4 ms·
>> They're priced this way because they're 80-90% cheaper than the previous treatment. Your statement is true. But it also hints at another problem, which is t
by phkahler 7y ago
>> They're priced this way because they're 80-90% cheaper than the previous treatment.
Your statement is true. But it also hints at another problem, which is that the default is to price life saving treatments as high as the market will bear. It's a pricing model in line with extortion, the only exception being that the extortionist doesnt have to threaten to kill you - the virus or whatever condition is already making the threat for them.
I was about to summarize by saying "sometimes a free market can mimick evil" but I just remembered it's not a free market at all. These treatments have government granted monopoly status via patents. That's why they are priced so high.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoWith new drugs you can make the argument that development costs need to be recovered while they are still under patent protection. Time and cost of development is high, 10 - 15 years and several billions, and a successful outcome is not guaranteed. This is the order of magnitude of a flagship space program of a large nation. Where you really have no excuse is the price for old drugs that get bought up by venture capital. Wilson's disease is treated with triethylenetetramine. The price had always been ~ USD 600 for 100 pills until the manufacturer became bought out by Valeant, who then raised it to 20 kUSD for 100 pills. There was the usual protestations by Hillary Clinton and other politicians, but the price is still where it is. Where is the revolution?
- ouid 7y agoDo development costs really need to be recovered through sales? I thought most of this research was done on federal grants.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoThe early research is done on federal grants. What costs real money is late-stage development and especially clinical research, startups and universities are not at all equipped for that. The financing model is problematic. Return on investment is much higher and faster in IT, besides there is a mismatch between what the market favours and where future clinical needs are (the antibiotic crisis, neglected tropical diseases).
- claudeganon 7y agoIsn’t the solution then to build a national infrastructure for late stage trials as opposed to putting life-saving drugs behind a ludicrous paywall, whose price is determined by the opaque malfeasance of the healthcare system in the US?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lmm 7y agoLate-stage trials are enormously costly and negative results are common. To publicly fund them, we'd have to be ok with governments spending billions and getting nothing for it. And after the fact there'd be a long line of people saying how $treatment was obviously never going to work and only an idiot would ever have let it go forward for stage 3 trials. I'm not opposed to the idea, but I think you'd struggle to make it politically achievable.
- vilhelm_s 7y agoThe government mostly funds basic research, but then there is a lot of work to turn promising leads into products. Googling a bit, in 2017 the pharma companies spent $70 billion on research while the NIH spent $38 billion.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pgeorgi 7y ago> I thought most of this research was done on federal grants And if not, why not? There may be folks who think public research grants shouldn't exist, but since they do, what else would be worthy of such support if not public health research?
- vilhelm_s 7y agoI think it's the "right" price, you want to incentivize companies to try to develop drugs that will do the maximal amount of good. Like, you could imagine a system where you don't have a free market at all, the government would directly fund both medical treatment (like in Europe) and medical research (like nowhere right now, but you could imagine nationalizing the drug companies). So then, before the hepatitis-c drug exists, you are paying $500k for each liver transplant, and you try to figure out how much money should be allocated to that drug research program. You'd want to fund it at roughly the expected cost saving, multiplied by the probability that the drug development is successful. In the actual system, if the drug companies try to develop the drugs, and then charge about the same price as the cost of the previous treatment during the time they hold the patent, then their expected payoff (so how much money they will put into research) is the cost of the previous treatment times the probability that they will be successful---so this high price is basically what we would want to allocate anyway. And if the drugs are paid for by the government, their expected spending over all the drugs is similar to optimal amount of direct research funding.
- MisterTea 7y ago> I think it's the "right" price, you want to incentivize companies to try to develop drugs that will do the maximal amount of good. So the only incentive to do maximal good is more money. And people wonder why I laugh when it's claimed that we live in a civilized society.
- jessaustin 7y agoHow much drug research have you personally done? Is your time more valuable than that of others?
- benchaney 7y agoWell, the only financial incentive to do good is money. But that is a tautology, not an observation. There could potentially also be other types of incentives, but I don’t see how they are supposed to apply here.
- UnpossibleJim 7y ago
- masonic 7y agoIt's a pricing model in line with extortion This common attitude is why I fear that we won't see true cures for anything, except perhaps from government labs. This class of HepC drugs (Solvaldi et al) are cures. Not chronic treatments, but cures. The developer only has that one course of treatment to make all the revenue they ever will on that patient. So what happens when they are told that they can't charge prices commensurate with the result? They'll abandon a cure model for treatments that have ongoing chronic purchases to provide revenue streams over time. Imagine this category of HepC drugs being marketed as a $999/month regimen for life rather than $50K for a one time cure. They would face far less friction. Happy now, consumers? This is why new antibiotic research was abandoned, by and large.
- clavalle 7y agoIf everyone in the United States with Hepatitis C was treated at a cost of $50K it would be $150 billion dollars. That's over 8 times what Viagra pulled in over the past 20 years. I'm not sure where the line between reasonable profit-taking and extortion lies, but it's probably somewhere south of the GDP of Kuwait.
- refurb 7y ago$150B would be the same as the lifetime sales of Lipitor, which was not even a cure.[1] [1] https://www.kiplinger.com/slideshow/investing/T027-S001-the-15-all-time-best-selling-prescription-drugs/index.html https://www.kiplinger.com/slideshow/investing/T027-S001-the-...
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoAnd the cure they "created" was in reality from a university or government lab. Paid for by the citizens. Ain't regulatory capture and 'release' great?