3 ms·
Your second paragraph is true, but the first paragraph only applies to physical property and, trivially, to legally protected intellectual property. ("Trivially
by jessriedel 16y ago
Your second paragraph is true, but the first paragraph only applies to physical property and, trivially, to legally protected intellectual property. ("Trivially" because in the case of intellectual property, the only value is in the legal protection itself, whereas for physical property it's possible to illegally transfer stolen goods even though the new possessor will not have a legal claim to them.) However, private-eye type intelligence has no legal protection as property as far as I know. It is only "sold" in the sense that the person who has it reveals the info in exchange for compensation.
- pyre 16y agoIt depends on whether the information in question is the raw source information, or the actual intelligence report created by the private-eye.
- jessriedel 16y agoOnly if the buyer intended to publish the report, in which case it would be the protected intellectual property I mentioned. But if the report were leaked before the private-eye was able to sell it, there is nothing he could do legally to prevent the potential buyer from acting on that information (which is usually why people hire detectives). In particular, the FBI would legally be able to investigate and prosecute people using HBGary's info without paying HBGary. Professional courtesy and/or conflicts of interest might prompt them to pay for it anyway, of course.
- pyre 16y agoI was assuming there would be some sort of copyright issues with the information. I think that HBGray owns copyright on the report itself since they likely have some sort of analysis in addition to the raw information organized in an understandable fashion, though I guess there might not be any 'fruit of the poisoned tree'-type issues with the FBI using that information in their investigation.
- ZachPruckowski 16y agoWhat about chain of evidence? Who's to say that the hacker didn't change details of the report between downloading it and publishing it? "This is a report from a security expert" sounds quite a bit better in court than "This is a report that another hacker claims is an unaltered copy he nicked from a security expert".
- anamax 16y ago> However, private-eye type intelligence has no legal protection as property as far as I know. Why do you assume that it isn't "born copyrighted" like almost everything else? (The big exception is pure data, such as the phone book.) The expression of observations is clearly copyrightable. And then there's trade secret protection. The fact that they got hacked doesn't necessary void that.