4 ms·
You seem to have missed his point, though, that calls for moderation and tolerance from an oppressing party are often just a means to defend an unjust status qu
by krapp 7y ago
You seem to have missed his point, though, that calls for moderation and tolerance from an oppressing party are often just a means to defend an unjust status quo, and by extension, unjust power. I'm sure there are plenty of Chinese who wish Uighurs and Hong Kong protestors would just calm down and understand that civil order is more important than "justice." But doing so will never work out well for those aggrieved parties.
To use another example more directly relevant to MLK, if African Americans had to wait until it was convenient and comfortable for the white establishment to tolerate and accept them as equals, and the civil rights movement only ever worked within the bounds of the law, they would still be picking cotton. Maintaining order for its own sake without regard for the justness of the society being defended is tantamount to fascism.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI get that point very much ($deity knows I had it explained to me a lot in other discussions). You present very good examples. But the point I can't ever seem to get across is this - action is meaningfully different than inaction, regardless of what is the status quo. It's the action part that's risky. Action has a price, and it's worth considering how high it is in a given case, before jumping to keyboards or bayonets. > I'm sure there are plenty of Chinese who wish Uighurs and Hong Kong protestors would just calm down and understand that civil order is more important than "justice." I think there's also plenty of Chinese who wish their own government backed down and let Hong Kong go its own way. And as a westerner, while my heart is with Hong Kong on this one, every time someone proposes that maybe the US should get involved I start wishing either of the sides involved just gave up, because quite frankly, none of this is worth the price of a nuclear war. > To use another example more directly relevant to MLK (...) [if] the civil rights movement only ever worked within the bounds of the law By "order", I don't mean "the law" (and I don't think MLK meant it either). In the MLK era, the Civil Rights Movement achieved their goals without plunging the country into a civil war. They've treaded the line between justice and order well. The point I'm trying to get across is that there are situations that are less like civil rights movement, and more like asking US to threaten China with nukes to get them to back off on HK. That the potential collateral damage may outweigh the gains. That doesn't mean abandoning pursuit of justice - only being mindful of the importance of preserving some order when deciding what to. Because, once the dust settles and the justice has been won, it would sure be nice if there were people left to enjoy that justice.
- mikojan 7y agoI don't think many would deny "action" is or might be "risky." However, you'd have to show that "inaction" is not for your argument to make sense.
- krapp 7y ago>It's the action part that's risky. Action has a price, and it's worth considering how high it is in a given case, before jumping to keyboards or bayonets. I agree completely. I don't think most would disagree with this. >The point I'm trying to get across is that there are situations that are less like civil rights movement, and more like asking US to threaten China with nukes to get them to back off on HK. I think you're conflating your fears about a specific, and in my opinion unlikely, doomsday scenario into a general slippery slope argument against the dangers of disruptive justice. Most such movements don't even have a theoretical capacity to pose an existential threat to civilization, so in most cases, the risk is arguably worth the reward.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> I think you're conflating your fears about a specific, and in my opinion unlikely, doomsday scenario into a general slippery slope argument against the dangers of disruptive justice. Yes, I kept repeating the one example I used, but I worry about all issues that could plausibly lead to a civilization-ending war. Of which there are many, including all kinds of problems created by worsening state of the planet's climate. But I also worry about things that could lead to local wars (including civil wars), and history says that regular politics, even identity politics, can find a way to turn into bloodshed.
- alphabettsy 7y agoThere is already bloodshed, but right now it just happens to not be yours. The point of MLK’s quote, in my opinion, is that moderates can always find reasons to maintain status quo especially when the issues at hand are not deemed personally impactful. People are being harmed, but because they are not me or look like me it’s not worth risking potential upset.