4 ms·
In San Francisco we have these old ladies who rummage though people's bins looking for redeemable containers. Most are "conscientious" enough to put the rest o
by mc32 7y ago
In San Francisco we have these old ladies who rummage though people's bins looking for redeemable containers. Most are "conscientious" enough to put the rest of the recyclables back in without leaving a mess on the sidewalk, but some are less caring and you wake up having to put things back in the bin. On the other hand I believe rubbish companies consider the practice theft and so they campaign against the practice.
- benatkin 7y agoWhere I used to live in Emeryville, I would get woken up by someone digging in the trash in the morning. Short of wearing earplugs, which are uncomfortable and not recommended for wearing while sleeping, there was nothing I could do about it. It was infuriating. At one place I worked in San Francisco we had a padlock on our trash can. It was worth the inconvenience of unlocking it and locking it back up when taking the trash out. The waste department had keys that could open it. This was in the mission.
- throwlaplace 7y ago>there was nothing I could do about it you could pay more in taxes so that these people could have section 8 housing and food stamps so that they don't have to dig in the trash in order to survive. edit: i see i'm getting downvoted. it boggles the mind. people are starving literally in his driveway (not in another state, not in another country, not abstractly) and he's complaining about the noise of their death rattle. like how do you square that? i'd love someone to actually respond/answer rather than downvote in indignation. are you upset at the politics of the suggestion that the solution to the problem is not getting rid of their sole means to survive but to actually help them? is it divisive because i invoked the hob goblin of hn (higher taxes)? just truly what is the appropriate response here? is it really "fuck em let die so i can sleep blissfully unaware"?
- ch4s3 7y agoI think part of the issue here is that section 8 is rent support payments. It doesn’t pay directly to build housing. California is already a very high tax state, there’s money there. However, because of overly restrictive zoning and the ability of neighbors to block construction, that kind of housing can’t get built.
- throwlaplace 7y agothat's fine. i'll gladly admit that i'm not a welfare economist and that my shoot from the hip solution isn't necessarily the correct one. but at least the thing i'm expressing is "how can we help them" instead of "how can we make life even more difficult for them". this isn't to say i'm proud of myself or something - i'm just sincerely flabbergasted at expressing the latter opinion.
- mc32 7y agoI didn’t downvote, but I’ll reply. When you send your (surplus) taxes to the city or state (or feds), you don’t get to earmark it. Also let’s say you could and this person got housed and they also decided they would not rummage thru trash. Someone else will take up the slack and rummage. For example the city of SF spends inordinate amounts on homelessness but the problem only gets bigger. When people talk of the military industrial complex, we know what it means. In SF there is a homelessness-industrial complex that exists for its own sake and is better off perpetuating homelessness than solving it. Don’t believe me? Propose homelessness solutions that cut out these orgs and see how well your ideas are received.
- throwlaplace 7y ago>When you send your (surplus) taxes to the city or state (or feds), you don’t get to earmark it. fine then give that homeless person the $20 yourself - they're in your driveway! you could literally pay them a couple of bucks a day (the worth of the cans in your trash) to skip your house. my point is simple: the reflexive reaction is "banish them" instead of "help them" even if helping them is the most straightforward way to solve the problem. >Someone else will take up the slack and rummage. "let's not try to cure any diseases because there will always be new ones" does that make sense? >When people talk of the military industrial complex, we know what it means. In SF there is a homelessness-industrial complex that exists for its own sake and is better off perpetuating homelessness than solving it this is utterly incredible. please do tell which services are rendered to the homeless at exorbitant cost to anyone (e.g. tax payers) such that it merits comparison with defense contractors.
- JadeNB 7y ago> >When people talk of the military industrial complex, we know what it means. In SF there is a homelessness-industrial complex that exists for its own sake and is better off perpetuating homelessness than solving it > this is utterly incredible. please do tell which services are rendered to the homeless at exorbitant cost to anyone (e.g. tax payers) such that it merits comparison with defense contractors. I don't know much about the situation, and do not mean to assert any facts here, only a different interpretation of the grandparent from the one I think you had. I think mc32 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21889186 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21889186) was suggesting that the money is funneled to the people allegedly solving homelessness, not to the homeless themselves, and that those solvers have the perverse incentive that they are more interested in the continuing revenue stream than in actually solving the problem. Of course comparisons to the military-industrial complex are hyperbole: such expenditures will fall far short of those spent on defence, as all expenditures in the US do.
- nitwit005 7y agoYou're blaming a random stranger on the internet for taxation and benefits policies which you know they don't control. They might even agree with you. Every time homelessness comes up on hacker news there are people who leap on posts they think don't show enough sympathy. This behavior never seems helpful.
- throwlaplace 7y agoi'm not blaming them for the homelessness - i'm blaming them for casting the issue as the homeless antagonizing the well-heeled rather than as society failing the homeless. >leap on posts they think don't show enough sympathy i do not understand what the issue with that response is. we should shun the unempathetic.
- jes 7y agoWhat about meeting people lacking empathy where they are at, and trying to connect with them? Sometimes a perceived lack of empathy has its roots in a lack of human connection.
- throwlaplace 7y agoi have meditated long and hard on this. when i was younger i gave people the benefit of the doubt - if you comfort and reassure them they make themselves vulnerable to you and become empathetic. after decades of experience i can safely say that many many people will never overcome whatever barriers they have to empathy (cowardice, jealousy, etc) and moreover i'm not jesus - i'm not responsible for everyone. given that i'm finite (time and energy) priority goes to those that are disempowered rather than those that have power and can't see their way to using it benevolently.
- zasz 7y agoYou very much can exert control when it comes to policies on the local level, but you'd have to be actually civically engaged to do so.
- 7y ago
- fennecfoxen 7y agoI also downvoted this, well after your comment, because the comment directs someone to go out and do something that they cannot actually do (i.e. rewrite politics), because the political parties in power in California are perfectly happy to spend money on these matters already, but mostly because it is nontrivially likely that someone rifling through trash at such hours is a homeless person who has bigger problems than the availability of housing vouchers, so the specific policy perspectives offered will have only a marginal effect.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zer00eyz 7y agoI grew up in Connecticut where we always had redemption value on cans/bottles and so on. The rule was if you sold it you had to take it back. Taking back the cans and bottles was normal for me as a kid, it was how I got change for the vending machines in front of the store. In CA (in the Bay Area) I am charged redemption value on cans and bottles. I put them in recycling, and guess what, the same truck that picks up my garbage also picks up my recycling... it is all going in the trash. Recycling is broken, and we need to make more changes to make it effective.
- benatkin 7y agoPart of the redemption values is now effectively a tax, because many people who never redeem them. This is fine, except much of it's being scooped up by people picking through the trash, as a disorganized benefit for the poor, which might work well but isn't designed for that purpose.
- nrp 7y agoIn the Bay Area, you're probably being served by Recology. They have trucks with multiple compartments for recycling, composting, and trash, but they also have pretty advanced sorting capabilities at their sites: https://www.recology.com/environment-innovation/#resource-recovery https://www.recology.com/environment-innovation/#resource-re... I don't doubt that recycling needs to be improved in most places, but the San Francisco Bay Area system is among the better ones.
- zer00eyz 7y agoUmmm... In two counties, the same single compartment truck is picking up both cans (trash+recycling) at the same stop. No amount of sorting is going to help fix that mess.
- nrp 7y agoYou’d be surprised. In the last city I lived in in Orange County, the waste system was deliberately designed to have a single residential container and full sorting done at the waste facility by a combination of people and machines. The claim was that it was actually more effective than curbside sorting because the professionals and automation knew how to process recyclables better than the average resident. I don’t know if that is what Recology does in single-truck locations, but it seems likely.