4 ms·
"Unions would have no market power without said laws" Well, that's a-historical. Unions existed before laws were in place to support unions. https://en.wikipe
by eesmith 7y ago
"Unions would have no market power without said laws"
Well, that's a-historical.
Unions existed before laws were in place to support unions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_v._Hunt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_v._Hunt .
The union power in the late 1800s was not built on laws which supported them. Often the government stepped in to fight the unions. And the unions sometimes won power, and were able to get the laws changed to prevent, eg, bloodshed in the future.
Your other comments still do not address the questions I asked, like, "what makes something a 'conspiracy theory'?".
Your "freedom of contract", if you really believed it, should apply to any situation which restricts trade.
If my contract with you says that disputes are exclusively to be settled by mediation with company X, then that prohibits other companies from being involved in the mediation.
"Freedom of contract" lovers think that sort of exclusive agreement is fine.
Similarly, a company A might contract with company B so that B is the exclusive supplier of temp workers.
"Freedom of contract" lovers think that sort of exclusive agreement is fine.
But somehow "organizations A and B enter into a contract such that A will only hire members of B" when B is a union is not fine?
Balderdash.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoUnions were very weak pre-labor-laws. Unionization rates were very low consequently. Whatever power they did have emanated from the threat of their illegal activity, ranging from blockading company premises (e.g. stopping trains) to setting up picket lines that involved violence against 'scabs'. >>Your other comments still do not address the questions I asked, like, "what makes something a 'conspiracy theory'?". I'm happy to carry that line on in another forum. >>If my contract with you says that disputes are exclusively to be settled by mediation with company X, then that prohibits other companies from being involved in the mediation. Of course, but labor laws, as they stand, prohibit companies from negotiating with any party but the union in the event that one of their work units unionizes and demands collective bargaining. This is regardless of what the company agreed to.
- eesmith 7y agoSo, "no power" = "very weak"? You sure you haven't moved the goalposts? The Boston Journeymen Bootmaker's Society won the labor action, and the lawsuit. Why should I believe the Society was weak? Wait employed five or six Society members, and only one not willing to be in the Society. That sounds like the boot industry, at least, had a high unionization rate. Of course, that was a craft union. I think you are talking about industrial unions. Which didn't, you know, really exist until after there were big industries in the late 1800s. "Whatever power they did have emanated from the threat of their illegal activity" I don't think you read the Wikipedia page on Commonwealth v. Hunt that I linked you to. It was clear that the Society's power emanated from the threat of a walkout, and not from any sort of illegal activity. Indeed, the court decision was that "labor combinations were legal provided that they were organized for a legal purpose and used legal means to achieve their goals." (quoting Wikipedia). A walkout must be legal in a free market. Otherwise it's forced labor to say that someone can't quit if they no longer want to work a given job. You write "as they stand". Which is entirely my point. We are not in a free market. If people really want a free market, they need to advocate for removing restriction on both labor and capital. Those who only want to remove restrictions on the control of capital, and not labor, are using "free market" hypocritically. Edit: And remember, the union powers prohibited by Taft-Hartley were legal until then, so those aren't examples of the illegal actions you refer to.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoIf unions have power in a free market, that would be absolutely fine with me lol But you're being disingenuous and or are deluding yourself if you claim that union power wasn't vastly more limited before the advent of labor laws, and that what power they did have wasn't disproportionately as a result of the threat that they'd engage in the illegal acts that they were so well known for. So to clarify, while I predict any transition to a free market would result in a drastic reduction in the power of unions, I would have no problem with a scenario where my prediction proves wrong and unions have substantial power in a free market. I just don't like the laws that overwhelmingly advantage unions at the expense of investors.
- eesmith 7y ago