4 ms·
> So why have eBooks failed so miserably, when other media such as movies and music now sell and rent so well online? [...] > Then there’s the question of wha
by emodendroket 7y ago
> So why have eBooks failed so miserably, when other media such as movies and music now sell and rent so well online?
[...]
> Then there’s the question of what you get for your money with an eBook. According to the publishers in that recent case in the CJEU, you get a perpetual licence (not ownership) to access their copyright content, which never deteriorates in the same way that physical books do. As a result, the publishers claimed successfully, you aren’t free to sell on your licence, and can only do so if they, the copyright owners, agree. In other words, you pay much the same price for something which immediately on purchase becomes worthless.
Well... what's the difference there? That doesn't seem like it, since it's no less true of movies or music.
Actually, my guess is that most people never read most of the books they buy. Maybe they intend to, but it ends up mostly being some kind of affirmation of the kind of person they are. While the e-book experience has a lot to recommend it if your object is actually to read a lot of books (particularly outside the house), it doesn't do much to burnish your bookshelf.
- wongarsu 7y agoMovies and songs sell digitally because of convenience. I can watch what I want now, instead of waiting two days or making a two hour trip to a store that may or may not have that movie. But reading a book is a much larger commitment than watching a movie or listening to a song. Thus it's more planned and waiting a bit isn't as much of a factor.
- emodendroket 7y agoI question the premise that books are rarely impulse-bought. That's kind of the idea of Hudson Books, for instance. Besides that, digital books are actually much more convenient in some important ways -- if I want to read a dense technical book on my way to work and a thick novel on my way back, I might not bother with the physical books because I don't want to lug them around. With the Kindle that's no problem.
- wongarsu 7y agoReading is a trade-off. Sure, an ebook reader is lighter and smaller than a book, but reading on an LCD is 20% slower than on paper, meanwhile eInk screens are rather slow. Both are only slowly catching up to books in terms of print quality (i.e. pixel density). Also books don't require a battery and have often better UX in terms of annotations etc. In some situations the ebook will win (e.g. when traveling), in other situations the book is still superior.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoPhysical books are expensive, ebooks can be pirated. That is a huge difference.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> According to the publishers in that recent case in the CJEU, you get a perpetual licence (not ownership) to access their copyright content, which never deteriorates in the same way that physical books do. What crap argument is that? In reality, a random physical book has expected useful lifetime longer than most publishers, longer than Internet and anything recognizable as personal computing ever existed. Books don't deteriorate into uselessness for decades. Licensed content on-line typically disappears after few years, very often together with the service that you rented it from in the first place.
- emodendroket 7y agoDoes it really though? In 100 years I think people will care more about Citizen Kane or Michael Jackson than Rich Dad, Poor Dad or Excel 95 for Dummies.
- mplanchard 7y agoIt doesn’t seem fair to compare classics of two media with books that are definitively not in the same league. I definitely want to be able to pick up my copy of Pale Fire in 30 years and read it. Similarly with The Idiot. Those physical books will definitely still be functional in three decades. And, if a copy is lost or damaged, it’s easy to get a cheap replacement at a used bookstore, something that isn’t possible with ebooks.
- emodendroket 7y agoOf course, but the point of the comparison is that there is no shortage of forgettable books. I predict it will be quite easy to download a new digital copy of The Idiot in 30 years if you lose access to the one you have today as well.
- catalogia 7y agoThere is no shortage of forgettable anythings. If that was your point, it's a poor one. If you could predict ahead of time what might be valued in the future, then you could discard the rest. But you cannot do that, since you are not from the future. Scraps of data once thrown away as mundane are now valued in the present by researchers; there is no reason to believe this won't continue to be true into the future. Even your poorly contrived example of mundane data was debunked easily by another commenter. Keep what can reasonably be kept, and let future researchers worry about filtering it. Preemptive filtering will only deprive future researchers of data they'll desire for reasons you cannot presently fathom.