5 ms·
Eigenmorality (2014)
- peter_d_sherman 7y agoExcerpt: "Back then, I was extremely impressed by a research project called CLEVER, which one of my professors, Jon Kleinberg, had led while working at IBM Almaden. The idea was to use the link structure of the web itself to rank which web pages were most important, and therefore which ones should be returned first in a search query. Specifically, Kleinberg defined “hubs” as pages that linked to lots of “authorities,” and “authorities” as pages that were linked to by lots of “hubs.” At first glance, this definition seems hopelessly circular, but Kleinberg observed that one can break the circularity by just treating the World Wide Web as a giant directed graph, and doing some linear algebra on its adjacency matrix."
- amznthrowaway5 7y ago(2014) old discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7925375 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7925375
- dang 7y agoAlso 2015: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9378741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9378741
- kragen 7y agoBecause the Eigenmoses matrix contains negative values, the Perron–Frobenius theorem does not apply, and so there is no unique largest eigenvalue, necessarily. This can be observed in the form of holy wars. Moreover, I think we can construct real niceness matrices none of whose eigenvalues are real.
- edflsafoiewq 7y ago> A moral person is someone who cooperates with other moral people, and who refuses to cooperate with immoral people. One immediate property of this is it is too symmetric: assuming "honor amoung thieves" (immoral people cooperate with immoral people and refuse to cooperate with moral people), it is unchanged under interchange of "moral" and "immoral". That is, it can't tell you whether it's calling good "moral" or evil "moral". Anyway, the circular definition I'm interested in is Sausserian structuralism: the meaning of a sign is determined by its place in a system of signs. I suppose in linguistics the article's construction then leads to eigenwords, but I am skeptical that eigenwords actually advance our understanding of semantics. I'm not as optimistic about the power of this construction to advance our epistemology as the author.
- pickdenis 7y agoI think it's interesting because we don't assume "honor among thieves". Otherwise there's no useful way to distinguish morality from immorality. "x cooperates with y" and "y is moral" shouldn't imply "x is moral".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- daveguy 7y agoThat, or z coerced x and x's cooperation with y has no direct indication of their morality.
- nine_k 7y agoTo me, there is a clear indicator: human suffering. A group that strives to induce suffering on the outgroup, or on uwilling members of ingroup, are "bad guys". A group that strives to limit and reduce suffering, for the ingroup, outgroup, or both, are "good guys", as long they don't match the previous definition. Corollary: "good guys" normally stay away from aggression.
- Joker_vD 7y agoYou probably need to add "increase human happiness" or something along those lines, because otherwise the group of "let's painlessly euthanize all the other humans first, and then ourselves" guys are trivially "good guys" — they monotonically reduce the human suffering to zero.
- nine_k 7y agoIn Buddhism, human existence is a source of inevitable suffering. The only way out is to (eventually) reduce your karma to nothing, and to not be born again. The difference from your euthanizing sect is that nobody can be forced to follow this path (not just morally, but also technically).
- woodruffw 7y ago> Ah, I thought—this is precisely where linear algebra can come to the rescue! Just like in CLEVER or PageRank, we can begin by giving everyone in the community an equal number of “morality starting credits.” Two metaethical presuppositions stand out: * That right and wrong (or right- and wrong-making action features) are discrete and quantifiable. * That right and wrong (or ...) are expressible over communities as consequences to external individuals, rather than the properties of (potentially ineffectual!) actions themselves. Written as counterclaims: * We have no reason to believe that any right or wrong action corresponds to a particular number of morality credits, or that actions are independent (consider: most of us have some sort of intuition about bad things being excusable or forgivable if done only once). * We have no reason to believe that the outcomes of our actions are what make them actually right. Consider the murderer who cooperates with the "moral" group to find ideal victims, but fails to kill them out of cowardice or incompetence -- a reasonable intuition to have would be that the murder is bad, despite external cooperation to the contrary.
- narag 7y agoThat right and wrong (or right- and wrong-making action features) are discrete and quantifiable. The thought that such a thing was possible is so scary. Please, let me act (mostly :) legally and keep your ideas of morality out of my life.
- nine_k 7y agoWhat is legal is very much influenced by what is considered moral. See: slavery, sex outside marriage, homosexuality, free speech, the very notion of murder (stand your ground vs excessive self-defence) and of crime in general (whether malicious intent is present). Sorry, laws of society are not laws of nature.
- narag 7y agoThere are two opposite approachs to establish rules for a society: imposition and negotiation. I prefer negotiation. Morals tend to work in absolutes, so morality gets into laws by negotiation because persons with different morals make a deal. When majority morals gets unimpemded into law, with no regard for minorities, the result is not pretty.
- fyp 7y agoAre there still ongoing iterated prisoner's dilemma tournaments that we can submit code to online? The idea that you can submit "code of ethics" to duke it out in a simulated environment is pretty fascinating.
- gfodor 7y agoInteresting how multiple people can have the same idea — about 10 years ago I was working on the problem of having people on mechanical Turk label terms with meanings, and determined that applying page rank to the connected graph of nodes (where nodes where turkers, and edges were agreements in labeling) would allow me to derive a trust metric for each agent, allowing me to discard noise/bots easily from the dataset.
- marmaduke 7y ago> The players are bots, which do whatever their code tells them to do. Interesting dualism (bot & code vs bot===code) which sums up current philosophy of mind despite best efforts of neuroscience
- swagasaurus-rex 7y agoEigenmoses has negative values, Eigenjesus is clamped to 0. What about a leaky RELU like function? Cooperation is noted and rewarded, but uncooperative behavior is given some benefit of doubt - to a point.