4 ms·
I'm mostly pushing back against the idea of some lost golden age of UI design. The file explorer used in this example is almost the same a quarter of a century
by pvg 7y ago
I'm mostly pushing back against the idea of some lost golden age of UI design. The file explorer used in this example is almost the same a quarter of a century later. And some of its deficiencies have lasted a long time - it took a couple of decades for explorer to learn to show a unified list of files and directories sorted by modification time. And it still doesn't have an inlined tree view making the basic task of moving files between adjacent directories clunky.
At the same time, for all of its fashions and foibles, the one-app-a-time, direct-manipulating touchscreen UI has made computers more accessible to all sorts of people to whom 'the desktop metaphor' was and remains confusing and unintuitive.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoThe iPad touch screen device was intuitive for a while, until featuritis took over. Explorer too for that matter.
- pvg 7y agoYoung children, the elderly, the desktop-bewildered still use iPads and touchscreen phones more readily than they ever used desktop UIs. I think as experienced computer-users we easily miss that this has been a genuine revolution in UI reach.
- ddingus 7y agoMy 3 year old rules any tablet. Can get to the movies and pictures quick. Will even make phone calls when they get hold of a phone. The right phone calls. It is an advance.
- ta999999171 7y agoWhat if we put Win98 on a tablet with an application that had Caillou inside of it? Guarantee they'd be cruising the fuck out of Win98, as well. Environment is everything.
- thrower123 7y agoSomehow, we managed to fuck around with autoexec.bat to get Doom to run when we were kids...
- ahartmetz 7y agoI often hear this argument. It could be used to argue that comics are better than novels and overalls are better than regular clothes. Three year olds are three year olds - what is best for them is not necessarily best for adults.
- ddingus 7y agoNever said it was best. I agree with you. Still, it is an advance. More work overall remains to reach more optimal for more people more of the time.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoNot necessarily, if it debilitates the majority of the user population (adults) - if it helps some people get more done, while making much more people get much less done.
- ddingus 7y agoNo, it's still a net gain. What you are talking about is a priority problem. That problem is applying the right UX to more people more of the time. That costs more than just doing one size fits all, and we should be paying those costs more, in my view.
- ddingus 7y agoAlso, in some cases, we can make investments to get productive on the new UX. I did that with Android. Have to be honest. I can fly on a reasonable Android phone. Apple, not so much. Didn't want to make two investments. Content create, communications, programming, social media, all aren't a burden today. Function set is limited, but it's not as big of a deal as it was prior to really working the UX, just like many of us did with the other paradigms. And I often just do not need a deeper set of features / flows too. Not saying it's better. It's not in my view. But, I am also saying, users can do better with it than they may think.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI don't think we miss that. We're just paying attention to what that revolution cost us. Part of the problem is the "winner takes all" dynamic of the computing sector. I'd be fine with simplified interface for children and elderly existing side by side with a properly deep interface for adults in full capacity. But currently, the market can only sustain one of these - and it chooses the one that can support more users, despite the total loss of utility this causes. Porting an example I use in topics about accessibility: consider Braille. Everyone can learn to read Braille, but blind people can't learn to read regular, printed characters. But we don't try to replace print with Braille, because it would be ridiculously debilitating to the vast majority of the planet's population. We instead opt to run two interfaces side by side - we print both regular and Braille books.