3 ms·
Very. They may very well take into account your grades and SAT score to determine feasibility of repayment. You act as if the SAT score is a predictive of futu
by scarface74 7y ago
Very. They may very well take into account your grades and SAT score to determine feasibility of repayment.
You act as if the SAT score is a predictive of future success. Do you know how easy it is for parents of means to pay for “sat tutorials” that will help their kids improve their scores significantly? Ask me how I know.
They may and why shouldn't they? This will deter expensive colleges and push students to cheaper alternatives like trade schools, community colleges and state schools. What's wrong with that?
So only the rich should go to the good schools?
People who can't pay back loans? I don't follow your point. Are you saying that loans should be made without consideration of feasibility of repayment?
Student loans are or should be based on the ability to pay back loans based on future earnings. Most loans are based on credit, prior repayment history and income - three things that students don’t have.
- sokoloff 7y agoCollege Board suggests that going from 0 to “6-8 hours” of prep is good for about 90 points and to 20 hours is good for only an additional 25 points. It would seem folly to take the test with 0 prep and there’s a Khan Academy free prep course that you could use for the 20 hours of prep. Given that, I’m not so sure that intensive prep is going to boost someone’s score significantly beyond basic prep.
- scarface74 7y agoAgain of course the College Board has every reason to perpetuate the myth that the SAT is about college readiness and not about how much access you have to tutorials. Do you really think some free online tutorials are as good as $100/hour private tutor who is a college professor that we got for my son or in my case having a mother who was not only a high school Math teacher but also taught SAT tutorials? Do you really think the latter had no bearing on me having to highest SAT score in my school and the second highest in the district with 800 seniors? I’m not bragging. I didn’t exactly live in a top ranked school system in the small town south.
- sokoloff 7y agoBoth my parents were math teachers. I qualified for SMPY/SET (and came from a rural high school where only ~10% went on to four-year colleges). I am fairly convinced that outcome was likely from years of math education in daily life, on car trips, doing math puzzles with my parents, etc. We’re doing the same with our kids now. My daughter just scored perfect on the SSAT practice math test and finished in half the allotted time. My total extent of “dedicated” prep was under an hour. Our total extent of informal prep was thousands of hours over nearly a decade. (That test isn’t nearly as difficult as the SAT, of course.) I suspect your mom had more to do with your outcome based on years than the expensive tutor did in a few dozen hours. (I’ll also not hesitate to do that if I think it’s needed.)
- scarface74 7y agoDoesn’t that kind of make my point? That kids who either grow up in an environment where they have affluent parents with access to resources or in my case, highly educated parents teaching me what ended up being 11th grade math in 8th grade is advantageous? That still doesn’t make the SAT unbiased.
- sokoloff 7y agoWell, the question is whether you were simultaneously prepared for the SAT and for college by 18 years of daily reinforcement of the value of education and practical subject matter drilling? I believe I was, far more than someone whose parents were equally loving and caring, but who worked in a factory or a trade. If your upbringing was causal in preparation for both, it seems the college board might be correct in claiming that the SAT measures college readiness.
- macspoofing 7y ago>You act as if the SAT score is a predictive of future success. It's a predictor of your odds of graduating from University. >Do you know how easy it is for parents of means to pay for “sat tutorials” that will help their kids improve their scores significantly? Children of Parents who care about their education will do well. News at 11. >So only the rich should go to the good schools? That's not what I said at all. There are lots of good schools providing good education out there. State universities, by and large, are phenomenal, frequently with a good tuition for in-state students. You don't need a boutique humanities degree from a high priced private college. You can leave those to the rich. >Student loans are or should be based on the ability to pay back loans based on future earnings Sure. I don't disagree with that. It's why nobody complains about doctor school debt load, because their field pays well. What's disgusting is giving a non-affluent student tens of thousands per year in debt to get a humanities degree. And that's the problem .... we're not discriminating enough by the chosen degree. Federal loans should discriminate by the program. >Most loans are based on credit, prior repayment history and income - three things that students don’t have. You're still operating within the current system where tuition has been distorted due to massive injection of federally guaranteed loans into the system. There is no reason why you shouldn't be able to choose a good school and work part-time or do school part-time and pay your way (at least mostly). This is possible today even in the distorted market. And finally, are you really arguing that loans should be given to individuals who cannot afford them and will not afford them with the degree they will get??