10 ms·
Coinbase Wallet to remove DApp browser to comply with Apple's policy
- yladiz 7y agoAs this post doesn’t explain what a DApp is, for anyone curious it seems to be a “decentralized app”. I’m not sure how they work, or what the benefit of them are, but I guess they’re like apps-within-apps, kind of like the mini apps in WeChat (someone more knowledgeable please chime in).
- davidajackson 7y agoYou can create front facing software that only interfaces with blockchain(s). To create a wallet you create a pub + private key pair. You can then sign tx's with that. A DApp can enable transfer of assets between addresses, calling smart contract functions in deployed smart contracts, and the frontend keeps you updated on the tx statuses. Essentially they are created for privacy and security reasons, and to execute scripting code from a mobile app, which is stored at a deployed smart contract address. I'm not sure what Apple's motivation is here, compliance or legal issues would probably be their biggest complaint? Or is this their attempt to squash an app store within their App Store?
- qz_ 7y agoI believe Apple forbids running third-party code it hasn’t approved, with some exceptions for educational apps.
- davidajackson 7y agoI see, it's like when developers build automatic deployment into their apps to avoid app review.
- pat2man 7y agoYeah but these apps are just html and JavaScript which is normally allowed.
- EGreg 7y agoYeah Apple explicitly states that in their guidelines. Why would they ban it?
- Fnoord 7y ago> I believe Apple forbids running third-party code it hasn’t approved, with some exceptions for educational apps. Exceptions list: 1) Content served over HTTP(S) such as JavaScript. 2) WeChat. 3) ...
- aakilfernandes 7y agodApp is kind of a flexible word, but the typical unifying feature is that the user has custody of a private key they use for signing transactions on a distributed ledger. Most dApps (at least the ones you access through a dApp browser) have UIs built using regular web technology, and served over http. As for why Google/Apple are doing this, I can only imagine that it threatens their walled garden by giving web users more access to payments that they'd rather monetize.
- saurik 7y agoOn a desktop computer by far the most common "dApp browser" is MetaMask, which is merely a Chrome/Firefox extension. The mechanism is simply "a web browser" that gives the web page the ability (via some injected JavaScript object) to "request an Ethereum transaction be executed" (which costs money to do, and might even simply be the transfer of money). If it were possible to make browser extensions for MobileSafari people likely wouldn't bother making entire replacement browsers, as the experience is categorically worse. Alternative browsers--built using Apple's browser--exist on the App Store; the issue here is that users are paying for something via a mechanism that isn't in-app purchases: Apple wants all payments in the world to flow through them, and so the idea of a decentralized payment future is incompatible with the App Store.
- cdiddy2 7y agoWouldn't they remove regular Bitcoin and ethereum wallets too if they were trying to control payment flows
- saurik 7y agoAs far as I can tell, they model those apps like banking apps, or Venmo, or PayPal, which you will note are all also allowed. However, they model stuff you do with these dApp browsers as direct payments for a service. Apple has a rule in their App Store review guidelines that if you sell something, you must do it via in-app purchase.
- cdiddy2 7y agoMost dapps are more similar to investing like a tdameritrade, which is allowed in the app store. I guess that doesn't apply to all dapps though.
- newnewpdro 7y agoAnd yet you can purchase things in conventional e-commerce using a web browser on an iphone without Apple getting their cut. How is this any different?
- hanniabu 7y agoThis is a fairly good explanation on stackexchange: https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/a/384 https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/a/384 Excerpt (in the context of Ethereum, a smart contract platform): > A DApp has its backend code running on a decentralized peer-to-peer network. Contrast this with an app where the backend code is running on centralized servers. > A DApp can have frontend code and user interfaces written in any language (just like an app) that can make calls to its backend. Furthermore, its frontend can be hosted on decentralized storage such as Swarm or IPFS. > If an app=frontend+server, since Ethereum contracts are code that runs on the global Ethereum decentralized peer-to-peer network, then: DApp = frontend + contracts
- EGreg 7y agoHow does the web3 or whatever js running in your web browser know what gateway to use to interface with the blockchain? What if that gateway goes down? How does it or any ETH or Bittorent node bootstrap in general?
- Acrobatic_Road 7y agoThe web3.js file doesn't pick your gateway. MetaMask uses a default gateway from Infura, but you can switch to another such as Cloudflare's gateway or a local node.
- dboreham 7y agoThe web3 service host name is configurable by the user (with some defaults for batteries included user experience).
- chairmanmow 7y agoI made/am working on a DApp that does some stuff involving ANSI art as tokens with some additional properties that have rules that get enforced by the smart contract, which is essentially the back end. While the site sort of functions without being connected to the blockchain (there's a crappy database backed backend too), there is an entirely different set of data that's stored there that is not entirely in my control - only so much as the smart contract/backend coding permits once deployed to the Blockchain Virtual Machine. Instead of talking to an API connected to a database, it's connected to an ABI talking to the blockchain. Someone could directly interface with that, or use my client, or build their own etc, it's open on the blockchain. Read operations are free unless specified, write operations generally have an implicit cost of the smart contracts currency at least with what I've used, which was Ethereum.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoWhat is a "DApp?"
- llovan 7y agoDecentralized App
- awinter-py 7y agoyeah only wechat is allowed to have their own app store https://techcrunch.com/2018/11/07/wechat-mini-apps-200-million-users/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/11/07/wechat-mini-apps-200-milli...
- ghostpepper 7y agoDoes wechat allow users to make payments to each other? I wonder if that's what this is really about.
- infecto 7y agoLets be honest. Its the same for Alipay's app too. They both are their own ecosystem and they are going to be allowed without a doubt, if Apple was to touch either of these Apps it would be seen as an offense to the red flag and I could easily see the mainlanders boycotting it.
- sdan 7y agoAnd could potentially leak into foreign politics.
- McTossOut 7y agoRemember when Microsoft sued OpenOffice for building a functional free competitor? Or when Sun sued Python? I feel it's time to ramp up support for Ubuntu Touch.
- Fnoord 7y ago> Remember when Microsoft sued OpenOffice for building a functional free competitor? Or when Sun sued Python? They never did. They never did. Both companies did some evil things in the 90s and 00s (Microsoft arguably much worse than Sun) but not what you described here. There were some worries from words that Microsoft might sue OpenOffice users. Sun never sued "Python" (you cannot sue a programming language, for starters). ..and why specifically Ubuntu Touch? There are other FOSS options available. Ubuntu Touch never took off, and is now a community project. Even Windows Phone failed. I put my money on Sailfish OS as platform #3 (if we ignore KaiOS) which is partly FOSS. Why SFOS? Because it will get adoption in non-Western markets such as Russia and India. Countries don't want to be dependent on US proprietary code because it isn't auditable, and these companies in the end do what the US government asks or demands them to do. I'm also curious what is going to happen with the Chinese Android fork led by Huawei.
- K0SM0S 7y agoSailfish is definitely my next phone OS, and even though walking away from Google / Apple tentacles is one incentive, by far the biggest for me is that it runs Linux, complete with terminal etc. Oh the joy of just being able to grep, rsync, ssh... I always felt like that wasn't a lot to ask, but evidently, I couldn't be further away from the truth.
- loourr 7y agoAll distributed apps should be built for the desktop first. Everything else will be censored.
- Acrobatic_Road 7y agoThere's nothing stopping you from throwing a DeFi interface on a local web server. Built for web doesn't mean web exclusive.
- loourr 7y agoThat's true, but it's just more difficult to distribute.
- Acrobatic_Road 7y agoYou're right, it is inconvenient. There are some desktop dapp browsers such as shadowlands (supports uniswap and makerdao) but nobody is really using these (yet). https://github.com/kayagoban/shadowlands https://github.com/kayagoban/shadowlands
- throwGuardian 7y agoApple taking giant craps on less powerful companies, is becoming routine. After all this publicly available information on their behavior, if the supreme Court sides with apple on app store policy, I think we'll have Google and Microsoft immediately pivoting to this model of fingering developers and end users
- dang 7y agoUrl changed from https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/51693/coinbase-wallet-to-remove-dapp-browser-to-comply-with-apples-policy https://www.theblockcrypto.com/linked/51693/coinbase-wallet-..., which points to this.
- swiley 7y agoWhy is the iPhone so often associated with innovation? It’s always the thing that prevents innovation and substitutes banks (ultimately) manipulating individuals.
- latchkey 7y agoIf you ever tried to develop software on phones before the iPhone, you'd understand. A buddy and I developed a pretty cool 'Cocktail App' for the Danger Hiptop. After many months of frustratingly going back and forth, we were not able to get it onto the Hiptop app store because the carrier (T-Mobile) did not want to be responsible for someone using a recipe to make a simple bar drink and then going off and killing someone. They eventually added a 21+ category and we still couldn't get it onto the store. Never mind the fact that someone could just use the installed web browser to view the same exact content. Of course you'd think that we should have known that we might get rejected... but the issue was that Danger couldn't even talk to the carrier until the app was written and they could physically show it to them. So it was one of those things where we knew the app might get rejected, but we took the risk anyway. It was a good learning experience. So yes, this weird stuff around getting software onto phones has been going on for a long time. Apple was one of the first to take the control away from the telco. I don't know if that is better or worse, but it changed the economics substantially.
- giancarlostoro 7y ago> So yes, this weird stuff around getting software onto phones has been going on for a long time. Apple was one of the first to take the control away from the telco. I don't know if that is better or worse, but it changed the economics substantially. The legal burden is no longer on the telco's but on Apple in this case.
- latchkey 7y agoCorrect. At the time, there was no way to even talk to the telco. All communication had to go through a single person at Danger who was overloaded with their job and barely had time to respond to people who were not guaranteed to make it into the store. Luckily I had friends that worked at Danger and could help a little. It took a while and went through a lot of growing pains, but at least now, Apple has the financial resources to hire staff to respond to support tickets. If we are comparing literal apples to lemons... I'd much rather deal with someone at Apple than someone at a telco.
- ssalka 7y agoI remember hearing about this portion of the App Store policy before - where "mini app stores" are essentially banned. Can anyone link to this specific portion of the policy? Curious to see what it actually says.
- saagarjha 7y agoThe language around this changes constantly and currently says something about not emulating multi-app widget experiences.
- Sargos 7y agoApple and Google have complete control over the mobile market which is the dominant way humanity interacts with the internet in today's world, especially in developing countries. Having a policy which forbids arbitrary things like listing other apps for users to interact with is very dangerous as it effectively bans whole industries from competing on a level playing field. This is a big problem for cryptocurrency especially as mobile web browsers cannot interact with blockchains and so users are forced to use custom apps that implement the web3 interfaces. This effectively bans wallets from providing a good experience to allow users to interact with dapps and since you can't fall back to using a web browser on mobile it might end up being a total ban on the use of dapps on mobile platforms unless each dapp makes their own app (which just opens a whole new can of worms). I'm not really sure what the solution is here but something really needs to be done before it becomes a ceiling for dapp adoption. Perhaps the answer is government regulations mandating open access to mobile platforms which is looking more likely each year as the investigations into big tech are ramping up but I'd rather see mobile Chrome get extension support so people can at least fall back to metamask. I don't see that happening though. This will be a fun war over the next decade but I'm hoping for the best.
- pentae 7y agoCue the "But I like Apple running the app store with an iron fist! No malware and viruses!" comments. Unless the government forces Apple in the future to permit sideloading, this is never going to change.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Unless the government forces Apple in the future to permit sideloading, this is never going to change Granted. Convince me this is an issue best solved by a law specifically regulating side loading?
- anfilt 7y agoWell what else do you propose since iPhones comes with essentially a hard coded PC equivalent of secure boot that you can't disable. You can't even load your own keys onto the device and sign your own software or OS. At which point you don't even own the computer since you have limited say as to the software you can run on it. I don't see Apple planning to stop restricting users rights anytime soon. Same applies for phone manufactures who sell android devices.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoIt would be helpful if the post explained what this is and means. What is "DApp browser?"