do is install this thing. Is the author crazy? I'm not installing something without a single goddamn screenshot! Lets write an HN comment... The thing is I am not going to install your program without this information, and I think you need to spend some time thinking about what visitors to your project will need to see before they take the plunge and look at your stuff.
- codetrotter 7y agoI agree they ought to show what it’s like to use this on the landing page. Meanwhile, for anyone curious there are some screenshots and demonstrations of usage in the docs, starting with this page: https://docs.racket-lang.org/video@video/Getting_Started.html#%28part._.Video_.Basics%29 https://docs.racket-lang.org/video@video/Getting_Started.htm...
- derision 7y agoI disagree. A link to documentation is at the start of the page. That's where I expect to see code samples and output which is all there
- mdip 7y agoWhich covers, reasonably, people who have an idea of what the product is and enough motivation (i.e. working in the space, or a serious hobbyist) to click in more deeply. Myself -- little more than an enthusiast -- clicked the homepage link, the documentation link, the blog and ended up landing at the point where the line on my "interest in the product" part of the graph met my "time I'm willing to spend figuring out if I'm going to be more interested" before I ever got the answer to "would I want to use this?" That's fine -- the author is within his rights to target what s/he wants. Perhaps it's so Alpha that the author doesn't desire people other than "serious hobbyists" to dig in deeper (there's valid reasons to do this). But if the goal was to get larger traction (as posting to HN is likely to cause), that didn't happen, for me.