9 ms·
Can you expand please on the blocking group messages?
by azinman2 7y ago
Can you expand please on the blocking group messages?
- jachee 7y agoiMessage isn't MMS. Android does group messages with the latter.
- zwily 7y agoiMessage does MMS for group chat with non-iMessage clients.
- jachee 7y agoYes, but what the poster above describes as "locking you out of group messages" sounds like a member of an all-iMessage group switching to android, and the group message continuing on in iMessages-only, rather than being restarted as MMS to include the Android.
- damnyou 7y agoIf you are in an iMessage group chat and you switch to Android, you need to create a new group chat to continue talking to your friends.
- duskwuff 7y agoUm… yes? iMessage is a feature of iOS and macOS. It isn't available on Android devices, and its group chats don't exist outside those platforms. But I don't see how this constitutes Apple "blocking" anything.
- damnyou 7y agoIt's not a position you're put into with WhatsApp or any other app. It is bad for your messaging to be made by the same company as your phone. Some really problematic conflicts of interest.
- duskwuff 7y ago> It's not a position you're put into with WhatsApp or any other app. Sure it is! You can't continue a group conversation from WhatsApp -- or any other messenger, really -- on another messenger service without manually recreating the group. There is literally nothing which makes iMessage unique in this regard.
- MiroF 7y agoWell WhatsApp is free and iMessage has a multiple hundred dollar price tag attached. Apple consciously doesn't make the APIs for iMessage available.
- jdjdjjsjs 7y agoBy that logic WhatsApp isn't free. I have to spend hundreds of dollars upfront to buy a phone, and worse, hundreds of dollars each year to maintain a phone line to use WhatsApp. WhatsApp doesn't provide an API so I could use it on my existing laptop over WiFi for free (the WhatsApp web requires it to be setup on a phone first).
- actsof 7y ago>I have to spend hundreds of dollars upfront to buy a phone But the phone doesn't have to be bought from Facebook, whereas with iMessage you have to pay Apple for a phone. >maintain a phone line to use WhatsApp. I wonder what the reason for this is. Maybe to reduce spam? Data collection?
- MiroF 7y agoBut I get to choose who to pay - and most people already have a phone. maintaining a phone line doesn't cost hundreds of dollars a year
- culturestate 7y ago> ...WhatsApp isn't free. I have to spend hundreds of dollars upfront to buy a phone... WhatsApp works reliably on a staggeringly broad list of devices. You can get a supported phone for, like, $20 and stick a $5-per-month prepaid SIM in it (many of these plans in low-income countries specifically come with WhatsApp allowances) and be connected.
- asdff 7y agoThis function even harms iOS only groupchats. I walk to an area of low reception and try and message the group chat, it defaults as an sms due to the poor signal and breaks the group in the same way. Not sure what advantages an imessage vs sms groupchat even give me in this era of unlimited texting. Pretty hearts?
- duskwuff 7y ago> Not sure what advantages an imessage vs sms groupchat even give me in this era of unlimited texting. Pretty hearts? Some cellular carriers still charge per MMS message, so group chats (which use MMS) can get expensive. MMS group messages also have some undesirable properties -- in particular, adding or removing users from a group is unreliable, because each device is responsible for generating a list of recipients itself. Plus, iMessage uses end-to-end encryption. MMS does not.
- neilalexander 7y agoFalling back to SMS is an option in Settings. I personally have it disabled - when disabled, it spends longer trying to resend the iMessage rather than sending an SMS rather quickly.
- zwily 7y agoOff the top of my head: * more than 10 participants * can set a topic for the group * can add and remove participants * end to end encryption * typing indicators (i think? Can’t remember if these work in groups)
- mulmen 7y agoWell iMessage works over wifi so if you don't have cell service it is handy. I just got home from visiting family and their local airport has no cell service.