4 ms·
I support this Because think of all the rogue actors who can deploy anonymous drones including from other countries Right now all our skies are clear but once
by EGreg 7y ago
I support this
Because think of all the rogue actors who can deploy anonymous drones including from other countries
Right now all our skies are clear but once we have a lot of drone traffic, we may have really bad stuff happen. It takes just one drone flying over a crowd to cause massive problems. Let alone a coordinated attack in multiple areas.
If you don’t know who to go after, to make an example of, after a crime (what if a drone drops grenades??) then you should be catching this drone with a net and disabling it.
Drones are the first type of robot that will be in PUBLIC PLACES which is cheap to produce. Autonomous cars are dangerous but expensive so we will not likely encounter cars which are unregistered and we don’t know who made them. But w drones it’s easy!!
To the downvoters: can you speak about how you would address the danger? Let’s have a conversation
- ceejayoz 7y agoYou think folks making a coordinated drone attack are going to willingly install Remote ID in their drones, under their real, traceable identities? If a drone drops grenades, you'll probably have little trouble tracing the grenades.
- mileycyrusXOXO 7y agoReminder: downvotes are for comments that do not add value to the conversation, not for opinions you disagree with. Instead, if you disagree with someone you should contribute to the conversation by leaving a comment stating why you disagree.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ggreer 7y agoThis will not deter competent attackers or help catch them. Disabling remote ID will be as easy as jailbreaking your phone. The hard part of a drone attack would still be sourcing explosives and modifying drones to carry and deploy such payloads.
- godelski 7y ago> To the downvoters: can you speak about how you would address the danger? Let’s have a conversation. Your concern seems to be about bad actors. Yet you also mention how easy and cheap drones are to build. There's thousands of online tutorials showing how to build them for extremely cheap. So how does this solution address the problem of bad actors? Bad actors are just not going to install the identification methods or remove them from commercial bought drones. With a radio based system the only way you have to track these people down is arrays of radios to track signals (automated fox hunting). But that doesn't scale well. Tracking drones is really a difficult problem. So considering that, what does this do other than harm good actors? Most of the problems are really uninformed actors. Punishing people doesn't resolve the issue of uninformed actors because you are being reactionary and not proactive, meaning the damage is done. I also find it ridiculous that drones are being regulated more than private aircraft. Drones have such a lower potential for harm.
- EGreg 7y agoIt addresses it by making it open season to shoot down any drones who don’t have it broadcasting, just like any rogue plane
- godelski 7y ago1) It is illegal to shoot down drones 2) If it was legal, it would be a bad idea because you're shooting down something with a lipo. Great way to start a fire. 3) Identifying a rogue drone is quite difficult. They aren't easy to see. And how do you know the radio signal you are intercepting is theirs? It isn't always that easy (in fact, that's what I was talking about with the city wide fox hunt). This might be easy in a small area where there is only one thing flying around, but as soon as you have multiple things it is hard to identify what is what. The easiest way is to get a yagi and aim it at the drone, but you're still going to have to follow it for awhile to make sure you have the right one. And are you going to do that for every arbitrary flying object? Seriously, that is a ridiculous notion. "Honey there's a drone outside! Get my yagi so I can check if it is operating legally or not!"