3 ms·
I pay 20 times what my neighbor pays, and the other neighbor pays 40 times as much, for the same services. How is this remotely fair? Even worse, I can find y
by jedberg 7y ago
I pay 20 times what my neighbor pays, and the other neighbor pays 40 times as much, for the same services. How is this remotely fair?
Even worse, I can find you homes in California that are valued over $4MM that are paying less than $1000/yr in property tax (buying that property new would be about $50,000/yr).
How is this fair?
- mikeyouse 7y agoI recently visited a friend of a friend on “Billionaires Row” on Pacific near Lyon. They are extraordinarily wealthy aside from their magnificent home and could easily afford the “correct” property taxes but since the home has been passed down for generations, they’re paying taxes on an assessed value that’s probably 1/50th of what it’s really worth. Just absolute madness that we subsidize ~hundred millionaires to the tune of $50k/year. It creates a literal landed gentry.
- dartdartdart 7y agoThese people know it's wrong but still won't reassess because there are incentives not to. Greed is a hell of a human trait
- remote_phone 7y agoThe only time you should look at your neighbors plate is to see if they have enough. Otherwise be thankful that Prop 13 will protect you as you get older. I don’t care that some of my neighbors are paying 1/20 what I am paying in taxes. They have lived in the same home for 25 years, they deserve it. I would not want to get kicked out of my house because I couldn’t afford the property taxes, that would be unfair. And one other thing that you don’t mention is that property taxes get reset if you make upgrades to your house. If someone lives in the same home and makes no upgrades then good for them, it means they can’t afford to move so leave them alone.
- mikeyouse 7y agoJust to be clear, while they’re avoiding property tax increases, they’re banking massive unrealized capital gains (which will also be passed through untaxed when the property is bequeathed to their children). Prop13 + stepped up basis in capital gains means that we’ve legislated inequality and in many cases racial inequality since only white families could buy property in the wealthier enclaves of California.
- jedberg 7y ago> The only time you should look at your neighbors plate is to see if they have enough. That's a nice platitude, but doesn't apply here. I'm paying for my neighbors services. They have as much ability to pay as I do. I want that to be fair. I have no problem helping those in need, but someone who owns a $2MM property isn't in need. > Otherwise be thankful that Prop 13 will protect you as you get older. This is red herring being spread by the anti-tax zealots. In all the other states, somehow old people aren't being priced out of their homes despite the lack of prop 13. The reason? Because property prices don't climb as quickly. They also have subsidies for the elderly. There are lots of solutions to this problem besides freezing taxes. I'm not worried about being priced out when I'm old, because I plan for taxes to go up. Also, when I get old, I won't need four bedrooms anymore, because my kids will be gone. I will downgrade to a smaller home and let a younger family take my place, as is what happens in most functioning housing markets. > I would not want to get kicked out of my house because I couldn’t afford the property taxes, that would be unfair. Worst case, you can take out an equity line to pay the taxes. > And one other thing that you don’t mention is that property taxes get reset if you make upgrades to your house. This is only partially true. You only pay extra tax on the cost of the upgrade itself. You don't reset on all the equity you've earned.
- remote_phone 7y agoOf course you don’t worry about the future you’re a rich tech worker. My neighbors are 60-80 years old. They never benefited from the salary gains. House prices have doubled in 6 years in the Peninsula. How the hell can retirees afford to pay for property taxes that go to over $2000/month? They just want to live in peace and sell their house when they are ready to sell, not when they are forced to because employees at Netflix made 500k+ and their stock went up 43x in 10 years. No one can compete against that when you’re lucky like that. Prop 13 is great for creating stability. As a home owner myself I don’t care that I’m paying 20x, I care that my future property taxes won’t drive me out of my house.
- emcma 7y agoImagine a retiree living in their own home sees a sudden increase in property tax bill due to the rise of the market prices in the neighborhood. Without prop 13, many people in that scenario will be forced to move away from their own home. The original idea of prop 13 is to protect home ownership. It sounds good but it is being applied to people that have “house” ownership not home ownership. Prop 13 should really be changed such that only if a homeowner living in the same house could pay the tax derived from the purchase price. If you rent out the property, you should pay the tax derived market price. If the property is a vacation house and not the primary home, the owner should pay the tax derived from the market price. Commercial properties should always be paying the market price.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The original idea of prop 13 is to protect home ownership. No, the original idea of Prop 13 was a Norquistian “starve the beast” approach to government. The big original sales pitch for Prop 13 was to stop old people on fixed incomes from having to sell their homes because of taxes, but if that was the motivation rather than the sales pitch, it would never have applied to anything other than owner-occupied primary residences; instead, it applies to all real property regardless of use or ownership.q
- masonic 7y agoThere have been many times (including right now) that the Democrats had complete control (Governor and supermajorities in the Legislature) and could have passed a split-roll amendment, which would then need only 50%+1 of voters to pass. They never have. Ask yourself: why not?
- jedberg 7y agoThey did. It’s on the ballot in 2020.
- jedberg 7y ago> Imagine a retiree living in their own home sees a sudden increase in property tax bill due to the rise of the market prices in the neighborhood. Without prop 13, many people in that scenario will be forced to move away from their own home. This is a red herring by the anti-tax zealots. Somehow in the 49 states without prop 13 this doesn’t happen. Worst case, the retiree can downsize their home and cash out their equity, freeing what is most likely an oversized property for a younger family, or they can take out a home equity line to pay the taxes.
- jdkee 7y agoIt is not in an absolute sense. But it is economically fair otherwise you would likely not have bought the property.