4 ms·
> we don't understand why programmers are paid so well. I think the problem is that programming is more complicated than other jobs. Your value as a doctor is
by csomar 7y ago
> we don't understand why programmers are paid so well.
I think the problem is that programming is more complicated than other jobs. Your value as a doctor is pretty much equal to the other doctor next door. That's not true for software developers.
One thing I noticed about open source software, is that most of the projects (even the big one) are mainly run by 1-2 guys. There can be a hundred contributors, but the heavy lifting is done by a single person or maybe a couple. This is different than say a hospital, where you can't have a single doctor doing all the heavy lifting.
Most software developers are paid shit (outside the USA and Silicon Valley) and are barely equivalent to other engineers or university educated folks.
> Consulting, investment banking, etc., are similar. Compensation appears to be proportional to the level of sacrifice
Yes, because you open a consulting shop and work starts following. It has been mentioned here, before, that consulting in tech is more about building a reputation and managing clients than the technical skills. So not really that much different. If you are highly talented and have no network, you'll make exactly 0 as a consultant.
> but the combination of medical school and residency is still incredibly brutal compared to most jobs at places like Facebook and Google
What the OP misses is that Facebook/Google do not represent your average US engineer; let alone the average global one. Whether they are talented or lucky, they are the minority.
> big companies need to compete with programmers choosing to go off and start companies, which is harder to do in many fields.
Maybe they are going to startup route because the compensation for a skilled software developer is very low.
Writing software is like writing novels (not exactly but close). A few good writers are going to make most of the $$ while the rest are going to barely survive. My guess is that in the future will see more of this trend where you either go big or go home.
- tomohawk 7y agoTo back this up, if you need a surgery, you want to go with the surgeon who has done at least 100 surgeries of the specific type you need and who has done a fair number of them recently. A skilled and experienced surgeon is key for best outcome in many surgeries. However, the comp from the insurer is going to be the same regardless of skill level.
- foogazi 7y agoOn the same theme, if you need surgery and are a high skills athlete who can make millions off of that surgery you won’t pay the going insurer rate
- 2sk21 7y ago> Most software developers are paid shit (outside the USA and Silicon Valley) and are barely equivalent to other engineers or university educated folks. Agree - and to add to this, a big chunk of "software" jobs does not seem to actually involve writing software nowadays but rather consist of an endless set of chores like fixing shell scripts, running ETL jobs, handling pager duty at 3am etc I have seen a number of fresh college graduates get stuck in these dead-end jobs and have helped them get out of these ruts by mentoring them. As you say, the vast majority of the software jobs are really bad.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoUh, maybe you mean one radiologist is interchangeable with another. And one pediatrician is interchangeable with another. Doctors are definitely less interchangeable with each other than engineers. Top surgeons probably make more money compared to median surgeons than top engineers to median engineers. So the idea that all, say, plastic surgeons are roughly the same is ridiculous, too. Same thing goes for lawyers and marketers. Engineering isn't uniquely complex, and top engineers aren't uniquely highly compensated either. This is how it works in every industry, from sales to marketing. If anything, top engineers seem to be uniquely surprised that they get paid so well. I've never met a salesperson who thinks he's overpaid. Almost every engineer I know thinks he's overpaid. If anything, that's suppressing our wages.