3 ms·
I have no problem with saying software may be proven consistent with a spec. But correctness is just an entirely tougher nut. Promising the latter but only del
by ncmncm 7y ago
I have no problem with saying software may be proven consistent with a spec. But correctness is just an entirely tougher nut. Promising the latter but only delivering the former may be good enough for the journals, but Engineering has a higher standard to meet.
- tome 7y agoYes, I entirely agree. I'm just saying that despite having a pure branch, mathematics also has an applied branch which is used in engineering, and formally-proven applied mathematics suffers from the exact same risks of misuse as formally-verified software.
- ncmncm 7y agoOK, yes. Applied mathematics has the same sort of gap between model (axioms) and reality as between specification and actual requirements. In both places people confuse the two, and sometimes make unjustified claims for the second from justified confidence in only the first.