2 ms·
I think one of the reasons the subject is difficult to understand actually lies beyond tech. For someone not familiar with "move fast and break things" and the
by Nextgrid 7y ago
I think one of the reasons the subject is difficult to understand actually lies beyond tech.
For someone not familiar with "move fast and break things" and the huge toxic part of the tech industry, it would be reasonable for them to expect that a high-profile company such as Facebook or Google is complying with all local laws & regulations and isn't acting in bad faith otherwise they would've be fined out of existence long ago. After all, we have regulations for things like food safety that mean you can buy any food item from a mainstream supermarket and be confident it's safe to eat, and there are severe penalties to ensure that remains the case and deter potential offenders.
It's totally reasonable for these people to not be suspicious when they're downloading a popular app that's been around for decades and used by everyone and not suspect bad faith or malice when the app asks for contacts or photos, because regulation is supposed to crack down on fraud and lies (which dark patterns are).
The problem is, of course, that the law hasn't caught up with tech and with all the corruption... I mean lobbying - around I don't think we'll even get there. If an individual lies and gets access to something they're not supposed to it's called fraud and there are real penalties for that, even more so if the fraud happens on a computer (and the definition of that is so loose even implied legitimate access to a web server could be argued to be "unauthorised access"). When Facebook lies to you regarding their usages of the data however, it's no longer fraud nor hacking, even though it fits the bill perfectly, including the "on a computer" part. This is the real problem.
- briandear 7y agoLet’s not compare app privacy with food safety. Food safety literally is life or death. Nobody dies because Facebook knows you went to Soul Cycle. I am not saying privacy isn’t important, but it is a false equivalence to compare it to food safety. (In the US at least.)