5 ms·
I didn’t downvote, but I’ll reply. When you send your (surplus) taxes to the city or state (or feds), you don’t get to earmark it. Also let’s say you could an
by mc32 7y ago
I didn’t downvote, but I’ll reply.
When you send your (surplus) taxes to the city or state (or feds), you don’t get to earmark it.
Also let’s say you could and this person got housed and they also decided they would not rummage thru trash. Someone else will take up the slack and rummage.
For example the city of SF spends inordinate amounts on homelessness but the problem only gets bigger.
When people talk of the military industrial complex, we know what it means. In SF there is a homelessness-industrial complex that exists for its own sake and is better off perpetuating homelessness than solving it.
Don’t believe me? Propose homelessness solutions that cut out these orgs and see how well your ideas are received.
- throwlaplace 7y ago>When you send your (surplus) taxes to the city or state (or feds), you don’t get to earmark it. fine then give that homeless person the $20 yourself - they're in your driveway! you could literally pay them a couple of bucks a day (the worth of the cans in your trash) to skip your house. my point is simple: the reflexive reaction is "banish them" instead of "help them" even if helping them is the most straightforward way to solve the problem. >Someone else will take up the slack and rummage. "let's not try to cure any diseases because there will always be new ones" does that make sense? >When people talk of the military industrial complex, we know what it means. In SF there is a homelessness-industrial complex that exists for its own sake and is better off perpetuating homelessness than solving it this is utterly incredible. please do tell which services are rendered to the homeless at exorbitant cost to anyone (e.g. tax payers) such that it merits comparison with defense contractors.
- JadeNB 7y ago> >When people talk of the military industrial complex, we know what it means. In SF there is a homelessness-industrial complex that exists for its own sake and is better off perpetuating homelessness than solving it > this is utterly incredible. please do tell which services are rendered to the homeless at exorbitant cost to anyone (e.g. tax payers) such that it merits comparison with defense contractors. I don't know much about the situation, and do not mean to assert any facts here, only a different interpretation of the grandparent from the one I think you had. I think mc32 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21889186 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21889186) was suggesting that the money is funneled to the people allegedly solving homelessness, not to the homeless themselves, and that those solvers have the perverse incentive that they are more interested in the continuing revenue stream than in actually solving the problem. Of course comparisons to the military-industrial complex are hyperbole: such expenditures will fall far short of those spent on defence, as all expenditures in the US do.
- kirstenbirgit 7y ago>you could literally pay them a couple of bucks a day (the worth of the cans in your trash) to skip your house You sound really naive.
- zasz 7y ago> When you send your (surplus) taxes to the city or state (or feds), you don’t get to earmark it. I don't know where you're from, but in California, we regularly vote on ballot propositions to levy taxes earmarked for specific purposes. For example, in the most recent election cycle, Proposition C was on the SF ballot, which raised $300 million in taxes to address homelessness. Due to our fondness for direct democracy, any interested citizen can write a ballot proposition for everyone else to vote on. So yes, you certainly can earmark taxes. You can push for propositions to reduce homelessness, and you can vote for them, and encourage your friends and family and coworkers to vote for them. > For example the city of SF spends inordinate amounts on homelessness but the problem only gets bigger. That's false. SF spends only about $3.8k/year per homeless person: https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/heatherknight/article/Businesses-must-contribute-more-to-city-s-13178743.php# https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/heatherknight/article/Bu... At any rate, even if SF were spending an inordinate amount trying to house the homeless, it would only make sense to, given how damn high the rents are. > Don’t believe me? Propose homelessness solutions that cut out these orgs and see how well your ideas are received. Yeah, I don't believe you, because the people who get into working with the homeless don't do it because they like money. I'm a software developer. I certainly don't do it because I need the money. It's not even sexy work, as far as non-profits go. Assuming that the same incentives that work on the military apply to do-gooders doing thankless work is just lazy. There is also the small problem wherein if the org I volunteer with on occasion, Food not Bombs, were cut out, homeless people would literally starve. So yes, I _would_ be very opposed to that, unless the city took it upon itself to feed the homeless instead. The biggest obstacle to solving homelessness, as with many other problems, is not the people who care about the homeless, but the people who don't: the NIMBYs. The SF NIMBYs recently put $250k and a lawsuit into the effort to defeat the Embarcadero Navigation Center, which has only 200 beds. Thankfully, it has failed, but there are only seven centers, and a homeless population of 7-8k, so it's not going to make much of a dent. When every attempt to build a good homeless shelter meets this much opposition, it's just deeply wrongheaded, and, dare I say, callous, to blame the people helping a population who so many hate.
- lazyasciiart 7y ago> Don’t believe me? Propose homelessness solutions that cut out these orgs and see how well your ideas are received. Yes, people are often negative towards suggestions that don't use any existing knowledge, experience or infrastructure. To jump from that to "there's a conspiracy to keep this in place!" is ludicrous.