6 ms·
> Looks like a major redistribution of wealth, from taxpayers to educational institutions. :-/ This is my surprised face. This is my beef with free college. It
by rayiner 7y ago
> Looks like a major redistribution of wealth, from taxpayers to educational institutions. :-/ This is my surprised face.
This is my beef with free college. It's a huge amount of public money going to benefit people who don't need it, all for an extremely tenuous promise of upward mobility. Kids growing up in real urban poverty aren't going to college, tuition-free or not. The hurdles keeping them from upward mobility are happening at a much earlier point than the tuition payment deadline.
And the lower middle class kids who might go if college were tuition free--are they really being helped? AOC graduated with a BA cum laude from Boston University and went back to bar-tending afterward. Absolutely no criticism of that--it's honest work. But what does that story--which is common--say about the value of a BA from a college outside the top tier? I studied for the LSAT in Atlanta. I was working as an engineer at the time--all my Georgia Tech classmates had gotten good jobs in Atlanta within six months of graduation. But the folks in my LSAT class, who mostly graduated from places like Georgia State with a BA, were doing things like bar-tending, or administrative roles they could easily have done without a college degree. One of my friends works at a brewery--he says that all but one of the guys bottling/packing the beer have college degrees. Is college really adding value for these people? Or would making it free just transfer wealth from taxpayers to college professors and administrators, while graduates end up doing the same jobs they'd be qualified to do without a degree?
- bhupy 7y agoThere's some mainstream literature (with data) that corroborates this point of view: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2017-10-30/free-college-would-help-the-rich-more-than-the-poor https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2017-10-30/free-c...
- snowwrestler 7y agoThis might come as a shock, but AOC is a member of Congress now. (It's silly to judge the value of a college education by the jobs that people get the first few years after college.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 7y agoWell, that covers 435 Boston University grads. What about the rest of them?
- fzeroracer 7y agoCouldn't the same be said about any level of education? The law of averages means that yes, on average not everyone is going to see massive success. That doesn't meant we should deprive them the right to get an education.
- tptacek 7y agoWhat does the law of averages have to say about 435 out of 2 million? My point is that Rayiner was more right than the parent comment: AOC's election doesn't refute the point that a huge number of humanities degree recipients are durably underemployed.
- fzeroracer 7y agoAnd my point is I'm not sure why that matters. A huge number of highschool graduates are unemployed, therefore does that mean we should start charging for basic education? Just start defunding it further because it has no value? This linking of career to college education is exactly the problem I'm talking about. People should be free to study what they want, because educated citizens have more value than what they can contribute to the corporate bottom line. European countries understand this and it's time we follow suit. And some of the best software engineers I've known came from education such as the humanities or teaching.
- tptacek 7y agoResources are finite. People should be free to study what they want, but we shouldn't be allocating resources to subsidize all postsecondary study for its own sake. This is why a lot of people think community college should be free: it's largely pin-compatible with the first several years of university education, but has none of the social status and leisure components that have turned college – yes, including state universities – into a Veblen good.
- fzeroracer 7y agoI mean, you're essentially arguing that people like me (people that grew up in deep poverty) wouldn't benefit from a college degree, but here I am. A software engineer because I was able to afford college through benefits and grants that made it near-free. I didn't go to a top tier college. I went to the local community college and used that to go to the local University to get a degree in CS. Well, here I am. Are you saying I don't exist? Without my degree which opened quite a few doors, I'd be still back home in poverty.
- JamesBarney 7y agoI don't think that's what he's arguing. I think he believes there are some people who - grew up in deep poverty - graduated highschool with the grades/SATs to get into a STEM program - didn't get enough grants/loans to go to college - would have gone to college had it been free - and would have graduated with a worthwhile degree had they gone but they're outnumbered by their peers who wouldn't benefit from free college, but would still have to pay extra taxes, or receive less in benefits to fund a bunch of upper/middle class kids art pursuing history degrees.