4 ms·
I know that the dictum to keep politics off of HN has been a dead letter for some time- especially since tech has become overtly non-apolitical in the last few
by Apocryphon 7y ago
I know that the dictum to keep politics off of HN has been a dead letter for some time- especially since tech has become overtly non-apolitical in the last few years- but it's still funny to see pg himself breaking that rule.
- jpitz 7y agoHow is he breaking it?
- Apocryphon 7y agoThis is an essay on politics. It goes to show that people in tech are acknowledging more that the industry is not apolitical and has a very real social and political effect on the world at large, and are so dropping the pretense of lacking political interest. That and like the rest of the world, the tech industry has become increasingly politically polarized over the last half decade.
- namirez 7y agoTo be fair to PG, perhaps, someone else shared his post on HN so he didn't break any rules. On a different note, I guess in the age of Facebook, it's not possible for tech to remain silent on politics whether we like it or not.
- wbronitsky 7y agoI think you have conflated PGs blog with HN. They are firmly separate entities
- wbronitsky 7y agoThe original post was edited completely to make my previous post read as nonsense
- robbrown451 7y agoI would argue that politics is ok to talk about if you are talking about in in the meta sense, as he is. If people were all "accidental moderates," there would be no need to keep politics off HN. The problem is that people pick one of two tribes, and discussions get ugly. If people weren't tribal like that, less of a problem, it's just a bunch of people with opinions all over the place.
- totalZero 7y agoAll politics is meta. Eking out a decision from the great power jumble requires self-awareness about the forces that gyre and gimble therein. Not all politics is tribal. PG explicitly establishes two different cohorts, each with its own way of thinking, from the outset. His argument reifies tribalism.
- robbrown451 7y ago"all politics is meta" That doesn't make sense, or you just don't understand my usage
- totalZero 7y agoYou're saying talking about politics is somehow different than talking about issues. Your "usage" creates this magical escape route where you somehow consider it apolitical (or more acceptable) to comment on political discourse itself. I disagree. Talking about issues is inherently a conversation about politics itself, insofar as the power dynamics involved in making decisions don't magically disappear when we don our academic or self-referential hats. And talking about politics inherently touches the base issues that underpin the discussion, otherwise there is no objective way to judge right and wrong, strong and weak. All politics satisfies both conditions. All politics is about issues, and all politics is meta. In other words, your "usage" is not really meaningful.
- gwbas1c 7y agoFrom https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity The article is more about phycology than politics, IMO.
- grzm 7y ago'pg posted on his own site and did not submit it here. What someone posts on their own site is clearly up to them, and definitely not bound by another site’s discussion guidelines.