5 ms·
DARPA head resigns, moving on to industry
- dpflan 7y agoWhat does this mean for DARPA / the state of DARPA? I just searched and see that Walker was head of DARPA for about 2 years, which seems like a short time. Previous heads' tenures: 1. A. Prabhakar: ~5 years 2. R. Dugan: ~3 years 3. A. Tether: ~8 years
- ghostcluster 7y agocompare that to the heads of other government agencies and the so-called revolving door https://www.opensecrets.org/revolving/top.php?display=I https://www.opensecrets.org/revolving/top.php?display=I
- dpflan 7y agoAre you saying that this is a longer tenure than other industries? I see in the link you shared that "Internet" has 387 people profiled and a high percentage 78.0% (which I don't quite understand, the page seems to be lacking information.)
- ghostcluster 7y agoI haven't dug into the data that deeply but my hunch is this is probably somewhere in the broadly average range of the distribution Just for example: > The most prominent example of the Comcast/FCC revolving door is former FCC commissioner and current Comcast lobbyist Meredith Baker. > Baker, whose views tended to side with the industry even before she went to the FCC, was appointed to to her FCC position in July 2009 and stayed there for nearly two years, cutting her four-year term short in June 2011 to move to Comcast as its senior vice president of government affairs. https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2014/04/the-comcast-fcc-revolving-door/ https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2014/04/the-comcast-fcc-rev...
- dpflan 7y ago(Check out this comment by JonathonW: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21892818 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21892818)
- freyr 7y agoI don’t know about the head role specifically, but DARPA generally has short tenures by design. Each DARPA project lasts two years (with possibility of extension). So a typical DARPA program manager will work in that role for just a couple years before returning to industry.
- JonathonW 7y agoWalker had been acting director of DARPA since January 2017 (eventually formally becoming director in November 2017), so, when his resignation takes effect, he'll have been in the position for three years-- actually a few months longer than Dugan. Historically, Prabhakar and Tether's long tenures in the position are unusual [1], with most directors staying anywhere from one to four years. This mirrors how DARPA works at the lower levels: the revolving door for DARPA Program Managers (and their programs) is very much real and 100% intentional: DARPA PMs are typically recruited from academia or industry, serve 3-5 year terms and then return to work in academia or industry. This keeps fresh talent and fresh ideas moving through the organization, and provides a sense of urgency and time-sensitivity to their work (successful projects get transitioned either commercially or into longer-term programs under other branches of the military-- they don't languish forever within DARPA by design). [1] https://www.darpa.mil/attachments/DARPA_Directors_Sheet-web.pdf https://www.darpa.mil/attachments/DARPA_Directors_Sheet-web....
- dpflan 7y agoThank you for clarifying! This approach makes sense.
- cushychicken 7y agoSeems like a smart way to do business. (Or, research, as it were.) Too many orgs end up resting on their laurels - either getting too focused on research and not executing on technical advantages generated by that research, or too focused on execution and not enough into research.
- taneq 7y ago> Walker will move on to a position in industry It's really hard to read this and remain non-cynical. Were any big contracts signed recently?
- GlenTheMachine 7y agoThere are SO MANY laws preventing this sort of thing. I take the training occasionally; just the refresher takes half a day. The full training to be a Contracting Officer’s Representative (a “COR”) takes a full week. Suffice it to say: having Walker’s experience and contacts will secure him a nice position, and rightly so. But if that position regards a government action in which he had any role he would likely end up in prison, and the contractor would be heavily fined and maybe barred from competing for government business.
- tomjakubowski 7y agoThere may be laws but are they actually enforced?
- frank2 7y agoUS Federal laws are enforced vigourously enough that I think the burden of proof is on those who claim they are not enforced. Whether the laws are effective at preventing the behavior they are designed to prevent is another story.
- decebalus1 7y agoThis book https://www.amazon.com/Chickenshit-Club-Department-Prosecute-Executives/dp/1501121367 https://www.amazon.com/Chickenshit-Club-Department-Prosecute... has lots of proof.
- pathseeker 7y agoThat's not a good point of evidence. The laws in question are regarding government employees self-dealing by awarding contracts in exchange for employment/favors later. >Why were no bankers put in prison after the financial crisis of 2008? This question is enough to dismiss the entire book outright. The financial crisis of 2008 was caused by a systemic risk modelling failure. This led to banks relying too heavily on the stability of mortgages. Bad business decisions are not criminal, that's why the bankers weren't arrested. Here are some other questions for you: Why were no energy industry employees/CEOs put in prison after the 1973/1979 energy crises? Why were no tech people arrested after the dot-com bust? Entire industries have systemic failures that impact broad society. That is not evidence of a crime and implying so in a leading question to your book means pandering to a specific political view or just gullible people.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- yellow_lead 7y ago> Walker will move on to a position in industry, though a DARPA spokesman did not reveal where. Any ideas as to where? Lockheed, Palantir, Google?
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoIt's DARPA, not Darpa. It's the Hacker News submission title replacement code again, it's not the first time that the acronyms in the titles has been replaced improperly. To those who didn't know its existence... 1. It properly capitalizes the title, making it more pleasant to read, and it also automatically removes the ALL CAPS titles. But from time to time, it makes the title worse by removing the proper acronyms. 2. It removes buzzwords from the title, which is generally good for anti-karma farming, but sometimes it does this even if such use is technically appropriate. For example, "massively parallel" becomes "parallel". Submitter, please change the title back manually. And moderators, please update your code to recognize more acronyms, such as DARPA, CSAIL, etc.
- the-dude 7y agohttps://english.stackexchange.com/questions/51924/proper-capitalization-of-commonly-used-acronyms https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/51924/proper-cap...
- dragonwriter 7y ago> It's DARPA, not Darpa. Well, that depends on house style; it's not unheard of to set acronyms (in the narrow sense; that is, abbreviations pronounced as words) in initial caps rather than all caps, though that's (IME, at least) a more common style for English publications outside of the US.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThis seems pretty normal. I worked at a startup company founded by ex-DARPA people and I got the impression that it’s standard procedure there to move in and out of the agency and while in private business receiving funding from the agency.
- crocodiletears 7y agoThis is a bit tangential to the topic at hand, but do you believe that their previous experience at DARPA made the company's culture/workflow distinct from other startups in any significant way?
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThey were very hands off. Probably the same way they operated as DARPA project managers. It often felt that the CEO and CTO watched us from a distance. But they were excellent at writing, presenting and talking to people.
- Ericson2314 7y agoDARPA is pretty neat. Pitty it's part of the defense department and not something shared between them all. Tech isn't just good for war and ads, ya know. Make it ARPA again in name and flesh!
- xvilka 7y agoThere are also ARPA-E[1] for Department of Energy and IARPA[2] for Intelligence Community. [1] https://arpa-e.energy.gov/ https://arpa-e.energy.gov/ [2] https://www.iarpa.gov/ https://www.iarpa.gov/
- darksaints 7y agoThey do have some programs modeled after ARPA, such as ARPA-E. Unfortunately, they'll likely never get the level of funding that DARPA has enjoyed.
- eob 7y agoTo the folks reaching immediately for the “revolving door” observations: DARPA is one instance where churn is a feature, not a bug. Or if not a feature, at least an intentional design choice rather than an accident of corruption. Various rules about the way the USG works make it really challenging to innovate in the way private industry can. DARPA isn’t perfect, but it’s a pretty good effort to engineer an ecosystem within the USG that optimizes for “wild idea pursuit” rather than “Spec’ed hourly labor” (which governs the rest of the defense complex). Part of that ecosystem is regular rotation of leadership to bring in fresh ideas and agendas. Another part of that ecosystem is the acknowledgement that you have to spend money on 99 bad ideas before you find the one nugget of gold. Basically, the same observation that governs VC portfolio math but the DARPA is interested in capability unicorns rather than economic unicorns. When I worked in DC, the joke was that DARPA was the only agency in town that would pull your funding for SUCCEEDING. The reason being that if you succeeded, it obviously meant they had set their ambitions too low and needed to re-frame the work to be impossible before funding it any further.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoRevolving doors are a policy anti pattern when the proverbial door separates industry from industry regulators. DARPA doesn’t fit that category.
- uvesten 7y ago"The Dream Machine" by by M. Mitchell Waldrop (https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/722412.The_Dream_Machine https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/722412.The_Dream_Mach...) is a really good book about J.C.R Licklider, one of the perhaps lesser-known individuals who helped create the modern computer revolution, in no small part as an ARPA (later DARPA) director. By reading the book, I learned that the changing of directors is by design, and an 8 year tenure looks like a problem with finding a suitable candidate to fill the role. 2 years seems more in line with how it was set up. I really recommend the book for anyone interested in the history of computing, the internet, or DARPA.