3 ms·
> Those who feel that lgbt people _do_ have these rights will obviously think those who act against those rights are crucially defined by that opposition. I do
by rayiner 7y ago
> Those who feel that lgbt people _do_ have these rights will obviously think those who act against those rights are crucially defined by that opposition.
I don’t think that’s obvious at all. To use a different example, I think people shouldn’t be discriminated against based on their skin color. (This is maybe self serving based on the fact that I’m a brown guy.) But I’m not going to even bother to read an obituary for Bill Shockley or James Watson that starts with a discussion of their racist views rather than their science. It’s fine to add it somewhere below the fold, but to make it the central theme (as the obituary in question did with Monson) would be bad journalism and leave the reader ignorant about the historical significant of the men.
- TomMckenny 7y agoWatson's bigotry was not a key feature of his legacy. It was confined to some comments that would hardly directly impact anyone. And he resigned after it. Contrasted with his discoveries that will benefit all humanity forever. To a reasonable person, this is obviously more defining than his ineffectual coarse statements at the end of his career. Conversely, Monson was the leader of a relatively small religious group which he worked to benefit in roughly the standard manner. But he also used his considerable power to directly lobby and negatively affect thousands of people far outside his own religion. He certainly did not resign over this but worked continuously and unapologetic. So as you say, it'd be pretty ridiculous to portray Watson's core legacy was bigotry. But clearly reasonable people can disagree about Monson's legacy. Especially those who were directly affected. Rather than a scientist, I think a better comparison would be other religious or maybe political leaders. Elsewhere I point out complaints about Jefferson Davis' historic portrayal. Another might be Saint Louis of France. Or Pope Gregory VII, reformer and which hunter. (For that matter even the city of Salem Mass is still defined by its lunacy 300 years ago.) Trump's obituary will either list the impeachment first or not, either at length or not. Either way someone will _call_ it biased but that doesn't mean it is.