4 ms·
It should be noted that this research was likely published with a specific agenda in mind: https://twitter.com/mark_ledwich/status/1210743217982803970?s=21 http
by minimaxir 7y ago
It should be noted that this research was likely published with a specific agenda in mind: https://twitter.com/mark_ledwich/status/1210743217982803970?s=21 https://twitter.com/mark_ledwich/status/1210743217982803970?...
> My new article explains in detail. It takes aim at the NYT (in particular, @kevinroose) who have been on myth-filled crusade vs social media. We should start questioning the authoritative status of outlets that have soiled themselves with agendas.
From the linked Medium article:
> These events, along with the promotion of the now-debunked YouTube “rabbit hole” theory, reveal what many suspect — that old media titans, presenting themselves as non-partisan and authoritative, are in fact trapped in echo chambers of their own creation, and are no more incentivized to report the truth than YouTube grifters.
The paper itself makes a fundamental flaw of using logged out recommendations and attempts to disprove 2018 algos even after substantial changes since, which invalidates the research entirely.
- fastball 7y agoLess of an agenda than the aforementioned NYT article. Sure, this research doesn't use 2018 algos, because it's 2019. I guess the NYT and others should've done the research in the first place then. It certainly doesn't invalidate the research - it shows that the claims made by others are probably not accurate in 2019 on YT.
- shard972 7y ago> maybe the NYT should have done some research Wow, never heard that one before.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jakeogh 7y agoThey dont like the competition. https://imgur.com/VUdcIou https://imgur.com/VUdcIou
- metamet 7y agoI believe the 2019 algo was dramatically changed recently, meaning that the core of the 2018 algo was present throughout the majority of 2019.
- tmpz22 7y agoIt makes me wonder how one would research Youtube algorithms from the outside. Perhaps freshly imaged computers in random geographical locations periodically running selenium or other browser automation software, recording which recommendations are made for various viewing preferences? The problem is A) the study could be invalidated by basic bot prevention (from identifying Selenium, identifying fresh accounts, etc) and B) Youtube actively preventing such research with "new" accounts and C) lack of sufficient scale could skew the results. Ideally Youtube would partner with a transparent auditor and have internal teams work with the auditors, but there's no way Google agrees to that because it could potentially unearth some very bad practices by the Youtube team (if they do exist...).
- minimaxir 7y agoI helped contribute to YouTube algorithm research for BuzzFeed News in January: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-youtubes-recommendation-rabbithole https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/carolineodonovan/down-y...
- tmpz22 7y ago> To better understand how Up Next discovery works, BuzzFeed News ran a series of searches on YouTube for news and politics terms popular during the first week of January 2019 (per Google Trends). We played the first result and then clicked the top video recommended by the platform’s Up Next algorithm. We made each query in a fresh search session with no personal account or watch history data informing the algorithm, except for geographical location and time of day, effectively demonstrating how YouTube’s recommendation operates in the absence of personalization. From a technical perspective this does not seem very rigorous, specifically: > We made each query in a fresh search session with no personal account or watch history I don't see how you can confidently say > effectively demonstrating how YouTube’s recommendation operates in the absence of personalization --- 1) What is a "fresh search session" 2) Were all these requests made from the same IP address? 3) What does no personal account or watch history mean? Did you use incognito mode, did you logout from chrome, had you recently been logged into an account in that browser (such that cookies may still be present)? --- The point of my comment is that this research is ~hard~ and its difficult to definitely prove that Google's algorithms are immoral unless you can research with a high degree of rigor (the study is repeatable, its been peer reviewed by experts, etc). FWIW I think this research is immensely valuable and needed, but I feel like until it is done well the "news" about it is little more then Op eds and blogspam.
- elfexec 7y ago> It should be noted that this research was likely published with a specific agenda in mind: Just like the previous "study" which claimed everybody not part of the corporate media were alt-right. These types of "research" are funded and run solely for an agenda. Primarily to push social media platforms to direct traffic to corporate media. Also, radicalized is such an interesting word. If the saudis ran the exact same study with their definition of "radicals", I wonder how that would turn out? What if the chinese or the russians? Are their radicals the same as ours? Also, are the liberal elites' definition of radical the same as conservatives or the general population at large? At the end of the day, it's all about "authorative" sources - an orwellian and creepy word if there ever was one.
- ravenstine 7y ago> Also, radicalized is such an interesting word. If the saudis ran the exact same study with their definition of "radicals", I wonder how that would turn out? What if the chinese or the russians? Are their radicals the same as ours? Also, are the liberal elites' definition of radical the same as conservatives or the general population at large? If we want to be consistent, the founding fathers of the United States were radicalized, but that's usually not how people think of them.