4 ms·
I'm interested in art and culture. Here's my favourite piece of art of all time, the Artemission bronze: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemision_Bronze https
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
I'm interested in art and culture.
Here's my favourite piece of art of all time, the Artemission bronze:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemision_Bronze https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemision_Bronze
I guess, if you look at it from the wrong angle it looks just like a dude with
his feet planted apart, like he's about to take a shit. But, look closely and
you see that he's in full motion. His right leg is twisting behind his body.
The heel is raised and the toes are pushing down hard to put the full strength
of his body behind the throw. His left leg is pivoting on its heel. The toes
are pulled back as he turns his torso. He is leaning back, slightly to add his
weight to the power of his muscles. His left hand is extended in front of him,
so that he can swing it around like a pendulum, and add momentum to the throw.
He is throwing a weapon- and dancing at the same time.
This is a bronze statue so it was made to stand on its own two legs, without
any props to keep it upright. That is the biggest shock of all. A living,
breathing man would keep himself upright in the middle of this whirling move
by pulling on his mucles to maintain balance. And yet, here's a lifeless chunk
of bronze that has caught this man in the middle of all this pulling and
twisting and pushing, and dancing- and it's standing upright, balanced an
unfalling.
The artists who created this piece must have spent hours upon hours, days upon
days, studying the human form. They must have sat at the palaistra (the
public gym) observing the young men of Athens competing in javelin-throwing
for ages. Until they learned how the human body comes together, how it moves,
how it balances itself; how it _works_. Then they went off and transferred
this knowledge into bronze. And now, thousands of years later, any human can
look at the bronze and see what they learned.
This is what makes humans, human. To be able to look at the world and know,
and learn, and then put this knowledge into a form that can reach through time
and speak to other humans, and communicate this knowledge. To touch another
human's heart and mind through time and space, even after you're long gone. To
leave something behind that says "I lived, I learned, I created".
So, yeah, I see the value in art.
But modern art, like Jackson Pollock, that's a steaming hot pile of shit that
means nothing. There is no skill in it. There is no knowledge. No study. No
insight. There is no thought or emotion. There is just the cold hard glint of
gold in the eye of the so-called artist and those who sell his garbage on as
art to people who only understand the value of money, and have no other value
in life than money.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoI see Pollock-like depth visuals every time I am incredibly hungover. So given the context I had always associated them with this deep, wisely accepted sadness which comes after realising your own mortality and limitations. It's such an engineer's opinion, that life somehow owes you a clearly-defined meaning and forms.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoCheers, I'll take that as a compliment. Before I studied computer science, in another life as they say, I studied art. I took history of art courses and I was taught the official explanation for Pollock's work, that it's really a study of human motion. I bring up the Artemission bronze partly as a counterpoint. _That_ is a study of human motion. Not what Pollock did. There is real knowledge and understanding of the world that we can acquire. Obviously not for everything. Obviously the world doesn't "owe" us anything. But we can study, and work, and learn what there is to learn. Pollock did none of that. He just moved his arms around and pretended to do it, like a magician without magic, like a conductor without an orchestra. Edit: it is Pollock's work that is cynical (referring to what the GP said). Its premise is that nothing is really worth it. That you don't get anything out of working hard to try and understand. So embrace your limitations and wallow in the cheap and effortless, because you can never do better than that. Well, that's -sorry for the easy point but- bollocks. You can do much better than that. People have done much better than that for thousands of years.
- heavenlyblue 7y ago>> So embrace your limitations and wallow in the cheap and effortless, because you can never do better than that. That’s not what I said. I said this is what kind of feelings it makes me remember. It doesn’t mean I think that life has to be cheap and effortless per se. Yet I would appreciate art that reminds me of these feelings? You are your typical art academician who having studied art now thinks they know better than others. I don’t think you do. Did you go for computer science because it pays better? So who’s truly cynical here now? I went for computer science because I was good at it since the age of 11. It’s my passion and I have a sense of respect for people who earned their name in other industries, even if they did so not exactly through the most straightforward methods. You may say it’s bullshit. But so is Steve Jobs? After all, he died because he didn’t do chemo at the right time, instead going for yoga.