3 ms·
I have a great deal of sympathy for these people and it's a shame that the way zoning works it's difficult for there to be enough cheap housing built where peop
by fortran77 7y ago
I have a great deal of sympathy for these people and it's a shame that the way zoning works it's difficult for there to be enough cheap housing built where people need it.
However, I have some questions for the NY Times:
1. What does the fact that there are people paying $13,000/month rent have anything to do with the people collecting cans?
2. They're stealing from the City, as you point out. Why isn't this wrong?
3. How much tax-free money are they earning? Combined with the benefits they're receiving from Federal Government, City, and State with this untaxed revenue stream, what's their income? How much would a person who pays taxes have to earn to net the same amount?
- ipnon 7y agoThe article quotes the commissioner of the sanitation department saying that collecting cans is decriminalized.
- fortran77 7y agoThere's a difference between "decriminalized" and "legal". Certainly we shouldn't fill jail cells with recycling thieves, but we shouldn't deify them either. And their income tax theft isn't legal or decriminalized.
- whorleater 7y agoThis is an extraordinary comment, especially in how ghoulish it is. It makes a head fake towards the "welfare queens" myth, ignores the fact that collection is decriminalized and calls it "stealing", and best of all, the commenter makes the off handed implication that this story is emotional manipulation. I wonder if HN really thinks journalism should have the writing of an API documentation.