4 ms·
Right and left are arbitrary constructs necessitated by a first past the post voting system. Change the electoral system and you will see much more diverse and
by Animats 7y ago
Right and left are arbitrary constructs necessitated by a first past the post voting system. Change the electoral system and you will see much more diverse and meaningful party affiliation.
Diverse, yes. Meaningful, maybe. Look at Israel right now. 17 parties with seats in the Knesset, none with over 30%, and, after two elections, still no agreement on Prime Minister. Third election coming up.
- black_knight 7y ago> after two elections, still no agreement on Prime Minister. Third election coming up. Parlamentary systems without the option to call re-elections is an attractive alternative. The politicians just can't keep asking people's opinion until they get the answer they want. Then there will have to be compromises, and even the smaller parties can get some of their important causes through.
- raverbashing 7y agoI agree, calling for "new elections" is a cop-out Have an elected parliament sit for at least two years, maybe four, will go some way in making them work out their differences.
- rossdavidh 7y agoSmaller parties have gotten plenty in Israel, sometimes to the point that supporters of the larger parties feel they have less voice than whichever small party holds the balance of power at that moment. Or, as in the current situation, there is simply no agreement, and they go months without a government. It's not clear that an inability to call re-elections would improve Israel's situation; they could be stuck for years with no government.
- zjaffee 7y agoThe situation in Israel only exists because there are multiple layers of opposition at play, the "moderates" are hardly different politically than the conservatives, they just dislike it's leader, where they are unwilling to form a coalition with any of the arab parties in order to form a government.
- CameronNemo 7y agoI agree that parliamentary systems make it difficult to form a government, but I disagree that those 30 parties are less meaningful than major parties in the US or UK. Each one represents a unique community within Israel, reflecting the diversity and disunity of the nation itself. Also I would argue Netanyahu failing to form a government two times is a good sign for Israel. That man is divisive and harmful.