8 ms·
The three parties are schools, teenagers, and the government. More than 90% of existing student loans, and nearly all new loans, are issued by the government.
by rayiner 7y ago
The three parties are schools, teenagers, and the government. More than 90% of existing student loans, and nearly all new loans, are issued by the government.
The student loan system will cost the government $170 billion in losses over 10 years, because interest doesn’t cover money written off due to hardships and loan forgiveness. The non-dischargability of student loans protects the government from further losses.
Non-dischargability is a reasonable feature given the other aspect of federal student loans: they offer income-based repayment. Under Obama’s REPAYE, your loan payments are capped at 15% of your discretionary income.
- dahart 7y ago> The student loan system will cost the government $170 billion in losses over 10 years I don’t doubt this, but it’s a statement that focuses only on losses and completely ignores the economic benefits of the educated workforce. $170 billion over ten years is on the order of 1% of education spending. Since graduates and postgraduates are earning, on average, roughly 2x and 3x non-graduates respectively, the extra income taxes paid by the non-defaulting group of college graduates alone makes the loan forgiveness losses a drop in the bucket, the income makes up for the losses many times over.
- rossdavidh 7y agoOnce the job market got better a couple years ago, the percentage of job postings which required a college degree dropped. In other words, the "requirement" was mostly a way of filtering, not something that actually increased productivity. Speaking as a person with two degrees myself, I can say that non-degreed programmers seem to be just as productive as those with degrees. In fact, CS majors in particular have a problem just solving the problem in front of them, and often want to over-engineer things using the techniques and patterns they learned in school that are applicable to huge systems, whereas non-degreed programmers often just solve the actual problem they have without trying to justify (in their own minds) years spent learning other techniques. I am not at all convinced that a college-educated workforce is more productive, for more than half the jobs in which it is required.
- dahart 7y agoProductivity isn’t the metric that determines whether the government recoups student loan defaults, income is. And the income of graduates is still multiples that of non-graduates, as shown by the data in this article.
- malvosenior 7y agoCorrelation does not equal causation. There's a very broad spectrum of people who do not have degrees. It's very likely that if you took those same people earning degrees and had them enter the workforce instead, they'd have equal or greater pay.
- dahart 7y agoThat isn’t supported by the data we actually have. Please take a look at Figure 3 on page 39.
- malvosenior 7y agoThat data doesn't reference the point I'm making. What I'm saying is that it's very possible that if the same people that got bachelor degrees instead entered the workplace, they'd have equal or greater lifetime earnings. To put it another way, earnings are correlated with an individual's talent and drive. Currently, many of those people end up getting degrees. It's a correlation, it's not the degrees that are causing the jump in earnings, it's the individual's skills.
- dahart 7y agoYou’re right, figure 3 doesn’t answer your question. But your point/topic is not addressing my original point. My point above was that income before taxes alone is what you need to evaluate whether the student loan program offsets the student loan default rate. The financial return on investment of the student loan program is determined solely by the increase in income, not the wealth premium. To address your separate point directly, there are studies that attempt to directly answer the question you’re asking. For example: http://conference.iza.org/conference_files/CoNoCoSk2011/gensowski_m6556.pdf http://conference.iza.org/conference_files/CoNoCoSk2011/gens... However, your conclusion isn’t shared by the authors. They show a positive return on college degrees, it’s just smaller than the unadjusted difference in income. One probable factor for this is cultural bias toward giving jobs to people with degrees, and paying employees more who have degrees. Individual skills alone do not explain the difference in earnings, so despite the fact that talent correllates with income, the correlation is not 1, and thus it is not likely that the same people earn equal or greater without a degree than with. It is likely that the same person without a degree will earn less than with a degree, on average.
- xyzzyz 7y ago> Since graduates and postgraduates are earning, on average, roughly 2x and 3x non-graduates respectively The original paper that this whole discussion is happening in the context of literally says that the college premium is very low, and for non whites practically zero. The whole issue is that society-wide, college education doesn’t increase the wages of people. Yes, the college educated people make much more than those without a degree, but the question is how much they’d make on average if those same people didn’t get a degree, and as the paper argues, only a little less if at all.
- dahart 7y agoNo, income taxes are extracted before the premium is calculated. I’m not talking about the wealth premium that a degree gives you, I’m talking about the income taxes that the government extracts from people who have degrees, which is completely unaffected by the recent downward trend in the wealth premium that this paper is calculating. This is a case where the absolute, uncontrolled data is very important to differentiate from the adjusted, controlled data.
- sokoloff 7y agoWhat the “other” side is arguing is that if you’re using these income taxes as justification for the government backed loans because those loans allow the attendance of college, then it matters whether or not those same people going directly into the workforce, starting working 4 years earlier, and using their talent and ambition would end up paying a similar or greater amount of income tax. In short, you’re saying only the outcome matters and they’re saying the outcome might not be caused by college attendance.
- dahart 7y agoI’m not saying that only the outcome matters, I’m saying that the government’s financial investment on the student loan program is seeing high positive returns right now, despite the default rate on those loans.
- 7y ago
- avisser 7y ago> The non-dischargability of student loans protects the government from further losses. This one feels like a "true in theory, but not practice." Since the change was recent, we don't know how it will turn out, but it seems _very_ likely that some percentage of folks will die with outstanding student loans. If tuition keeps rising, it will be a non-trivial amount of money.
- droithomme 7y ago> Under Obama’s REPAYE, your loan payments are capped at 15% of your discretionary income. What happens to the many students who are paying at less than their interest accumulation? Does the federal government pay the difference so their loans don't at least keep growing, or does the amount they owe just keep getting bigger and bigger? And in either case, wouldn't such a capped payment scheme be advantageous primarily to the lender collecting the interest?
- brownbat 7y agoThese are good points and make me want to go back and yell at the study authors for pointing fingers at 2005 while ignoring the REPAYE Act. I think it's better terms than even you said -- 10% of discretionary. Discretionary is AGI minus 150% of the poverty rate... a real hardship borrower--say the barista with a million dollar pottery degree--could easily qualify for a $0/mo payment then have all loans discharged after 20 years. (That forgiveness would result in a massive tax bill, however...) My only remaining quibble is that while private loans might be 7-8% of all loans, they're still large in absolute terms, and seem to cluster around the most problematic areas of education, like unaccredited schools. Yet somehow they seem to have the benefit of both worlds, nondischargability without income based repayment, unless I'm missing something. May not be the cornerstone issue here, but still seems like the policy on private educational loans could be better. After your comment, poked around, this history seemed especially useful to fill in some of the gaps I had on the policy history here: https://www.savingforcollege.com/article/history-of-student-loans-bankruptcy-discharge https://www.savingforcollege.com/article/history-of-student-... Thanks, you changed my mind.