4 ms·
This could go very bad for Sonos. Imagine a virus that looks for Sonos devices on a network and bricks them all via "recycle mode"! The API probably isn't eve
by echelon 7y ago
This could go very bad for Sonos.
Imagine a virus that looks for Sonos devices on a network and bricks them all via "recycle mode"!
The API probably isn't even locked down. I think it's unauthenticated SOAP/UPnP.
An even dumber attack: guests with your wifi credentials can download the Sonos app and break your gear. It's entirely unauthenticated.
- rmtech 7y ago> Imagine a virus that looks for Sonos devices on a network and bricks them all via "recycle mode"! This would be an incredible public service. Unfortunately I don't have the skills to do it so I won't.
- tripzilch 7y agoI mean it really wouldn't, because the virus would be dooming the devices to go into "recycle or trash" option, instead of the "reuse" option. And otherwise it would just piss off Sonos owners?
- ThiefMaster- 7y agoIf it's purely server-side it would force them to un-recycle everything, which would be a good thing.
- ThiefMaster- 7y agoYou probably don't need a virus or anything running in the end user's network. If your Sonos can access the API to mark a device as recycled, so can you. So if you can predict serial numbers or just bruteforce them (depending on how complex they are) you might be able to brick every single Sonos out there... I highly doubt they assign unique keypairs etc. to every single device...
- throwaway100773 7y agoIm in the market for sound equipment. I just crossed these guys off my list.
- remote_phone 7y agoThey will brick your older speakers or remove functionality. I have 7 Sonos speakers, spending $3-4k on them because quite frankly I love them and the technology was great. I bought a soundbar for my TV with sub and surround speakers and they sound fantastic, and being able to use them to play music was amazing. But then they started removing functionality from their app, and the Play 1s don’t even work with the iPhone anymore unless you have a streaming service or you set up a music service. The ability to just play music and then play it on your speakers is gone. And they don’t give a fuck. They are completely unapologetic and they just forget about their older speakers like a bad habit and that’s why I will never buy another one again. And their app is getting worse, they are forcing logging in to monitor your usage, etc. It’s infuriating. Their technology was amazing 5 years ago but now it’s annoying.
- hurrdurr2 7y agoSame here. The only way to get these kinds of asinine behavior to stop is to hurt them in their pocket book; since it's apparently the only thing they care about.
- matttproud 7y agoSeparate from this issue here, Sonos should be off your list. The UX becomes progressively worse and opaque, your time will be wasted owing to mandatory software updates, needless churn, etc. I have been a user since 2014, and I emphatically will not continue to be their customer once my existing devices bite the dust.
- staktrace 7y agoThis describes my experience exactly as well.
- asenchi 7y agoI bought two speakers they stopped supporting new features a few months later with no plans to support them. I would highly recommend against them. On their own the devices work “most of the time” but i have more trouble with them than I ever expected to have. I’ll never buy another Sonos product.
- nullc 7y ago> This could go very bad for Sonos. How could it? It's all server side. If such a virus existed, they'd just undo all the 'recycling' after the day it started circulating.
- echelon 7y agoThere's both a hardware and software bricking component. Edit: I reread the thread and now I'm not so sure. It might be entirely software blacklisting. But if that's the case, can't you ip blackhole Sonos' servers and still have it all work?
- tinodotim 7y agoAnd spoof what ever they're sending from the speaker? Because the whole "recycle" mode is about getting that rebate.
- TheRealPomax 7y agoyou think Sonos' equipment works without an internet connection?
- echelon 7y agoI think so. The clients are all SOAP/UPnP, and there are lots of open source clients and API bindings. I could be wrong, though.
- lightedman 7y agoServer is hardware, controlling OS and such is software. Both bricking components are present.