4 ms·
I'm thinking of applying to YC this fall. I have capital, but little business experience. My product and niche is pretty cool and very research heavy. YC's 7%
by echelon 7y ago
I'm thinking of applying to YC this fall. I have capital, but little business experience. My product and niche is pretty cool and very research heavy.
YC's 7% is a pretty heavy take if I already have a few million in self-funding. Is this negotiable?
I think an exit for what I'm pursuing is very high if we can grow fast enough. (Possibly become the incumbent.) It's a new market and absolutely trounces an existing one.
- lisper 7y ago> little business experience Yes, that's clear just from the fact that you're asking this question. > YC's 7% is a pretty heavy take This is a FAQ and here is the stock answer: if you think that participating in YC will increase the value of your company by more than 7% than it would otherwise be, then it's a win. Otherwise not. That is true regardless of the circumstances. If what you say is true then you should have investors beating down your door whether or not you're in YC.
- beambot 7y agoSuch a negative undertone... And very unhelpful. "(...) if you think that participating in YC will increase the value (...)" is exactly half of what the commentor was asking (indirectly): is the value of YC worth 7%? That one's nuanced -- echelon, feel free to hit me up via email if you want to discuss (see profile). The other half of the question (is there any wiggle room?) is almost universally "no" to my knowledge. Echelon also already stated that they have investors -- self-investment, but still.
- lisper 7y ago> is the value of YC worth 7%? There is no universal answer to that question. For some companies the answer is clearly "yes", for others it is clearly "no", and for some it's a tough call. But there is absolutely no way anyone could give a more specific answer without knowing a whole lot more about what's going on. That is not something that should have to be explained to you unless you are a totally clueless noob. That is not a value judgement. There is nothing wrong with being a clueless noob. Everyone starts out that way. Echelon even came right out and said that he (she?) had "little business experience". But I'm not convinced that Echelon was really being sincere about this because he (she?) then went on to strongly imply that his company was so bad-ass that YC should be willing to seriously consider changing their standard terms for the privilege of being allowed in. Echelon is almost certainly wrong about this [1]. So "I have little business experience" sounded to me like a humblebrag. My answer was intended to convey the following message: Yes, Echelon, your lack of business experience was evident even before you told us, and though you don't seem to have fully taken this on board, it is a serious threat to your success. You are almost certainly not as bad-ass as you seem to think you are. Not yet. Maybe I should have spelled all that out originally, but I was in a hurry. --- [1] Since I am passing judgement on Echelon's odds of success on very little data, I feel I should give you some of my bona-fides: I have been a principal (founder or co-founder) in six startups and invested in about 20 others. Just this year I am closing out an investment fund that I managed which had an IRR of 70%. I've seen success, and I've seen failure, and while there is obviously no reliable way to make these predictions, there are a few warning signs that manifest very early that have in my experience proven to be very good predictors of failure, and signaling that you think you're bad-ass when you pretty clearly aren't is one of them.
- new2628 7y agoI think you got the math wrong. Say your company value was $100. After it increases by 7%, it is $107. But now you own 93% of it, which is about $99.5. So you need to increase it in value by about 8% to be worth it.
- irjustin 7y ago100% you should. Get the optionality to decline if you believe it is too expensive. IMHO, 7% to learn good business sense is very cheap from guys who have seen it all. > Is this negotiable? From my understanding, it is not, but if you get an offer to join, you can try always try and negotiate. > I think an exit for what I'm pursuing is very high if we can grow fast enough. (Possibly become the incumbent.) It's a new market and absolutely trounces an existing one. While you might believe this and it very well could be true, these words are uttered by too many startups/founders, so the words don't exactly carry weight. Disruption, taking over, etc etc. These words used to mean something closer to 2010. Today it's largely noise and words pale in comparison to track record and strong numbers. > I have capital, but little business experience. Where does this capital come from? Self? Self funding is always cool to keep 100% control, but taking on investors also helps get strong advice, ideally from industry leaders, while opening doors. Keeps one from a dangerous, self ruining, echo chamber - which by your own admission, sounds like this could happen.
- contingencies 7y agoI have capital, but little business experience. My product and niche is pretty cool and very research heavy. Sounds like you are motivated. How much of the research would you be doing yourself? How much do you anticipate needing to spend? If you have both capital and motivation, then consider moving somewhere cheap and investing your own time to maintain complete ownership. You can get all the hand-wavey advice online, YC videos, books, etc. My only advice would be don't discount the importance of marketing. "Build it and they will come" doesn't work. If possible, get a few committed or LOI (potential) customers and some small income guarantee first.
- echelon 7y ago> How much of the research would you be doing yourself? All of it. That's what evenings and weekends have been for awhile now. > How much do you anticipate needing to spend? Equipment is going to be a huge expenditure. The software and the configuration adds all the value. I'll try to self-fund as long as I can, but if/when it catches on, I don't want to be caught off guard without funding while the big players step in. At some point this is going to have to grow fast to stay ahead. If I'm at all right about the market. I suppose I'd better meet some people now that I can start conversations with when I need to.
- contingencies 7y agoEquipment is going to be a huge expenditure. As a hardware startup currently spending big on manufacturing equipment, I feel your pain. I've seen a few hardware startups use alternative approaches to this space, which depending upon your target business model may be viable. One option is, if you are selling hardware with your own software and configuration, the hardware manufacturer may gift/loan/discount development hardware to you to facilitate your development work. Another option is leasing or timeshare of the equipment. Finally, vendor financing may allow you to defer payment for 12-24 months without the overhead of seeking external capital. Outside of the above methods, at a business process level having a rapid and well documented pipeline for per-unit assembly that does not necessitate pre-purchase can help to defer per-unit costs (shift from pre-fab to post-purchase fab) without greatly blowing out lead time from the customer perspective.
- hinkley 7y agoJust an armchair inhabitant here, but I'm wondering if you've got the question backward. That is, instead of negotiating down the take, what help could they give you that would make it worth that 7% to you? What would be worth the opportunity cost?