3 ms·
> Weightlifting is almost pointless from a calorie perspective Maybe in terms of the energy you burn directly by lifting weights, but it raises your base metab
by taneq 7y ago
> Weightlifting is almost pointless from a calorie perspective
Maybe in terms of the energy you burn directly by lifting weights, but it raises your base metabolic rate significantly for quite some time after a workout. The extra muscle mass you built also raises your BMR in a longer lasting way. Especially when combined with interval training, weights are very effective.
- romaaeterna 7y agoDoes it raise your BMR that much? What is that energy doing exactly? Does your body temperature increase? Do you move around more? You can't have energy going nowhere, of course. What other activities can drive the same? And what is the magnitude? "The extra muscle mass you built also raises your BMR in a longer lasting way." Unless you are talking about fantastic amounts of muscle mass here -- 10 pounds of muscle will only burn an extra 60-70 calories a day -- this oft mentioned factoid is unnoticeable in daily calorie expenditure.
- taneq 7y agoIt's hard to find good data on what the effects are in amongst all the bro-science articles, but I believe the raise in energy usage is due to the body repairing the muscles after the weights workout, so you'd see an increase in body heat generation (although the core temperature would stay the same, peripheral circulation would go up and skin temperature would rise a bit). HIIT is just good at hitting a lot of different muscle groups hard enough in a short amount of time to maximize the effect. It's not huge but several hours of increased passive energy burn does make a difference. Also, 10 pounds of muscle isn't a fantastic amount to put on (depending on body size), especially if it's muscle that you're re-gaining rather than building for the first time. A few months of regular moderate weights work would build that much without pushing too hard. And again, passive energy burn is "free" and helps with gradual long-term weight loss.
- sundvor 7y agoAgree. Although, when I'm doing my working set of deadlifts (after a series of warm up ones) my whole body is by then heaving for air and on fire after the last rep. It certainly gets the heart rate going. Now I don't do those every day, of course, but squats I do. Either as high rep/lower intensity warm up for other exercises, or low rep 5x5 heavy as a primary target of the day. They never fail to kick-start the body.