6 ms·
I think the skillset needed to successfully start a company is quite different from the skillset needed to be a good programmer. I consider myself to be a decen
by adrianN 7y ago
I think the skillset needed to successfully start a company is quite different from the skillset needed to be a good programmer. I consider myself to be a decent programmer, but I would never be a successful business owner
- jolmg 7y agoIt's still probably a lot easier compared to other professions. Most need their employers to provide them with very expensive equipment to do their work. Programmers need little more than a laptop. That's a big difference, business-making skill notwithstanding.
- taneq 7y agoTrue but a development machine is a bit cheaper than a steel foundry or an automotive production line. The barrier to entry for a new software company is orders of magnitude lower than other industries.
- wallace_f 7y agoAlso, for the most part, isn't yet monopolized by lobbyists, corporatists and government working together to use regulatory capture to corner markets. It's pretty extreme in some industries, such as telecomm with natural monopolies, but also in markets without natural monopoloes. People even get arrested/fined for ridiculous things like braiding hair, giving haircuts (such as to homeless), selling hot dogs, selling cookies, or selling diet advice, etc. So in accordance with OP's theory, if this were to happen the salaries for devs would go down.
- jefftk 7y agoI'm confused: normally occupational licensing and other barriers to entry are modeled as increasing pay by constraining labor supply. Why do you think I think the opposite?
- username90 7y agoThere is no such thing as local demand for software engineers, instead you get tend to get paid more the bigger the project you work in is. This means that you'd expect software engineer salaries to be the highest where you have the highest concentration of them, such as San Francisco or New York. If it becomes illegal to gather such high concentrations of developers in one place then all of those high paying jobs will have to move elsewhere, as you can't sustain them without high concentrations.
- wallace_f 7y agoI was just following a thought from the OP's theory. Although it makes some sense as follows: Regulatory Capture involves not just occupational licensing, but artificial monopolies over products and services. For a current example, Facebook has been lobbying congress and even publicly stating that they want to work with them to regulate social media platforms and news media; and even though many can see some benefit to these regulatory laws, the trouble here is that critics argue these types of regulations tend to entrench large corporations who have the legal staff and dev bankrolls to deal with these rules. Actually, many industries, even historically cottage industries such as agriculture has been in modern time criticized in this way as having rules and subsidies written by large industrial, corporate entities which benefit large providers by creating barriers to entry for small competitors. In short, they create legal barriers to entry to creating the next providers, such as the next Facebook. In accordance with OP's theory, as the opportunities diminish, the value of labor decreases. But yes, traditionally occupational licensing increases cost and barriers to entry to providing a product or service and is modeled as to increase salaties and decrease jobs as labor supply is constrained. This is an interesting comparison of orthodox economics as you have mentioned with a reasonable yet heterodox theory in the wild I've seen. I haven't seen OP's theory stated explicitly before. Have you? Unfortunately in economics, we are dealing with the science of studying human decisions and as such it is grossly impractical to create a true scientific experiment here to determine which theory makes better predictions. This is probably also partly why economics tends to be snobby, pretentious and inflammatory: it is ultimately a war of words and mathematical arguments when it comes down to it.
- 7y ago
- amiga_500 7y ago> Also, for the most part, isn't yet monopolized by lobbyists, corporatists and government working together to use regulatory capture to corner markets When your flawed government has its own stage in the product life cycle
- agumonkey 7y agoBut that's because employees are the Factory Line in a way.
- radicalbyte 7y agoA good software developer paired with a talented marketer/salesperson together with a lot of work (400-800 hours each) have a decent chance. They would probably be odds-on to succeed if they were chasing a niche in an established market. This doesn't apply to companies like Facebook, Google etc because they're protected by a network effect.
- Shoetp 7y agoNot with that attitude.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoYou never know until you try.
- learnstats2 7y agoIt's likely that your employer will support anything you ask for to be a better programmer, but will support nothing that helps you to be a better business owner.
- shantly 7y agoDev lead (actual lead, not just a title) and product manager roles would definitely help, and developers can move into those. Granted that’s not everything, but you’ll need some of both of those to make it, especially product management, even if you’re solo.
- coldtea 7y ago"Successful business owner" doesn't mean creating Google, it could just mean having a 3-5 person IT consultancy and independent clients.
- adrianN 7y agoBy that success measure basically any office worker can start a company just as easily as a programmer. The only advantage I can see for programmers is that a relatively small team can serve a very large number of customers, because software scales much better than other kinds of works.
- dron57 7y agoThat's a huge, huge advantage. Even doctors and lawyers can only serve a small number of clients. While software can be reused and enable large deployments. These margins make all the difference.
- coldtea 7y ago>By that success measure basically any office worker can start a company just as easily as a programmer. Yes, but nobody needs them. Companies can hire office workers by the ton, and office workers can't reach further than a small load of work. Software can.