3 ms·
I agree. I suspect the problem is these children were disruptive at age 8 and no one did anything. I don't think letting a 12 year old decide they don't have
by kenjackson 16y ago
I agree. I suspect the problem is these children were disruptive at age 8 and no one did anything.
I don't think letting a 12 year old decide they don't have to go to school is the answer. But I do think they should not be allowed to disrupt the education of others.
There are some intereting alternative schools that may be a way to tackle the issue. It's not an easy problem.
With that said, I think what this essay addresses, while seemingly obvious, is one of the biggest problems we face, and education reform generally doesn't mention it.
And I do speculate it hides one of the reasons why places like Promise Academy do so well. The students, even from broken homes, who go there are strongly pushed by mothers (or grandmothers) that this is special place. The expectation of good behavior is much higher there.
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoNone of the students at Promise Academy have supportive fathers or grandfathers?
- moultano 16y agoFor a poor black child to have a father in the home is currently atypical: http://www.theroot.com/buzz/72-percent-african-american-children-born-unwed-mothers http://www.theroot.com/buzz/72-percent-african-american-chil...
- PakG1 16y agoAs an addendum, that's an issue of the parents failing, not the school. The primary responsibility for a child's welfare should fall to the parents, not the schools. Schools are secondary. If schools take the primary initiative, there's even more incentive for parents who are on the decision margin to offload that responsibility to the schools and instead focus on other (potentially, but not necessarily, more selfish) things.