7 ms·
The checklist item that asks for a proof is for theoretical claims. Empirical claims are supported by experiment. Theoretical claims must also be supported theo
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
The checklist item that asks for a proof is for theoretical claims. Empirical claims are supported by experiment. Theoretical claims must also be supported theoretically.
To put it plainly, if your paper has a "Framework" section that has some text titled "lemma" and "theorem" then you also need some text titled "proof"
- currymj 7y agoalthough it’s probably in appendix D due to page limits.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoSome venues let you put a longer, more detailed proof in the appendix, but the reviewer is free to ignore it for the purpose of evaluating your paper. Anyway, if you have a detailed theorem in the main paper it makes sense to have at least a rudimentary proof in the main paper also.