3 ms·
Rail equipment is all ancient and highly redundant for both uptime and safety. Yet the actual system reliability and safety doesn't seem great. Signal outages
by londons_explore 7y ago
Rail equipment is all ancient and highly redundant for both uptime and safety.
Yet the actual system reliability and safety doesn't seem great. Signal outages happen nearly every day in the UK, and delay tens of thousands of passengers. Safety failures in signalling systems kill on average a few people per year.
How about a modern system, built with JavaScript-de-jure, running over 4G and WiFi, consumer GPS, "Download train-control from the app store", running on tablets or the train drivers BYOD phone, etc. How would it work out for safety/reliability?
I suspect counterintuitively it would work out much better. Simple cheap portable devices means a bunch of spares can be around always. "Phone battery dead? No worries, there's a tablet I can control the train from too". No WiFi? It also works with 4G or Bluetooth. Server down? It has a Peer connection backup. Hackers broke in? The system has safety logic built in to every device, and uses a consensus system so a few rogue systems can't crash trains. Power supply broken? We have 24 hours of battery, longer if I turn the brightness down.
- bschwindHN 7y ago> How about a modern system, built with JavaScript-de-jure No thank you.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoimport { train } from 'lodash';
- thinkingemote 7y agoOh my sweet summer silicon valley child! We should disrupt every safety equipment and process everywhere!
- pergadad 7y agoBetter 1000 failures than one deadly accident. These systems are built in basic and redundant ways for a reason. See also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12071240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12071240
- seanparsons 7y agoNot sure about daily signal failures, even when I commuted daily it wasn't near that bad. The idea of powering such a safety oriented system with JavaScript quite literally terrifies me, I'd expect it to be about 30 minutes before two trains collided.
- Smaug123 7y agoAside: I think you might mean "Javascript-du-jour"? "De jure" (pronounced roughly "day jooray") means basically "legally speaking, but probably not practically speaking", the dual of "de facto". "Du jour" (pronounced roughly "doo zhoor") means "of the day", "the new thing", "the current fad".
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIf this was satire it would be on point.
- Nextgrid 7y agoI'm sure this is sarcasm but I'll play along: can't wait for the day the country's rail infrastructure stops working because someone pulled a package from NPM.