4 ms·
I think the author of this article has no experience with consulting companies. $100/hr is well below what Accenture, IBM Global Services or any of the other bi
by gaius 16y ago
I think the author of this article has no experience with consulting companies. $100/hr is well below what Accenture, IBM Global Services or any of the other big names charge. And clients, by and large, are fine with it; it's just a cost of doing business. And it's hard to argue that any of them haven't "scaled"; Accenture is 200,000 people!
Remember, in business there is no such thing as "cheap" or "expensive". There's "worth the money" or "not". A decision maker has decided that paying a consulting firm $250/hr/consultant is cheaper than it would be to do their own SAP implementation (and in turn, that SAP is worth more than it costs...)
FWIW a consultant as a rule of thumb would probably see 1/5 of his billing rate, tho' I have seen some get 1/3 and some as low as 1/8.
- smartbear 16y agoI'm not talking about IBM, I'm talking about most individuals doing consulting. "Clients by and large are fine with it." --Only big companies are fine with it. If you're a web designer for local business, they would not be fine with it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jbellis 16y ago"If you're a web designer for local business, they would not be fine with it." That's kind of the definition of "clients that are not worth having."
- euroclydon 16y agoI think that "web designer for local business" has finally become doable. I have a few customers where I just resell Wufoo + Weebly or Word Press, at a 25-50% markup. There's no custom code to maintain on my part, and if they ask for features which these platforms can't do, I just say no.
- stcredzero 16y agoSo "clients worth having" = big companies managed by people who don't have the expertise to judge your work who also act as if they're sitting on top of an endless pool of money which they sprinkle around freely because it's not even theirs. I can see the attraction in that. I've seen it up close. It's not worth selling your soul for. Broken systems that lack accountability will destroy your soul, one way or another. You might even be warm, fat, and happy all the while it's happening.
- patio11 16y agoThere are a huge, huge number of clients who are neither sclerotic BigCo nor the corner bakery. My typical client has less than 30 employees, the ability to react to issues fairly quickly by the standards of large corporations (i.e. squash a consequential bug in minutes, do a complete site revamp in weeks), more than enough money to pay any conceivable consulting rate for something with predictable ROI.
- stcredzero 16y agoThere are a huge, huge number of clients who are neither sclerotic BigCo nor the corner bakery. Sounds like you've hit the sweet spot! EDIT: My comments on this article are railing against firms like Accenture, not against folks like Jason.
- gaius 16y agoThat is freelancing, not "being a consulting firm".
- tdavis 16y ago> I think the author of this article has no experience with consulting companies. Jason has extensive experience with consulting companies, as you would know had you taken the 20 seconds necessary to read his bio before starting your argument with ad hominem. Congratulations on following it up with a straw man argument that replaces 99% of companies with the 1% that he blatantly wasn't targeting. sigh
- gaius 16y agosigh indeed. The article should really be titled "The unfortunate math behind freelancing" because that's what it is.
- thinkingeric 16y agoHis breakdown is applicable to service work in general.
- tptacek 16y agoNo it isn't. Different service organizations have wildly different $/headcount ratios with wildly different concentrations of clients and wildly different turnover rates. A gigantic slice of the economy is services work. This blog post is not that slice's Rosetta Stone.
- tdavis 16y agoSo now your argument is that there are about a dozen "consulting companies" in the world and the rest are loose collections of "freelancers"? Banal use of semantics aside, you still haven't said anything that refutes the problems/solutions surrounding "consulting companies" (or "freelancer gaggles" if you prefer) as they were defined in the article.
- gaius 16y agoHis argument hinges on consulting not being worth it at $100/hr - that is true, but it's also irrelevant, since typical consulting firms actually charge much more. Secondly he asserts that consulting doesn't scale. Well, with one example (of many such firms) tipping the scales at 200k employees, that point is demolished too.
- raganwald 16y agoWhen you pay $250 an hour for a major consulting firm, you get $50 worth of consultant, and $200 worth of "Nobody ever got fired for hiring IBM/Accenture/CGI/Thoughtworks." This is not a joke. When it isn't your money, your incentive is to make a decision that cannot be second-guessed. Imagine you do five projects. Accenture come in and have a big heavyweight process and they follow the process each time, and four of the projects are ok but cost 2x what they could have cost, and the fifth project is late and over budget. Well, the fault clearly lies somewhere other than your decision to hire Accenture, they have a process and a brand name! So you blamestorm a bit and it turns out that there were unknown unknowns that couldn't have been foreseen and so on, and you keep your job. But if you decide to hire BoutiqueCo and things go wrong, your head is on the block. If you do this five times and four times you save money but the fifth time things blow up, you're fired. BoutiqueCo don't have any credibility when blaming unknown unknowns with their "agile process" and what-not, and nobody remembers the fact that you saved so much money on the first four projects you could fund the fifth and sixth projects with the savings. Small boutiques cannot get gigs with the companies that can afford to pay the rates of the big firms unless they manage to create a very unique brand or find other markets.
- gaius 16y agoWhere are the boutique agile companies doing cut-price SAP implementations? They don't exist...
- stcredzero 16y agoSAP isn't exactly implemented in the most agile language ever.
- raganwald 16y agoThe reason they don't exist is that even if they worked for free, they can't offer any "Nobody ever got fired for hiring us" value, so nobody doing SAP implementation will hire them. Anybody who can afford SAP can afford to pay the full freight, in which case they want the full package including insurance against being blamed for problems. I was going to add that boutiques can charge the same rate as the big firms, but they do so in different markets. One example: Above I noted that the person buying the service has downside of being blamed but no upside for saving money. That isn't always the case. When the person making the decision is also under a lot of budget pressure, boutiques can make the same hourly rate by being more productive. That productivity often comes at the expense of insurance against blame, for example you can't have as heavyweight a process. But if you are working for someone who cares about the money, being more productive can get you the gig and the rate.
- thisisfmu 16y agoAccenture's revenue per employee is only $113206, or about $56.60/hr on the basis of 2000 working hours per year.
- ams6110 16y agoAccenture employess likely put in a lot more than 2000 hrs/yr, if it's anything like it was when they were called Andersen Consulting. 60-70 hour weeks were the norm for staff consultants. When you were on a project you were expected to be at work before the client arrived and work until after they left. Generally that was roughly 7am - 6pm.
- jonknee 16y agoThat's revenue per employee, not revenue per billable consultant. There are a lot of employees on the payroll that don't bill out hours.
- m1234 16y agoAccenture also has lot of offshore employees whose billing rate is around $20 to $30 per hour.
- stcredzero 16y agoAnd clients, by and large, are fine with it; it's just a cost of doing business. Only because they don't know better. When I was working for a language/IDE vendor, we saw project after project that was 3 to 10 times larger than it had to be. (The project that actually needs more than 12 people in a language like Smalltalk is very exceptional.) Why is it like this? Because they are structurally motivated to waste the client's money. Such companies facilitate a transaction. (Charging hourly for a consultant.) They siphon a little money off of this transaction. Naturally, they are motivated to hire as many consultants as possible. Basically, big consulting company sends people who give off the right competent business-suit vibe. They talk their to the customers, who are usually suits themselves and know almost nothing about making software first-hand, into thinking that their problems are deadly rocket-science and that they are just the uber-competent people to solve the super-hard problem. Then, they turn around and hire the cheapest resources they can (often fresh out of school) herded by a few politically adept managers, and hire them out for the highest mark-up possible. I've also worked at a software product company that actually made most of its money from body-shop consulting. I know it was body shop consulting, because most of their people were hired (by the hundreds and housed in several football-field sized floors) out of local podunk community colleges and didn't know any better than to rewrite doubly linked lists every time they needed a collection. Yes, the product had probably hundreds of doubly linked list implementations in it. It was so bad that one client's IT group wrote what they called "super-link" and heroically rammed it through against amazing amounts of push-back from their management and from the body-shop vendor. What was this controversial thing? A linked list library. [cue dramatic music] Paying for junior programmers to fix their newbie linked-list implementation dozens of times -- this is "the cost of doing business?" I think there's opportunity to disrupt an industry here. On the other hand, the fact that it's this bad indicates that there are very powerful forces maintaining the information asymmetry. EDIT: Let me put it this way -- what if someone tried to bill you big company hourly consulting rates for a dozen newbies repeated debugging their linked-list programming project?
- lsc 16y ago>EDIT: Let me put it this way -- what if someone tried to bill you big company hourly consulting rates for a dozen newbies repeated debugging their linked-list programming project Yeah, sure, you and I would hate that. Anyone spending their own money would. But consulting companies target the publicly traded. the guy making the decision, there's no upside in it for saving money. It gets done or it doesn't. If he hires a big name, he doesn't get fired if it doesn't get done. If he goes with a no-name, that's not so certain. I think this is a natural inefficiency that happens when the decision makers spend other people's money. they spend a lot of that money on insurance. Of course, I'm just bitter because I failed as a body shop, in spite of having very good people who were able to immediately move in to other body shops, getting paid quite a bit more than I billed out retail.
- damoncali 16y agoThe author of that article runs a consulting company.