3 ms·
> The mod made statements that vaguely pattern match as onerous hair splitting in order to undermine LGBTQ+ rights. The actual point is, there's no such thing
by zozbot234 7y ago
> The mod made statements that vaguely pattern match as onerous hair splitting in order to undermine LGBTQ+ rights.
The actual point is, there's no such thing as a "right to be addressed by one's preferred pronoun". Attempts to introduce such a purported "right" can easily pattern match to many other sorts of compelled speech, which in a genuinely liberal, rights-focused and non-oppressive political culture are generally rejected altogether - for very good reasons dating back to many centuries ago, that have zilch to do with the (very real and concrete, unfortunately) plight of a number of sexual and gender minorities.
Basically, this whole "you must use my preferred pronouns, or else" thing is a huge distraction that does nothing to make LGBTQetc. folks better off.
- sizzle 7y agoDoes compelling people to use pronouns conflict with the notion of freedom of speech?
- EpicEng 7y agoIn what way would it not? I'm free to call you or anyone else a jerk if I like, but I'm barred from calling you a pronoun you don't like? As if that in any way would change my view of the issue? As if it's anything more than some silly notion of protecting people's feelings? Why not worry about real injustices? You have no right to be free from being offended or having your feelings hurt, but you should be able to get a job, get married, get medical treatment, etc.
- damnyou 7y agoYou are in fact not free to call people jerks in a professional context.
- EpicEng 7y agoYou're not? Is the fed going to throw you in prison for doing so? Of course you're free to call someone at work a jerk. Your boss is also free to fire you. Freedom of speech is a concept that applies to our government, not private entities. That said, we can still discuss whether or not specific limitatations on speech by private entities are a good or bad thing. In this case, I believe it's a bad thing to codify. Rules which apply to harassment, which almost every forum has in place, still apply. The question is how far do we go? Are we really going to force people to use gender neutral ponouns at all times as a matter of course in order to protect some small portion of an estimated 0.6% of the population's feelings?
- damnyou 7y agoYes, you are technically free to call people jerks as long as you are OK with the consequences, which may include getting fired. The government cannot put filters in front of people's mouths, thankfully. Repeated and intentional misgendering is similar to racial or ethnic slurs, which also don't belong in professional settings and will ideally also get you fired. Personally I think the Catholic Church is a great force of evil, but I keep those opinions to myself at work out of respect for my Catholic coworkers. You are free to believe whatever you want about how nonbinary people are just seeking attention or whatever, but you shouldn't misgender people at work. Who's forcing folks to use gender neutral pronouns "at all times"? You only have to use them for people who have requested it. The 0.6% number is commonly quoted but is very dubious, since it doesn't account for people who may not be out due to social stigmatization. The real number of people who would be happier with a non-cis identity is probably much higher, somewhere around 5-10% by my estimate.
- EpicEng 7y ago>Who's forcing folks to use gender neutral pronouns "at all times"? You only have to use them for people who have requested it. An excerpt from Monica's side of things: >Under some pressure I said I don't use singular they or words like chairwoman but solve the problem other ways (with examples)." She said the moderator linked to her question and called her a bigot. From what I have been able to gather, it would have been very difficult to comply with the proposed CoC without literally asking someone what their ponouns are or risk a villation. Whether or not the latter would have been actually enforced I can't say, but it all sounds rather half baked and would have led to a very vague definition of how one person is allowed to address another. I also don't agree at all with the set of new nonsense pronouns like ze and xi. It's not useful as a language construct and I'm not ready to hand over the linquistic reins to a tiny minority. >The real number of people who would be happier with a non-cis identity is probably much higher, somewhere around 5-10% by my estimate. I can see why you doubt the 0.6% number (many people won't admit it), and that's fair, but your number sounds completely fictional. 10%?! C'mon. That requires some backing up.
- 7y ago
- damnyou 7y agoThere absolutely is a right to be treated with respect in professional settings. Part of respecting people is using the names and pronouns they ask you to use.