3 ms·
Every time Prop 13 comes up, I like to tell the story of my own neighborhood. On my block are four almost identical houses. They are all about 1800sq ft. My
by jedberg 7y ago
Every time Prop 13 comes up, I like to tell the story of my own neighborhood.
On my block are four almost identical houses. They are all about 1800sq ft.
My neighbor, who is the original owner from 1962, pays $X in tax. My neighbor on the other side, who bought in the 90s, pays $10X. I pay $20X (bought in 2008), and the one who just moved into the last house pays $40X.
We all get the same services from the city, but one person pays 40X the other. The new owners are basically subsidizing the neighbors, despite being the ones who have to spend more of their income to pay their mortgage.
It's completely ridiculous.
- m463 7y agoA friend is in this situation. There are periodic add-ons voted in for "school funding". They are based on assessed property value and follow the same sorts of figures.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- __david__ 7y agoI think it would need more ridiculous for your poor neighbor to be forced to move out just because a bunch of rich people paid a whole lot for neighboring houses and inflated the property values. Prop 13 at least gives you some comfort that the same thing will not happen to you—there is less uncertainty in your future with regard to your expenses (assuming your property tax is the 2nd largest bill after your mortgage).
- jedberg 7y agoThis is a red herring by the anti-tax zealots. Somehow in the 49 states without prop 13 this doesn’t happen. Worst case, the retiree can downsize their home and cash out their equity, freeing what is most likely an oversized property for a younger family, or they can take out a home equity line to pay the taxes. And luckily because of the rising property values it would be really easy to get that equity line since the LTV would be really low!
- masonic 7y agocash out their equity ... which means they pay income taxes on the unindexed gain (not adjusted for inflation). When you combine that tax hit with the cost of a replacement property, and it being taxed at the full current rate, it's not worth it. Those voters who voted No on Prop 5[0], which would have made tax basis portable statewide, have nobody else to blame for the low property turnover among long held real property. [0] https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_5,_Property_Tax_Transfer_Initiative_(2018) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_5,_Property_T...
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIf everyone's home value doubles overnight, the costs of schools, fire departments, and other local expenses funded by property taxes don't also double. They might rise with inflation (as do all goods and services), but not more.
- mertd 7y agoWhere will the teachers and firefighters live if the cost of housing doubles but their pay only grows commensurate to inflation?
- zanderz 7y agoMy retired dad lives alone in a 4 bedroom house walking distance from Apple he bought in 1981. It seems the region could benefit if such people had more incentive to downsize elsewhere, but prop 13 means even a much smaller place would have a way larger tax bill than he now enjoys. There was a ballot measure recently that would let such homeowners transfer their 1973 era tax bills to another property, but it had no stipulation that the next place be smaller. It lost. I feel bad for the hypothetical grandma who couldn't stay in her house when the tax bill increased, but what if grandma is paying next to nothing and sitting on a $2m house that could hold a whole family?
- dartdartdart 7y agoThe people who moved in later were also more disadvantaged than the people who moved in from 1960s who benefited from discriminatory housing policies.