4 ms·
My feeling has always been that no matter how you decide to allocate resources, some people are going to be 'better' at winning the game we design than others;
by cortesoft 7y ago
My feeling has always been that no matter how you decide to allocate resources, some people are going to be 'better' at winning the game we design than others; maybe they have some skill that is highly valued in the system we set up, or they are lucky, or have connections, or have a higher drive succeed, or whatever else might factor into success.
Instead of trying to figure out those factors and mitigate them so everyone has an equal chance, why don't we just say fuck it, and tax the winners more heavily? We don't know why you were able to win in the system so well, but since you did, you get to contribute a lot more to helping the people who don't succeed in the system. Give a universal basic income, tax the winners to fund it, and call it a day.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoThis is essentially what social democracies do, like in the Nordic countries, and it seems to work great at achieving good results in a variety of societal dimensions. The counter-arguments from fiscal conservatives generally take one of two tacks: either a plainly disingenuous one where they argue that this is somehow only possible in those specific countries (e.g. due to being small and/or relatively homogeneous), or an ideological one where they argue that even if this is beneficial to the society as a whole, they're against it because taxing the winners more is fundamentally wrong, taxation is theft etc. Well, the Nordic countries don't do the UBI part, but taxing the winners heavily and funding policies that are effectively redistributionist because they treat everyone more or less equally (like public transportation or universal healthcare), yeah they do that for sure.
- xyzzyz 7y agoNo, the Nordic countries don't really tax the winners more. The marginal tax rates for top earners there are about the same as in the US. The real difference is that they, along with most other European welfare states, tax the middle class much more than the US does. > either a plainly disingenuous one where they argue that this is somehow only possible in those specific countries (e.g. due to being small and/or relatively homogeneous) No, of course it is possible in other countries too. For example, people of Swedish ancestry in the US not only do better than average American, but in fact do much better than Swedes in Sweden.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoHmm, is that true? > So on average, those in the highest earnings bracket will pay 56 percent of their taxable income to the taxman (31 percent in local income tax plus 25 percent in national income tax), but a top earner living in Dorotea would pay 60.15 percent. https://www.thelocal.se/20180111/does-swedens-tax-system-really-screw-the-rich https://www.thelocal.se/20180111/does-swedens-tax-system-rea... That sounds higher than the US. Maybe not that much higher than particularly high tax places like NYC, but compared to the US on average, yeah that sounds high. That taxes there are also higher on the middle class, yeah I don't dispute that.
- xyzzyz 7y agoMarginal tax rate in places with most top earners, like California and New York, is around 50%, if you add together both federal and state taxes.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoJust used a tax calculator, in Stockholm gross of 500k USD annually was net 210k USD: https://se.neuvoo.com/tax-calculator/?iam=&uet_calculate=calculate&salary=4671068&from=year®ion=STOCKHOLM https://se.neuvoo.com/tax-calculator/?iam=&uet_calculate=cal... In NYC it'd be net 284k: https://smartasset.com/taxes/new-york-tax-calculator#xyAZi4NK9M https://smartasset.com/taxes/new-york-tax-calculator#xyAZi4N... So yeah, it's much higher in Sweden. The effective tax rates are 58% vs 43%.
- xyzzyz 7y ago> Instead of trying to figure out those factors and mitigate them so everyone has an equal chance, why don't we just say fuck it, and tax the winners more heavily? Because it reduces the incentive to try to be a winner. The government might get a bigger piece of the pie, but the whole pie will be smaller. More importantly, since we live in regime of economic growth, this kind of policy can have extremely significant impact down the line: over 30 years, the difference between 2% and 3% economic growth is really, really large. Thus, increasing taxes today might result in money to redistribute today, but less money to redistribute 30 years from now. Most governments fortunately understand it, and so in 1980s and 90s significantly reduced income tax rates in top brackets, and are in no mood for raising them. The tax rates for top earners in Sweden and Norway are about the same as they are in the US. The biggest difference between them and the US in terms of taxation is that Sweden, Norway, and other European welfare states typically tax the middle class much, much more than the US does. The welfare state in Germany, France, Norway or Sweden is not funded primarily by the "winners", it is funded by high taxes on people with incomes rather close to the median.
- cortesoft 7y agoI see people make the argument that it will reduce 'incentives to do well' all the time... but why is that so accepted? The net gain for 'winning' is always going to be positive, so it will always be better to win than to not... most people who work really hard to 'win' have that drive in them to succeed regardless of the actual amount of money they make. Really, after enough millions, the extra money isn't really changing their life... yet many still are driven to keep 'winning'... it clearly isn't about having the money to buy things at that point, it is about an internal drive. That won't change if we tax at a higher rate. As for it hurting the economy, what evidence do you have of that? If we use the extra tax dollars to provide UBI, this will cause economic growth as there are more consumers with money to spend. While inflation would be a worry, our modern economy has shown that we have a lot of latent productive capacity (and a lot of goods that don't require more resources to produce, like digital goods) that mitigate the inflation risk.
- xyzzyz 7y ago