5 ms·
> No, this is your assessment of user experience. It’s opinion, not fact. Perhaps some $50 wired headphones sound better but different people value different th
by arcticbull 7y ago
> No, this is your assessment of user experience. It’s opinion, not fact. Perhaps some $50 wired headphones sound better but different people value different things.
Ok, 3.5" headphones are objectively: cheaper, simpler mechanically, more reliable, easier to use, easier to connect to different devices, never run out of battery or require charging, you can't lose 1/3 of them, and oh, yeah, they tend to sound better at the same price point. They tend to sound much better at the same price point since all you need to focus on are coils and membranes, not bluetooth stacks and batteries and inductive charging coils. A set of Shure SE315s will blow AirPods Pro out of the water on sound quality and noise isolation.
Yes, wireless headphones are wireless. That's all though. You can achieve all the rest with the jack, but you could achieve all of that wireless while the phone still had the jack.
None of this makes AirPods Pro a platform. They're neat wireless headphones. Among the best wireless headphones probably. But that's still all they are.
I've used AirPods Pro, and I've used me SE535s with an inline mic. It's gonna be SE535s by a country mile for me, even to the extent I have to go through the additional hoops of stupid dongles to hook them up. [1]
[1] https://www.shure.com/en-US/products/earphones/se535 https://www.shure.com/en-US/products/earphones/se535
- asutekku 7y agoBut that’s the thing. A lot of people are willing to compromise just for the wirelessness. People apart from tech-people or audiophiles don’t really care about the points you listed or if they do, the convenience that comes from the wirelessness is more important.
- jamesrcole 7y agoBeing wireless counts for so much for me. For myself and many other people, the experience of wireless headphones is hands-down superior to wired headphones. I would never go back to wired ones. Wires are a pain. They get tangled, they mean your phone and headphones need to always be close (which adds a certain amount of friction, once you get used to the alternative), but most importantly (for me) they get caught on things all the time.
- jen729w 7y agoHi! I’m Johnny Average Consumer. Nice to meet you. > Ok, 3.5" headphones are objectively: cheaper, I don’t care. I’ll pay for convenience. This phone was a thousand dollars! > simpler mechanically, Why would I know or care? > more reliable, You may have a point here, but the convenience of wireless overrides this for me. > easier to use, What about that horrible wire? It gets tangled in my pocket and I rip my headphones out when I run. > easier to connect to different devices, I only have one device. > never run out of battery or require charging, I charge my AirPods Pro every few days. This is a non-issue. > you can't lose 1/3 of them, But I mangle the wire on my old headphones all the time, so this feels like a fair trade-off. > and oh, yeah, they tend to sound better at the same price point. I’m neither an audiophile nor particularly price conscious. > A set of Shure SE315s will blow AirPods Pro out of the water on sound quality and noise isolation. I’ve never heard of those and wouldn’t know where to buy them. > Yes, wireless headphones are wireless. That's all though. This is such a naive statement. I’m sorry, but it totally ignores everything that Average Consumer wants. > None of this makes AirPods Pro a platform. Not yet. > They're neat wireless headphones. Among the best wireless headphones probably. But that's still all they are. Once you’ve tried a pair of truly great wireless headphones you’ll never go back. Yours, Average Consumer
- ctz 7y ago> Hi! I’m Johnny Average Consumer. > This phone was a thousand dollars! It's not accurate to describe the average consumer as being in the thousand dollar phone market. They are premium products, and not one that the average consumer can afford. That's one reason why Apple's phone global market share wavers around 10-15%.
- camjw 7y agoAnyone buying AirPods has already bought an iPhone (a thousand dollar phone), so I think you can replace ‘Johnny Average Consumer’ with ‘Billy iPhone Consumer’ and the rest of their points still hold
- scarface74 7y ago
- cranekam 7y agoI agree they aren't a platform (yet?). I just don't understand why you're conflating this with an assertion that AirPods can't possibly offer any additional utility over a basic set of wireless headphones. I for one don't want to know what Shure offers or deal with adding microphones or whatever. I don't care about that. I just want to pay someone a sum of money I am okay with paying for a product that will do what I want. I don't even care if it doesn't sound quite as good as the best possible offering; for me part of the utility is not needing to think about all this stuff. (That doesn't mean I would blindly buy anything Apple makes or whatever my friends tell me, but in this case I felt pretty confident I'd be happy with my choice and I was.) I'm glad you're happy with your setup and choices. It wouldn't work for me but it does for you. That's all that should matter to you.
- Matthias247 7y ago> more reliable Not sure about that part - especially for bigger (over-ear) headphones. My last 2 pairs of wired sets all died because the cable or connector inside the headphones got loose due to mechanical stress. Resoldering was not an option since it was not possible to open the case in a non destructive fashion. At least that failure-mode does not exist in bluetooth headphones. And so far I had not an issue with my pair (but it's only a year old). But long term the battery might certainly become a potential issue.
- stabbles 7y agoMarshall headphones have a 9mm jack on the headphones themselves to solve that problem.
- bluedino 7y agoAirpods just magically stop working.
- greedo 7y agoI used to review consumer electronics as a side gig, and one year Shure was nice enough to send me one of every in-ear headset they made. This was around 2005 or so. The gear was excellent, fantastic sound quality, but they all broke. Even the $700 pair. The cable got pinched or something. Shure replaced them (even though at this point they were out of warranty), and the replacement pair broke a year later. Wires suck.
- susijdjdjxa 7y ago>never run out of battery or require charging On this point, wireless headphones are massively superior. You only need to plug in wireless headphones when you’re not using them. You need to plug in wired headphones all the time when using them. This enables things like “using two hands to carry an object across a room, without wearing a pocket, while listening to headphones”. This is a huge practical upgrade that most people find impossible to give up once habituated.
- ekianjo 7y agoHeadphones, no matter how high cost they were in the first place, always end up with a wire failure on the connecting part after a few years. I have come to hate them with passion for this single reason.
- arcticbull 7y agoAnything with an MMCX connector allows you to swap out the cable. Generally any expensive headphones have MMCX connectors.
- rimliu 7y ago> easier to connect to different devices Nope. With wired headphones you need to disconnect the wire from the one device and put it into another. You don't have to do that with AirPods.
- arcticbull 7y agoRight unless you want to plug it into the IFE on your plane?
- fauigerzigerk 7y ago>Yes, wireless headphones are wireless. That's all though. And that's exactly what makes them easier to use and better sounding if you don't sit still. Wires get caught in clothes and tend to pull on the earbuds. They scrape and bang against clothes, chin, neck and chest, making a lot of noise in the process. Does that mean I'm going to pay hundereds for headphones or believe in Excalibur - sorry AirPods - as a platform any time soon? Unlikely. I guess I'll just continue to put up with the occasional bluetooth pairing issues.
- philliphaydon 7y ago> A set of Shure SE315s will blow AirPods Pro out of the water on sound quality The internet really needs to get off it’s high horse about this. The fact is 99% of people can’t tell the difference. Just like 99% of people don’t care about the headphone jack being removed. This is evident by the market mocking Apple and then following Apple when they realised that it’s true.
- qqii 7y agoRather than not being able to tell the difference, most consumers don't care about the difference. Everyone has their own acceptable level of sound quality, even enthusiasts. That being said the airpod pros' fidelity are known to be quite good in audiophile circles.
- philliphaydon 7y ago> Rather than not being able to tell the difference, most consumers don't care about the difference. This is very true too. I agree.
- bluedino 7y agoAlmost everyone comments about how much better then AirPods Pro are than their old Airpods, though
- arcticbull 7y ago> The fact is 99% of people can’t tell the difference. No, they absolutely can, they just don't think the difference is worth the cost. That's not the same thing. > Just like 99% of people don’t care about the headphone jack being removed. [citation needed]
- Dwolb 7y agoRegardless of where this debate ends up, AirPods are estimated to have sold 60M units in 2019 [0]. This means AirPods as a stand-alone business is somewhere between a $5B-$15B/year. [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-airpods-pro-production-double-report-2019-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-airpods-pro-production...
- scarface74 7y agoFor another point of reference, that’s larger than the iPod revenue when it peaked in 2007. So the entire narrative that Apple hasn’t released a successful product since Cook took over is provably false. Both the Watch and AirPods lines are larger than the iPods ever were. http://www.asymco.com/2019/12/12/ipods-pro/ http://www.asymco.com/2019/12/12/ipods-pro/ Yes I realize that the $4 billion quoted in the article was for the Christmas quarter.
- scarface74 7y agoWired headphones wouldn’t work too well when I just have my cellular watch at the gym.... But even back in the iPod days, I hated wired headphones when I was running or doing anything at the gym. And how are they “easier to use”? I open the case, they pair to either my iPad or iPhone without a manual pairing process. I put one in my ear, it changes the sound to be monaural from stereo. I also don’t have to go through an unpairing process for it to connect seamlessly to my watch, iPad, iPhone, or AppleTV.
- specialist 7y agoDifferent use cases. Shure SE315s headphones are for audiophiles. I have 3 pairs of the cheaper model. I love them. AirPods are for on-the-go. Since getting a dog, I've become addicted to podcasts. AirPods are fantastic.
- arcticbull 7y agoI only picked the 315s since they're give or take the same price point as AirPods Pro and have infinitely better sound quality because they only do one thing.
- eric_cc 7y ago> Ok, 3.5" headphones are objectively: cheaper, simpler mechanically, more reliable, easier to use, easier to connect to different devices, never run out of battery or require charging, you can't lose 1/3 of them, and oh, yeah, they tend to sound better at the same price point. The utility value of AirPods or similar products is way higher. They are easier to use because they don’t need plugged in. They provide a superior user experience because you’re not tethered. They are easier to every-day-carry and thus always available. There will always be exceptions: audiophiles, etc. For most of us, it’s no contest.
- starsinspace 7y agoAnother disadvantage of AirPods (and most other wireless headphones): they're terrible for the environment. Builtin batteries which will wear out, glued shut so no way to replace the batteries, tied to a stack of radio/protocol/codecs which will be obsolete sooner or later. They are throw-away products. Just look at all the original 1st gen AirPods which now see their batteries failing - each one by itself is small, but given the sales numbers it's huge mountains of electronics trash. For the price of AirPods you can get a good pair of wired headphones which can last 20+ years. Replace tips or ear cushions as needed, on good headphones they are easily replaceable. No batteries or protocols or codecs to ever worry about.