4 ms·
> that implies there's some sort of authority - legal or otherwise - that determines "socially valuable." Well, we already have a system that rewards “valuable
by michaelt 7y ago
> that implies there's some sort of authority - legal or otherwise - that determines "socially valuable."
Well, we already have a system that rewards “valuable” contributions: Money.
Just a lot of people don’t like that system much, as it turns out that system places little value on childcare, elder care and teaching; and huge value on executives who are fired for sexual harassment. Which doesn’t line up very precisely with a lot of people’s personal values.
- clairity 7y agoyes, money is the mechanism we've defaulted to for measuring value, but economists admit that our economic systems, even capitalism, don't yet (properly) price everything that's valuable to humans (as you note). a charitable reading of the parent comment would find they're mainly against centralization of authority rather than how to value intangibles or how to engineer fairness into economic systems. but their first assumption that "'socially valuable contributions' [...] implies there's some sort of authority" is wholly unsupported. capitalism, for example, highly values rational resource distribution, but there is no central authority dictating that distribution. in any case, the crux of the problem is that with concentration of wealth comes concentration of power. we're all very wary of concentrations of power, for good reason. we need to decouple that pairing for a more stable and balanced society.
- nugget 7y agoGreat childcare and elder care is very expensive and the people who do these jobs well are, in my experience, quite well compensated relative to other jobs available to them.
- noonespecial 7y ago>Great childcare and elder care is very expensive It's hard even to find a way to buy "Great childcare and elder care". Mostly you end up paying as much as such a thing should cost but the money just goes to people who "administer" minimum wage workers delivering care that is mediocre at best.
- sdfin 7y agoAren't there childcare and elder care agencies that aim at families of different socioeconomic levels? I guess that the rich hire expensive nannies at expensive agencies. What you comment sounds unlikely to me.
- nugget 7y agoI agree there’s a sourcing/matching problem that leads the administrators in these markets to capture a disproportionately large share of any value premiums paid.
- ip26 7y agoI ran through the numbers when my kid started in childcare. It turned out there wasn't really a grand bureaucratic conspiracy. Instead, mainly labor is just really expensive. When your kids are still infants, at childcare centers, the caretaker:child ratio can get as high as 1:2. Those caretakers gross nearly $30k/year plus benefits & other employer costs such as FICA & Medicare.
- elil17 7y ago$30k/year is not a lot of money - definitely not enough to raise your own kids on
- ip26 7y agoNo, but it does mean that as a parent, if (in this canned example) you are paying $18k/year- while the number initially sounds crazy- nearly all of it is going directly to caretaker compensation, not bloat & largess.
- pmiller2 7y agoMaybe not, but it's a lot of money for most families to pay someone else to take care of their kids.
- cjlars 7y agoThat this is even arguable, I think, makes the OPs point.
- michaelt 7y agoI agree childcare you pay for is often expensive - I was thinking more of the unpaid work done by stay-at-home parents and families caring for their own elders - who earn no direct salary for their efforts. But nobody would say they ought to stop.
- ars 7y agoMoney certainly has it's drawbacks, but it does not have any kind of central authority that values it. It's the most distributed system there is. > Just a lot of people don’t like that system much Any other system would be more centralized, and even more open to abuse. As they say: "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others." It's the same with money. > places little value on childcare, elder care and teaching Those things have a completely different problem: Those benefiting from them are not those paying for them.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoIn fact it's quite efficient, as the feedback time between when the signal is sent from the consumer to when it is received by the producer is very short compared to political systems. Revealed preferences also show that what people say they want and what they actually want can be quantified very precisely using money as a proxy. And more generally, the vast majority of consumers show they prefer low prices over all other things, including priced in externalities, bad labor and management practices, unsustainable production etc... More recently however (~100 years) the advertising and marketing industry has shown that preference hijacking is a real thing, so markets are skewed in this way.