3 ms·
Stability works until it doesn't. The Romans were very good at building a stable and powerful empire until the dominance/greed ethic that powered it, consumed i
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Stability works until it doesn't. The Romans were very good at building a stable and powerful empire until the dominance/greed ethic that powered it, consumed it from the inside out and it collapsed.
I find Aaronson's output consistently baffling, because he seems to understand the world entirely through mathematical abstractions, and mathematical abstractions are fundamentally a bad way to solve problems if you don't understand the problem space.
You can create eigenmorality or eigendemocracy if you really want to, but it seems he's is more interested in the fact that they generate a neato mathematical puzzle than in the 4000 or so years of existing debate about ethics and government.
Marx, Durkheim, Weber, Smith, Hobbes, and many others will tell him far more about the challenges of politics and morality than linear algebra will.
But applying linear algebra creates a seductive illusion of powerful insight into a problem that's much harder than it appears to be.
In reality the "insight" is minimal and trite. Worse: the process which generates the insight reveals an unconscious ethical and political bias of its own - and also guarantees this solution will cause more problems than it solves.
- rsj_hn 7y agoThere is quite a lot to learn from Rome's stability, but of course it wasn't perfect. But I do believe there are evolutionary forces at play where stronger societies displace weaker ones, and after the advent of writing, we can access the morality of long running societies and use that as an input into our own. This is a much more valuable inheritance from Rome than just the architecture or Latin alphabet. For example, rule of law (the Romans were fanatically legalistic) continues to be an important inheritance in the West, and the notion that there is something moral about following the rules and being a law-abiding citizen is an important part of the Western heritage. But you are right, the idea that you can come up with a quaint mathematical argument (and the mathematical insight here is pretty basic) as a replacement for studying history and philosophy is very foolish.