3 ms·
> Ah, I thought—this is precisely where linear algebra can come to the rescue! Just like in CLEVER or PageRank, we can begin by giving everyone in the communit
by woodruffw 7y ago
> Ah, I thought—this is precisely where linear algebra can come to the rescue! Just like in CLEVER or PageRank, we can begin by giving everyone in the community an equal number of “morality starting credits.”
Two metaethical presuppositions stand out:
* That right and wrong (or right- and wrong-making action features) are discrete and quantifiable.
* That right and wrong (or ...) are expressible over communities as consequences to external individuals, rather than the properties of (potentially ineffectual!) actions themselves.
Written as counterclaims:
* We have no reason to believe that any right or wrong action corresponds to a particular number of morality credits, or that actions are independent (consider: most of us have some sort of intuition about bad things being excusable or forgivable if done only once).
* We have no reason to believe that the outcomes of our actions are what make them actually right. Consider the murderer who cooperates with the "moral" group to find ideal victims, but fails to kill them out of cowardice or incompetence -- a reasonable intuition to have would be that the murder is bad, despite external cooperation to the contrary.
- narag 7y agoThat right and wrong (or right- and wrong-making action features) are discrete and quantifiable. The thought that such a thing was possible is so scary. Please, let me act (mostly :) legally and keep your ideas of morality out of my life.
- nine_k 7y agoWhat is legal is very much influenced by what is considered moral. See: slavery, sex outside marriage, homosexuality, free speech, the very notion of murder (stand your ground vs excessive self-defence) and of crime in general (whether malicious intent is present). Sorry, laws of society are not laws of nature.
- narag 7y agoThere are two opposite approachs to establish rules for a society: imposition and negotiation. I prefer negotiation. Morals tend to work in absolutes, so morality gets into laws by negotiation because persons with different morals make a deal. When majority morals gets unimpemded into law, with no regard for minorities, the result is not pretty.
- threatofrain 7y agoNegotiation at the level of individual relationship to society and law is imposition with extra steps, but it is a desired sophistication of force. Sovereign citizens come to mind, talking about social contracts and moral law, but such things do not intermediate their relationship to government.