5 ms·
>This is telemetry and it's unacceptable. I dislike the idea of tying particular political or economic philosophies together with a tech stack like Linux. Eve
by Barrin92 7y ago
>This is telemetry and it's unacceptable.
I dislike the idea of tying particular political or economic philosophies together with a tech stack like Linux.
Everyone can distribute linux distributions however they see fit, it's an open platform and if that includes telemetry by default that's fine too as users have choice. I don't think anyone uses a Canonical distro and is genuinely upset or surprised about this particular benign case.
The linux distribution space is truly one of the few places where we can't make any excuses about market power or lack of choice. There are a billion distributions, almost all of them free. Users will pick accordingly, and my sense is that virtually nobody cares about this particular case of telemetry.
- tjoff 7y agoI am upset, and I do use ubuntu, and I am reconsidering that. It isn't about politics nor economics. It's about privacy and control. That is linked with Linux for a lot of users. And Linux users have a pretty good situation in regard to this. But it is starting to erode and if allowed can only get worse. It is unacceptable and the fact that canonical don't realize this is why I'm thinking of alternatives. Especially considering the use case. Either they haven't got a clue, or they are testing the waters. Does not look good any way you look at it.
- zerkten 7y ago>> I am upset, and I do use ubuntu, and I am reconsidering that. Good for you, but don't you sort of expect this with Ubuntu? It's obviously pushing in a different direction from the likes of Debian. I'm not sure most reasonable people have much sympathy for you here. >> It isn't about politics nor economics. It's about privacy and control. That is linked with Linux for a lot of users. And Linux users have a pretty good situation in regard to this. Privacy and control are intermingled with politics and economics. A quick analysis of Ubuntu and Canonical would have suggested that this risk exists for you. >> But it is starting to erode and if allowed can only get worse. You are naive if you think that it won't erode further in your view. Economics and the desires of Ubuntu audience will result in further "features" like this. It's inherent in their mission and they don't particularly care about you. >> It is unacceptable and the fact that canonical don't realize this is why I'm thinking of alternatives. They do realize this. They just don't care. You are the type of customer they want to fire because you aren't their audience, yet fight their choices. >> Especially considering the use case. Either they haven't got a clue, or they are testing the waters. Does not look good any way you look at it. It doesn't look good to you, but it's a trade-off with their users because it's intrinsically tied to their audience, economics, politics, etc. Don't forget that audiences can change. The customers that brought them to this point may not be those who take them to their next goal. It's just business. You can say Linux is more than business, but it doesn't really make an impactful argument.
- folkhack 7y ago> I don't think anyone uses a Canonical distro and is genuinely upset or surprised about this particular benign case. I've had to use Ubuntu in an environment with high security needs/regulations. I've had to disable this exact feature because leaking OS versions, network information, etc. externally via that user agent string was unacceptable from a security standpoint. I was upset that something as simple as a motd had been retooled to leak data. > and my sense is that virtually nobody cares about this particular case of telemetry. And in my real-world experience I've been paid to care. When forced to work with Ubuntu (which is everywhere these days) I have to "reign it in" with custom images/scripts/etc. > I dislike the idea of tying particular political or economic philosophies together with a tech stack like Linux. This isn't "political or economic philosophies" this is security 101. Leaking data like my OS version, IP addresses, when admins are doing their work, etc to the public internet is a hard "no" for anyone who's operating in any semblance of "best practices".
- lonelappde 7y agoWhat high security environment browses the hostile public web? You're afraid of the public internet seeing your IP address? The address that is required to serve responses to your requests?
- folkhack 7y agoI still consider originating IP address to be a leak - what about private intranets, processing-only infrastructure etc? Not everything is a traditional public-hosting model. In the screenshot posted you can see the following data is being sent out: ```bash USER_AGENT="curl/$curl_ver $lsb $platform $cpu $uptime cloud_id/$cloud_id" ``` This is 100% not acceptable. That data is NOT to leave my environments.
- Barrin92 7y agonot doubting your experiences but just out of interest if you can tell, what security-relevant sector uses stock ubuntu and exposes themselves to the internet like this? I've never seen a setup like that before.
- CaptArmchair 7y agoAnd yet, technology stacks aren't exempt from social and economic dynamics. Technology stacks are tools, means to a wide variety of ends. And as such, if they are freely available, people can and will use them for whatever purpose or need they seem fit. As such, linux is just as much a product and a service as it is a technology tied to very real markets and niches. And it with that come the exact same concerns you'd find in any other market. Your observation is totally correct: there are tons of distributions and there is plenty of choice and people don't care. But that choice is far from granted, and it's not an argument that deprecates questions about moral responsibility: Are companies providing a service/product entirely responsible for the consequences? Or are customers entirely responsible for their own choices and behavior? Or is it both? Let's use an analogy to demonstrate. Bread is a great example. The vast majority of people eat bread daily. And so there's a huge demand. But the market has consolidated in some places and so many people end up buying bread from retail chains. Sadly, such bread is a processed food and contains many ingredients that aren't that healthy such as emulgators (E-numbers), or loads of sugar. You could argue that people still have a choice: You could go to an artisanal baker. Or you could bake your own bread: the recipe isn't that difficult and requires few raw ingredients. So, why aren't people doing that when they know retail chain bread isn't good for them? Three reasons: because artisanal bread is expensive; it's a different shop from a centralized retail shop and making decent bread takes time and skill. Consumers simply calculate cost/benefits: buying cheap bread is far more convenient in the short run, even though the long term consequences may cost more. Okay, so how does that hold up with Linux? Same thing. Ubuntu is huge because it was successful in it's marketing early on; and it did a bang up job in creating an effective onboarding experience for new linux users. You can argue about their design choices over the past 15 years, but in the end, they have been ahead of the competition when it comes to tapping into a new generation of users. As time went on, what you see is that the Ubuntu community has spawned a huge volume of documentation: tutorials, videos, stackoverflow posts,... Google "how to install sound drivers in linux" and your first hit will be tutorial for Ubuntu. Whereas trying to find the same information for lesser known distributions might be just a tad harder. And that's what makes all the difference. Convenience. If you spend an evening trying to fix your damn audio after first installing Slackware, and all you find is Ubuntu tutorials, you will likely just switch over to... Ubuntu. Especially if you aren't particularly interested in the design philosophy of Slackware, or who these Canonical people are anyway. You simply want to listen to your favorite Spotify playlist, right? So, the issue here is that both retail chains and Canonical understand that the vast majority of people simply want convenience and they will easily choose it over principle or their own self-interest. And so, it's extremely tempting to exploit that. The question then becomes whether it's morally right to tap into that and take more from your customers or users then what they are bargaining from. Especially when they aren't really aware you're doing it. Either by using ingredients that aren't prohibited, but clearly unhealthy, or by using techniques to gain more insights about their behavior. Especially when everyone sells them "Linux doesn't do that unlike Apple, Google or Microsoft". And so, ever more people will keep choosing Ubuntu over other distributions, even when they do have a free choice. The mere existence of a choice isn't a defining factor at all, it's everything else: available tutorials, number of users, onboarding experience, how quick they can get things working and so on. Tis where the discussion does turn political. The public space is regulated through laws for many reasons. But such rules and laws aren't static. They can change through political discussion and ever changing power balances. And so, consumer protection laws exist not just to protect individual consumers, but also to ensure that large, unintended second order effects of new products and services don't cause shocks that might derail an arguably stable society. If retail chains are free to add more and more unhealthy ingredients to their food products because that clearly drives costs down and attract more customers, the societal cost will be an increasing number of people who suffer from health concerns linked to consuming those products. Not because people don't mind their health, but because convenience forces them, and the alternatives are simply too costly. By the same token, if companies are free to build in all kinds of telemetry sending scripts, that won't stop people from using those products as they prove to be really convenient. But the societal cost will be that private enterprises are able to derive very accurate profiles about who we are, and what we want, and use those in ways that don't align with the interests of users of their software.